Knight's honor achievement

[Cow]

I'm trying to get this achievement and I have every weapon, but I still dont have it, do I need a copy of every weapon unupgraded for it to work? If so how would I unupgrade a boss wep?

[Cow]

引用自 5thbrother：

Hmm did you get all 3 weapons from Sif soul ?? and all tail weapons ??

Drake Sword
Dragon King Greataxe
Moonlight Greatsword
Priscilla's dagger
Gargoyle Tail Axe

I have both artorias shields and swords, and tail weps yeah

[Jamchow]

ALL Weapons must be on the same character.

--Weapons ascended from Boss Souls--
This requires a certain type of regular weapon, upgraded to 10+, and the Soul of a defeated Boss. The Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo will ascend the weapon and soul for 5000 souls. Any properties, stats or movesets of the previous weapon will be replaced when forged into a Boss Soul weapon, so it is usually a good idea to use something cheap or easily obtained when creating them. Most Boss souls are used to create two different weapons, and the Soul of Sif is used for three, so several NG+s will be needed to acquire all Boss Soul weapons.

Chaos Blade :
Chaos Blade - You must ascend a +10 Katana and the soul of Quelaag. (An Uchigatana can be purchased for 5000 souls from Shiva of the East in Blighttown, providing you are a member of the Forest Covenant)
--Compatible Weapons--

Washing Pole
Iaito
Uchigatana

Crystal Ring Shield:
Crystal Ring Shield - Ascend a +10 shield or buckler, and the soul of The Moonlight Butterfly. Practically any shield can be used.
--Compatible Shields--

Plank Shield
Small Leather Shield
Leather Shield
Target Shield
Buckler
Cracked Round Shield
Red & White Round Shield
Warrior's Round Shield
Heater Shield
Knight Shield
Tower Kite Shield
Grass Crest Shield
Hollow Soldier Shield
Balder Shield
Iron Round Shield
Spider Shield
Spiked Shield
Pierce Shield
Sunlight Shield
Caduceus Kite Shield
Gargoyle's Shield
Eagle Shield
Wooden Shield
Large Leather Shield
Eagle Shield
Tower Shield
Giant Shield
Bonewheel Shield
Effigy Shield
Sanctus/Bloodshield
Black Iron Greatshield

Darkmoon Bow:
Darkmoon Bow - Ascend any +10 Bow, and the soul of Gwyndolin.
--Compatible Weapons--

Short Bow
Composite Bow
Longbow
Black Bow of Pharis

Dragon Bone Fist:
Dragon Bone Fist - Ascend any +10 Cestus or Claw, and the core of the Iron Golem.
--Compatible Weapons--

Cestus
Claw

Dragonslayer Spear:
Dragonslayer Spear - Ascend any +10 Spear or Rapier, and the soul of Ornstein.
--Compatible Weapons--

Mail Breaker
Estoc
Rapier
Ricard's Rapier
Spear
Winged Spear
Partizan
Pike

Golem Axe:
Golem Axe - Ascend any +10 Axe, and the core of the Iron Golem.
--Compatible Weapons--

Hand Axe
Demon's Greataxe
Greataxe
Gargoyle Tail Axe
Butcher Knife
Battle Axe

Great lord Greatsword:
Great Lord Greatsword - Ascend a +10 dagger, sword or greatsword, and the soul of Gwyn, The Lord of Cinder.
--Compatible Weapons--

Dagger
Parrying Dagger
Bandit's Knife
Demon Great Machete
Greatsword
Zweihander
Flamberge
Man-Serpent Greatsword
Claymore
Bastard Sword
Darksword
Barbed Straight Sword
Sunlight Straight Sword
Balder Side Sword
Broadsword
Longsword
Shortsword

Great Shield of Artorias:
Greatshield of Artorias - Ascend a +10 shield or buckler and the soul of Sif, The Great Grey Wolf.
--Com patible Shields--

Plank Shield
Small Leather Shield
Leather Shield
Target Shield
Buckler
Cracked Round Shield
Red & White Round Shield
Warrior's Round Shield
Heater Shield
Knight Shield
Tower Kite Shield
Grass Crest Shield
Hollow Soldier Shield
Balder Shield
Iron Round Shield
Spider Shield
Spiked Shield
Pierce Shield
Sunlight Shield
Caduceus Kite Shield
Gargoyle's Shield
Eagle Shield
Wooden Shield
Large Leather Shield
Eagle Shield
Tower Shield
Giant Shield
Bonewheel Shield
Effigy Shield
Sanctus/Bloodshield
Black Iron Greatshield

Greatsword of Artorias:
Greatsword of Artorias (cursed) - THIS IS CURSED - You must Ascend a +10 Dagger, Sword or Greatsword, with the soul of Sif, The Great Gray Wolf. Using these weapons for ascension will give you the cursed version of the Greatsword of Artorias. The name will not indicate any difference between the true and cursed variant, but the cursed version has a stat requirement of 18 for Faith and Intelligence.
--Compatible Weapons--

Dagger
Parrying Dagger
Bandit's Knife
Greatsword
Zweihander
Flamberge
Man-Serpent Greatsword
Claymore
Darksword
Sunlight Straight Sword
Balder Side Sword
Broadsword
Longsword
Shortsword

(True) Greatsword of Artorias:
True Greatsword of Artorias - THIS IS NOT CURSED - You must ascend a +10 Broken sword, and the soul of Sif, The Great Gray Wolf. Basic Zombies or the Defiled in Blighttown will usually drop broken swords. The name will not indicate it is the true version of the greatsword, but it has higher stat requirements of 20 for faith and intelligence.
--Compatible Weapons--

Broken Straight Sword
Straight Sword Hilt

Lifehunt Scythe:
Lifehunt Scythe - Ascend any +10 Halberd, Scythe or Whip, and the soul of Priscilla, the Half Breed. Unlike other Boss Souls, Priscilla's soul only ascends one weapon.
--Compatible Weapons--

Halberd
Lucerne
Scythe
Gargoyle's Halberd
Great Scythe
Whip
Notched Whip

Moonlight Butterfly Horn:
Moonlight Butterfly Horn - Ascend any +10 Spear or Rapier, and the soul of the Moonlight Butterfly.
--Compatible Weapons--

Mail Breaker
Estoc
Rapier
Ricard's Rapier
Spear
Winged Spear
Pike

Quelaag's Furysword:
Quelaag's Furysword - Ascend a +10 Curved Sword, and the soul of Quelaag. A scimatar is a good choice.
--Compatible Weapons--

Painting Guardian Sword
Murakumo
Server
Shotel
Scimitar
Falchion

Smough's Hammer:
Smough's Hammer - Ascend a +10 "Hammer" and the soul of Smough.
--Compatible Weapons--

Club
Mace
Morning Star
Warpick
Pickaxe
Reinforced Club
Great Club
Demon's Great Hammer
Large Club

Tin Darkmoon Catalyst:
Tin Darkmoon Catalyst - Ascend any Catalyst and the soul of Gwyndolin, The Darkmoon God. Ascension of the original catalyst is not needed, as it cannot be done. The sorcerer's catalyst is the best choice for ascension.
--Compatible Weapons--

Oolacile Ivory Catalyst
Logan's Catalyst
Tin Banishment Catalyst
Sorcerer's Catalyst
Beatrice's Catalyst

--Weapons or Shields dropped by enemies--

Black Knight Greataxe:
Black Knight Greataxe - Random drop from Axe-wielding Black knights.

Black knight Greatsword:
Black Knight Greatsword - Random drop from Greatsword-wielding Black Knights.

Black Knight Halberd:
Black Knight Halberd - Random drop from Halberd-wielding Black Knights.

Black Knight Shield:
Black Knight Shield - Random drop from any Black Knight.

Black Knight Sword:
Black Knight Sword - Random drop from any Sword-Wielding Black Knight.

Channeler's Trident:*
Channeler's Trident - Rare random drop from Channelers. Three respawning channelers can be found in The Duke's Archives. (Thanks to Waggonforce for confirming * weapons)

Crest Shield:
Crest Shield - Found in the Undead Asylum (revisited). Acquired as drop from the now hollow Oscar who first gave you the Estus Flask.

Crescent Axe:*
Crescent Axe - Acquired by killing Patches, but it can be purchased from him when he moves to Firelink Shrine.

Demon's Spear:
Demon's Spear - Rare Random drop from the Bat Wing Demons in Anor Londo (whilst sunlit). Can also be purchased from Shiva of the East in Blighttown, if you are a member of the Forest Hunter's Covenant.

Giant's Halberd:*
Giant's Halberd - Rare random drop from the giant gold knights in Anor Londo (whilst sunlit). It can more easily be purchased from the Giant Blacksmith at any time for 5000 souls.

Grant:
Grant - Acquired by killing NPC invader Paladin Leeroy. He will invade you in The Tomb of Giants just before Nito's domain, down near the area that overlooks the distant Ash Lake.

Sanctus:
Sanctus - Acquired by killing NPC invader Paladin Leeroy. He will invade you in The Tomb of Giants just before Nito's domain, down near the area that overlooks the distant Ash Lake.

Silver Knight Shield:
Silver Knight Shield - Anor Londo. Random drop from any Silver Knight.

Silver Knight Spear:
Silver Knight Spear - Anor Londo. Random drop from Spear-wielding Silver Knights.

Silver Knight Straight Sword:
Silver Knight Straight Sword - Anor Londo.Random drop from Sword-wielding Silver Knights.

Stone Greatshield
Stone Greatshield - Darkroot Garden. Random drop from the Stone Knights.

Stone Greatsword
Stone Greatsword - Darkroot Garden. Rare random drop from the Stone Knights. Can more easily be purchased from Shiva of the East, if you are a member of the Forest Covenant.


--Weapons found as treasure--

Astora's Straight Sword:
Astora's Straight Sword - Acquired from a corpse in Valley of Drakes, next to the Undead Dragon.

Black Iron Greatshield:
Black Iron Greatshield - Acquired from a corpse in Anor Londo to the left of the entrance to the Painted World of Ariamis.

Bloodshield:
Bloodshield - Painted World. Found on the bridge after the Undead Dragon Fight.

Dragon Crest Shield:
Dragon Crest Shield - Acquired from a corpse in Valley of Drakes, next to the Undead Dragon.

Dragon Tooth:
Dragon Tooth - Anor Londo. Found in a treasure chest alongside other chests containing Havel's Equipment, located behind a hidden wall in a Fireplace.

Dragonslayer Greatbow:
Dragonslayer Greatbow - Anor Londo. When you reach the Giant Blacksmith, go up some straight stairs. To the right, you will find some big windows with one broken. Exit the window heading right, and you will see a corpse with the bow.

Effigy Shield:
Effigy Shield - Tomb of Giants.

Havel's Greatshield:
Havel's Greatshield - Anor Londo. Found in a treasure chest alongside other chests containing Havel's Equipment, located behind a hidden wall in a Fireplace.

Velka's Rapier:
Velka's Rapier - Can found on a corpse in the Painted World of Aramis.


--Weapons or Shields acquired from covenants--

Dark Hand:
Dark Hand - Given as a gift when joining Darkwraith Covenant. (Can also be obtained as a drop from the NPC Darkwraiths in New Londo Ruins)

Dragon Greatsword:
Dragon Greatsword - Cut the tail off of the Ancient Dragon in Ash Lake. As long as you don't attack the body, this will not anger the dragon or break the covenant.


-- Weapons acquired from cutting off boss tails--

Drake Sword:
Drake Sword - Undead Burg. Use arrows to shoot the tail of the Red Drake, or Bridge Wyvern, from underneath the bridge. It can also be cut off from on top of the bridge, if the Bridge Wyvern has landed to attack you.

Dragon King Greataxe
Dragon King Greataxe - The Depths. Cut off the tail of the Gaping Dragon.

Moonlight Greatsword:
Moonlight Greatsword - Crystal Cave. Cut off the tail of Seath The Scaleless, once the immortality crystal has been broken. (Seath's tail cannot be cut off in your first encounter)

Priscilla's Dagger:
Priscilla's Dagger - Painted World of Aramis. Cut off the tail of Priscilla - this can be difficult to do considering her ability to turn invisible, so consider careful strikes or weak weapons. Tag her with a throwing knife so you can track her while invisible. use weak weapons or the Force spell to break her poise, then go for her tail.
I think it´s missing the weapon that you can build using the tail of the gargoyle´s just before to ring the Bell in the tower...

**The FuturePress guide is wrong when it says that you need the ghost blade and the titanite catch pole. You do not need either. Also, it says you can use different characters to acquire the boss soul weapons without having to do NG+. This appears to be untrue. As of now, I can say that I had the Dragonking Greataxe on a lower level less used character and all of the other weapons on my main. I did not get the achievement until I got the Dragonking Greataxe on my main. All weapons must be on the same character.

Sauce: http://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Knight's+Honor+Achievement+Guide

[Cow]

I used this list

[Dootslayer]

I heard the achievement can be glitchy on consoles, but seems like the pc port is suffering from that too. Try dropping and picking up weapons randomly, especially tail and boss weapons, maybe it will fix it.

[Cow]

引用自 Carlos Mendez：

I heard the achievement can be glitchy on consoles, but seems like the pc port is suffering from that too. Try dropping and picking up weapons randomly, especially tail and boss weapons, maybe it will fix it.

I'll try it, ty