Quest question STRANGERS IN NIGHT decision

[Caine]

wow, i really cannot decide what to choose, i dunno if Haren is good but giving away goods without his ok isnt cool either, otherwise the elves seem to be on a good point too, how did you decide? i think i will first choose not to give the goods cause a contract is a contract and you dont know at this point about both sides.

[CyberHaggis]

I sold the goods to the elves

[Alex]

You should always choose whatever you feel is right. You can always do another playthrough and pick different choices.

[Late Shacka]

Yeah, the game doesn't really have "Good or Bad" choices, it's very grey. One choice you make will have good outcomes on one part and bad oucomes on the other. It's great, I love the fact that it's not so black and white. Plus, it really gives you a reason to replay this awesome game. Just do what you think is the best choice, you'll see good and bad things come out of it no matter what the choice is.

[Alex]

One thing I really liked about how the developers made the Witcher series is that you won't always know the immediate impact of your decisions. It'll be later in the game when you realize how much your decisions weigh on things.

[DecayWolf]

Spoilers ahead.

If you let them take your food supplies, coleman will die a soon you put your feet in inn, and you will lose some quests.
If you choose to not let them have it, they'll fight you, you'll can talk about the missing friend from zoltan with haren, and you will not be abled to use dwarf blacksmith until you make any mission for non humans

[yamahog01]

So can you follow a true "neutral path" in the game? I'm still in Chpt 2 I believe, were I have to decide on helping the elves or the Knights of the Rose. I want to do a fairly neutral path were I can do what I want but it seems I'll be missing some exp if I do that.

[Alex]

There is a 'Neutral/Witcher' path yes.

[Late Shacka]

Originally posted by yamahog01:

So can you follow a true "neutral path" in the game? I'm still in Chpt 2 I believe, were I have to decide on helping the elves or the Knights of the Rose. I want to do a fairly neutral path were I can do what I want but it seems I'll be missing some exp if I do that.

Yes, when you pick one side a little later it'll give you another chance to make different decisions and so on and more decisions will role from that, if you can do em' int he correct order (shouldn't be too hard) you'll stay neutral.

[Kie Mugen]

Originally posted by Alex:

You should always choose whatever you feel is right. You can always do another playthrough and pick different choices.

well here is a problem, I dont feel any is right and I still have to pick one to import saves in W2

[Obsidian Maximus]

Originally posted by Kie Mugen:

Originally posted by Alex:

You should always choose whatever you feel is right. You can always do another playthrough and pick different choices.

well here is a problem, I dont feel any is right and I still have to pick one to import saves in W2

hey which option did you choose?