DARK SOULS™: Prepare To Die Edition

DARK SOULS™: Prepare To Die Edition

View Stats:
PaulieZero Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:30pm
Your Opinion: Boss Weapons
I want to hear from you Dark Souls veterans on which boss weapon is your favorite, and why!

I have only ever used the Greatsword of Artorias. I liked it against wraiths and such, but it was quite slow and difficult to use against bosses, in my opinion.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
The Mask Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:35pm 
All of them are useful, except maybe Smough's... but my favourite?

I would say it's a toss between the Dragonslayer Spear and Quelaag's Fury Sword, I think.




If I had to pick just one, I'd pick the Dragonslayer Spear.
WhiteLezard Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:40pm 
My favorite is Gwyn's greatsword. Fast and hits like a truck.
Artorias' greatsword isn't a good weapon unless you have a high SL.
Last edited by WhiteLezard; Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:45pm
Heck Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:43pm 
obsidian greatsword
works with any build
PaulieZero Jan 19, 2017 @ 8:19pm 
Thanks. I am going to check them out.
•C Jan 19, 2017 @ 8:26pm 
Moonlight Butterfly Horn's fun on a Sorcery build. I like it as a weapon, even if it's kinda plain.

I also really like the Chaos Blade a lot, even if it's essentially a slightly better Uchigatana that hurts you, can't be buffed (normally), and has weird R2's.

Shoutouts to Darkmoon Bow, even if setting up a Faith/Dex build to use it properly is horrifically gimmicky. I could see it being useful in a co-op/support build, though. Use the bow, use moonlight arrows, and use the party heal spells...
r.linder Jan 19, 2017 @ 8:29pm 
Abyss Greatsword would be my first choice, because it's the overall best of Artorias' swords due to the fact that it only scales with STR and DEX, unlike the others which scale with all four stats. For lower level builds, this makes it much more useful. The two biggest downsides are that, like the other 2, it's slow to swing compared to other greatswords, and you can't bring out it's maximum potential without 10 humanity.

Quelaag's Furysword would be a much more useful weapon, as it's both fast, and hits pretty hard. It's probably the overall best boss weapon, at least in the greatswords category.
AnKalameet Jan 19, 2017 @ 8:35pm 
Originally posted by Escorve:
Abyss Greatsword would be my first choice, because it's the overall best of Artorias' swords due to the fact that it only scales with STR and DEX, unlike the others which scale with all four stats.
Fun fact, the Cursed GSoA doesn't actually scale to Int and Faith despite the listed C scaling.

The really useful boss weapons (that require boss souls to be made, so Obsidian Greatsword is excluded) are the Furysword, Chaos Blade, Golem Axe, and MLBH. The Lifehunt Scythe deserves some honorable mention, but considering that using it essentially either locks your shield into a relatively ♥♥♥♥♥♥ shield or locks your ring slot into a relatively ♥♥♥♥♥♥ ring... Of those, my favorite is probably the Furysword.
Last edited by AnKalameet; Jan 19, 2017 @ 8:39pm
MaximumEffort Jan 19, 2017 @ 9:30pm 
Artorias Greatsword and Quelags Fury sword.
Both are awesome, esp against bosses. Ironic :steammocking:
Iirc Quelag's Sword was fun to use. At the moment I'm using the Moonlight Butterfly Horn, jus cause it's got great reach and it's valuable against many enemy types.
DevonShire Jan 19, 2017 @ 9:57pm 
- Dragonslayer Spear. Best weapon to guard break (kicks drain a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ of stamina) and same range as Silver Knight Spear's (longest after Demon's Spear). Split damage, high stat requirements and a bit heavy.
- Quelaag's Furysword. Very good range and easy to ghost-strike with. It also requires very low investment (you're good with 20 dex) to actually do damage, even if it's split.
- Chaos Blade. It's the best weapon in the game. That's it.
- Golem Axe. Memes.
- Dragon Bonefist. Bad.
- Artoria's Greatswords. Bad moveset, slow, very high requirements, split damage, good backstab damage. Iirc, the only one which could worth it was the Abyss Greatsword (I don't remember why).
- Crystal Ring Shield. Bad.
- Moonlight Butterfly Horn. Pure magic damage, not very good range, decent R2s.
- Darkmoon Catalyst/Bow. Bad.
- Greatshield of Artorias. Pick the Eagle Shield and forget about this one.
- Great Lord Greatsword. Horrible R2s, very low stat investment to do important damage.
- Manus' Catalyst. Only good with very high level.
- Lifehunt Scythe. The autobleed factor makes it bad.
- Smough's Hammer. Very slow. Very heavy. Very expensive stat-wise. Very bad.


PaulieZero Jan 19, 2017 @ 10:04pm 
Much love for Quelaag's Furysword here. That will be next on my list!
The Mask Jan 19, 2017 @ 11:39pm 
Originally posted by soundonlyy:
Dragon Bonefist. Bad.

How dare you? The falcon punch is the best thing in this game. Especially as a dragon bro. The satisfaction after you deliver a blow like that to a person is over 9K.

Originally posted by soundonlyy:
- Artoria's Greatswords. Bad moveset, slow, very high requirements, split damage, good backstab damage.

Misspelled name. And this is a PvE sword. Your complaints are irrelevant.

Originally posted by soundonlyy:
- Crystal Ring Shield. Bad.

But amazing for a shield-only run.

Originally posted by soundonlyy:
- Moonlight Butterfly Horn. Pure magic damage, not very good range, decent R2s.

It actually has amazing range, and it's superb when used by a mage in PvP.


Originally posted by soundonlyy:
- Darkmoon Catalyst/Bow. Bad.

Except this is the best bow in the game.

Originally posted by soundonlyy:
- Lifehunt Scythe. The autobleed factor makes it bad.

Except that if you use moss, and you run into light armoured players, you can literally end a fight in 2 hits.




This is why they teach you in school that you should always answer the question. Get it?



Things are always relative due to perspective and experience.





^__^
nomoreblues Jan 19, 2017 @ 11:55pm 
Originally posted by The Mask:

...

"PVE class, move out!" jk

OP: I agree Furysword is altogether most effective and also kinda easy to get into but still very... ugly (only fashionable along with long hair barely covering delicate chest imho)

my favorites r Golems Axe and Lifehunt Scythe (I've yet to try these myself, know them only from facing them) seemingly being somewhat special AND serious

Last edited by nomoreblues; Jan 19, 2017 @ 11:59pm
ShinkuTear Jan 20, 2017 @ 1:38am 
Are we specifically talking about Boss Soul weapons? Or can stuff like Tail weapons count as well? Cause I love me some Priscilla's Dagger and Moonlight Greatsword :8bitheart:

Among the soul weapons, my fav is probly the Furysword, if only because I dislike the Chaos Blade selfharm, and at heart love quality builds and dislike a lot of the huge weapons, things like Golem axe, Smough hammer... Fury Sword is a fairly simple no nonsense weapon that I can actually use.
Last edited by ShinkuTear; Jan 20, 2017 @ 1:42am
MaenaZ Jan 20, 2017 @ 2:02am 
Going as listed on the wikidot :
- Abyss Greatsword has a heavy stat requirement, but if you're fine with that (I.E. planned to do some mini double-casting, or don't care about meta SL ranges), you could have some fun with it, although the moves are a tad too 'telegraphed' for PVP and you need a high humanity to bring out its full power.

- Chaos Blade : It's a katana in a Dark Souls game. Nuff said. I personally don't use katanas, but come on. It's a katana. In a Dark Souls game.

- Crystal Ring Shield : It's not a shield, it's an extra set of projectiles. I hear these specific projectiles used to mean something, but now they're somewhat useless.

- Darkmoon Bow : It's fairly cool.

- Dragon Bone Fist : I never actually used it. Fist weapons' lack of reach scares me.

- Dragonslayer Spear : It does have a somewhat heavy stat investment need, but it's one of the better spears for quality builds. If only it wasn't quite so heavy.

- Golem Axe : Heavy, but a decent weapon. Plus you get the memetic distance slash.

- Greatshield of Artorias : Do you like greatshields? Do you have 10 int and want to once, just once, block a lot of attacks without any stamina problem? Then it's very good. Otherwise, it's just good.

- Greatswords of Artorias : The movesets are bad, stat investment requirements are huge, and the 'return' bonuses aren't all that good. Check Abyss Greatsword instead. However, they can be usefulish in PVE.

- Great Lord Greatsword : It's a quality greatsword. That means it's good, especially if you're not a weapon buffing type.

- Lifehunt Scythe : If you're not feeling edgy enough with a katana.

- Manus Catalyst : I dislike having halved spell uses personally, but it's probably a better option for PVP?

- Moonlight Butterfly Horn : It's a spear. It deals purely one type of damage. Low stat requirements. Good for mages. About the only flaw is no counter damage bonus, but you can have fun with that weapon.

- Quelaag's Furysword : It's my personal favorite out of the bunch because fire is actually surprisingly useful in this game, its weight and requirements are not bad, and its double dex+humanity scaling really helps boosting it up. Make no mistake, this is not 'the' weapon, but you can find plenty of use for it.

- Smough's Hammer : Now, great hammer movesets *are* good in this game, but personally I find the stat requirements and weight too ridiculous to bother. Just grab a large/great club or Dragontooth instead.

- Tin Darkmoon Catalyst : It's good if you can spare the slots or are good at swapping. Primarily used to buff weapons when saving your Darkmoon Blade / Sunlight Blade for that someone special on Valentine's Day. Can also be used for Remedy/Resist Curse / Dark Sorceries.





Other Demon Titanite weapons :
- Gravelord Sword : I like it. Doesn't require a great stat investment, has a strong attack useful in narrow passageways, and inflicts toxic (which is automatically better than poison).

- Demon's Spear : It's a good spear for strength and quality builds early on, but its effectiveness in the very long range somewhat diminishes. Still finds it uses on elementally weak opponents.


Last edited by MaenaZ; Jan 20, 2017 @ 2:06am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jan 19, 2017 @ 7:30pm
Posts: 18