Can you get the Black Eye Orb if you kill Lautrec early?

[gonzo]

Which I did.. to save Anastacia.

So, can you?

[Fex0]

No, you only get it if you let Lautrec kill her and it will sit at her corpse

[gonzo]

thaaaaaanks!

[Undisclosed]

That would make no sense.

[Nahkuri]

That would be a bit pointless, wouldn't it? I mean, the only use for the orb is to invade Lautrec.

[Shiro]

Is there really even a point to that quest? Seems to me you only get a copy of her clothes for all that effort.

[Husk720]

Originally posted by Shiro:

Is there really even a point to that quest? Seems to me you only get a copy of her clothes for all that effort.

Plus Lautrec armor and ability to restore Anastasia`s tongue.

[Big McHugeLarge]

Or not, and keep her soul all for yourself.

[Shiro]

Originally posted by Husk720:

Originally posted by Shiro:

Is there really even a point to that quest? Seems to me you only get a copy of her clothes for all that effort.

Plus Lautrec armor and ability to restore Anastasia`s tongue.

Okay, fair enough on his armor, but all she says is "Don't talk to me". Unless restoring her tongue is required for getting her to kindle the bonfire to full.

[Husk720]

"After you complete "The Murderer" questline (see below), if you speak to her after offering a Lord Soul or Bequeathed Lord Soul Shard to the Lordvessel, she will kindle the Firelink Shrine bonfire to max, giving you 20 Estus Flask charges when you rest at it."
Right from Wiki.