Ds1 prepare to die edition, the best "Souldborne up to date"

[Yu Ryujin]

Still unbeatable, this game is really something that will never die.

[NightmareGats]

The only Dark Souls game

[Sealer Moon]

Originally posted by Yu Ryujin:

Still unbeatable

will issue

it's nice to see that despite their attempts at killing it, PTDE is so incredibly good that it still has several hundred people playing it

[causality]

PTDE has better lighting. Remastered just looks so. . . plastic, if that makes that any sense.

[J.G.C.G.]

I just had this one from when it first dropped and I never opened the game until this week

[hone]

Originally posted by J.G.C.G.:

I just had this one from when it first dropped and I never opened the game until this week

Why you were waiting for so long?

[J.G.C.G.]

Why is it unbearable (genuine question).

[J.G.C.G.]

Originally posted by J.G.C.G.:

Why is it unbearable (genuine question).

Beatable*

[Mini]

Still unbeatable is crazy. I’ve beaten DS1 at least 5 separate times.

[Leither]

I do agree. Love the others, However, DS1 is just Special.

[spiric0m]

Every day I crave that sweet Games for Windows Live ragemail... Actually, I'm even nostalgic for the "Summoning failed" message 3 times in a row.

[Brecor]

I think his 'unbeatable' means no other DS version can beat it, not that the game is actually impossible to beat.

[Gypruzz]

Nah.
DeS has always been better.
BB is several times better.
And now, there's ER that's basically DaS1 but open world. Again, several times better.
Well, at least you can say it's the best game outta the Dark Souls trilogy.

[capercaillie]

the original des was kinda mid what are you talking about, this is just a refined game

[causality]

Bloodborne on PC now.

[Gypruzz]

Originally posted by isopropyl:

the original des was kinda mid what are you talking about, this is just a refined game

For you, maybe. During the first year when it was only available on PS3, and basically the only people knowing about DaS1 were DeS players, this game was only barely-warmly received, because it lacked "that something" that only DeS had. The game became big much later, when even the people who never played DeS discovered it.
Of course people who played DeS after DaS1 usually won't appreciate DeS, exactly the same as people who played DaS3 before DaS1, none of them usually consider DaS1 better than 3...
And more recently, people who played ER without playing any FS games before, almost none of them end up liking the previous FS games, or at least, not more than ER.
It's only a matter of which FS game was your first.