Should I give Ciaran Artorias's soul?

[Mike]

If I kill her I get the same rewards right?

[LarsenB]

Don't you dare!!
.
.
.
.
(anyway, yes, same weapons + the armor set....)

[Mike]

Originally posted by LarsenB:

Don't you dare!!
.
.
.
.
(anyway, yes, same weapons + the armor set....)

Is there anything bad that will happen if I kill her?

[AnKalameet]

If you give her the soul, you receive the tracers and that's it. Only by killing her do you receive the armor.

[LarsenB]

Originally posted by TheDankSoul:

Is there anything bad that will happen if I kill her?

Gameplay-wise, no.

[Mike]

When I came back here she was gone so I reloaded a backup I had.