Dungeons & Dragons Online®

Dungeons & Dragons Online®

I Cannot Remap the Controls
I have been a major fan of AD&D and The Elder Scrolls for decades. Since February I have been playing Neverwinter.

I thought I'd give DDO a try, and it is impossible to map the Left Mouse Button for Forward Movement. I cannot even look round by moving the mouse. The game is therefore unplayable for me; which is a shame.

Why on Earth have they done this? I have been playing home PC CRPGs since about 1993, and I always re-map the keys so it works like in Daggerfall:

where you look is where you go (move mouse left/right to face left/right, move forward/back to look up/down),
Left Mouse moves you forward,
Right Mouse Attacks with main weapon
Mouse Wheel interacts with objects and NPCs
whatever other keys for whatever other functions

This is a far better and more intuitive way of playing to me.

Anyone know if there is a Forum for the game company that produced this mess so I can post there and ask them to enable proper key bindings?

Otherwise I cannot play it and I am not prepared to learn a new method using WASD. It is a waste of my time and money. I rolled a Druid, but you have to buy it with 1495 points, so I had to turn him into a Cleric instead and I can't even play the game as he cannot look around or move forward.


Cheers!

< >
Mostrando 1-15 de 17 comentarios
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
I thought I'd give DDO a try, and it is impossible to map the Left Mouse Button for Forward Movement. I cannot even look round by moving the mouse. The game is therefore unplayable for me; which is a shame.
-.-
How hard did you try? Pressing T enables mouse look mode, where moving your mouse moves your view. Pressing and holding the RMB does the same,

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Anyone know if there is a Forum for the game company that produced this mess so I can post there and ask them to enable proper key bindings?
https://www.ddo.com/forums/forum.php
Not exactly hidden. Combined with your ignorance about Mouse Look Mode, I do have to wonder whether you actually bothered trying to look, or just expect everything spoonfed to you.

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Otherwise I cannot play it and I am not prepared to learn a new method using WASD. It is a waste of my time and money.
:summersun:
Última edición por Exothermically Eclectic; 14 AGO 2014 a las 5:02
gamingforfun 14 AGO 2014 a las 8:47 
Yes, the above information is correct. Many players play DDO enitrely in mouse view using 't.' It is also possible to re-map the keys associated with each button in game. You can submit a ticket to Turbine technical support here: http://support.turbine.com/ics/support/default.asp?deptID=24047&_referrer=https://www.google.com/
Doug 14 AGO 2014 a las 9:55 
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
I thought I'd give DDO a try, and it is impossible to map the Left Mouse Button for Forward Movement. I cannot even look round by moving the mouse. The game is therefore unplayable for me; which is a shame.

First, did you find the Key Mapping option in Settings at all? I believe <ESC> Options - Key Mapping is the path to get there.

You can indeed (with Default mappings) look around using the mouse. If you hold down RMB, you have that functionality. You also have the option to hit 'T' to enter mouselook mode and not have to hold a mousebutton at all. I personally find that limiting, but to each his own.

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Why on Earth have they done this? I have been playing home PC CRPGs since about 1993, and I always re-map the keys so it works like in Daggerfall:

where you look is where you go (move mouse left/right to face left/right, move forward/back to look up/down),
Left Mouse moves you forward,
Right Mouse Attacks with main weapon
Mouse Wheel interacts with objects and NPCs
whatever other keys for whatever other functions

This is a far better and more intuitive way of playing to me.

Obviously what is better is personal to each person in cases like this, which is why Key Mapping exists.
The mapping changes that will do as you want:

Change 'Attack' from 'Button 0' to 'Button 1'
Change 'DDO Classic Interact/Steer' from 'Button 1' to 'Button 0'
Change 'Action Interact' from <blank> (in my case: might not be default) to 'Button 3'

Note that there are a couple of Attack/Interact/Steer options, so this might not be the ideal combo, tho it certainly will work to enable what you seek.

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Anyone know if there is a Forum for the game company that produced this mess so I can post there and ask them to enable proper key bindings?

Go to www.ddo.com and select 'Community' then 'Forums' and sign in with your game ID.

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Otherwise I cannot play it and I am not prepared to learn a new method using WASD. It is a waste of my time and money. I rolled a Druid, but you have to buy it with 1495 points, so I had to turn him into a Cleric instead and I can't even play the game as he cannot look around or move forward.

You will need additional keys if you wish to 'slide' (i.e. move sideways without changing your aim point). Also, your key mapping suggests no backward key. That's what ASD do, even when using mouse for forward.

Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Cheers!

Really? Cheers?

I have taken pains to respond to this in a different tone than that in which it was posted. Rather than as an attack on DDO, might you next time try to phrase this as a 'How can I...?' or 'Does DDO allow...?' first, before assuming they've done it wrong?

I hope that this info will allow you to enjoy DDO. If you have further question, we'd be delighted to help.
Última edición por Doug; 14 AGO 2014 a las 10:02
Shadowblade001 14 AGO 2014 a las 10:26 
Thanks for all that. I think...

Of course I found how to map the keys or I would not have said that I cannot map FORWARD to LEFT MOUSE.

I found Mouse Look after posting, but I cannot map FORWARD to Left Mouse button as it is simply not allowed. I put in a ticket to support already. I was hoping for a quick and easy answer, but I get juvenile fan boy defence of the game and personal attacks instead. Attack the company? Where?

I CAN map FORWARD to Mouse Wheel Button, which is just plain stupid and difficult to use. But I cannot map it to Left Mouse Button.

Every other game I have played in the last 25 years has been able to so this. I don't understand why Warner Brothers decided on something different. And holding a button so you can look around? How whack is that? No wonder people use Mouse Look, which is the only intuitive and natural way to do it.

Neverwinter is down for maintenance in preparation for Module 4, so I wanted to spend the afternoon playing DDO, but I got as far as the cave and had to give up. Shame, really, as I much prefer 3.5E rules to NW's version of 4E and I would have bought 12 months of VIP membership so I could roll a Druid from the start.

Unfortunately, until they change the code so the LEFT MOUSE can be mapped to FORWARD motion, it is unplayable for me. So I'll pass.


Really? ASD are for left, right and back? Well DUUU-UUUHH! I wonder what I have been doing for the last 25 years, then?

How do I map FORWARD motion to the LEFT MOUSE Button?

YOU CAN'T. IT IS NOT ALLOWED.

And why is the Key Map Window so small? In Neverwinter, you can change the size like any Window in Windows, and see dozens of key functions instead of just a few. That way, you can more easily see if a key you want to use is already in use.

I had read that DODO was better then Neverwinter, but I have sadly seen no evidence of it so far.


Cheers!

~
Doug 14 AGO 2014 a las 10:57 
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Thanks for all that. I think...

Of course I found how to map the keys or I would not have said that I cannot map FORWARD to LEFT MOUSE.

I found Mouse Look after posting, but I cannot map FORWARD to Left Mouse button as it is simply not allowed. I put in a ticket to support already. I was hoping for a quick and easy answer, but I get juvenile fan boy defence of the game and personal attacks instead. Attack the company? Where?

I CAN map FORWARD to Mouse Wheel Button, which is just plain stupid and difficult to use. But I cannot map it to Left Mouse Button.

Every other game I have played in the last 25 years has been able to so this. I don't understand why Warner Brothers decided on something different. And holding a button so you can look around? How whack is that? No wonder people use Mouse Look, which is the only intuitive and natural way to do it.

Neverwinter is down for maintenance in preparation for Module 4, so I wanted to spend the afternoon playing DDO, but I got as far as the cave and had to give up. Shame, really, as I much prefer 3.5E rules to NW's version of 4E and I would have bought 12 months of VIP membership so I could roll a Druid from the start.

Unfortunately, until they change the code so the LEFT MOUSE can be mapped to FORWARD motion, it is unplayable for me. So I'll pass.


Really? ASD are for left, right and back? Well DUUU-UUUHH! I wonder what I have been doing for the last 25 years, then?

How do I map FORWARD motion to the LEFT MOUSE Button?

YOU CAN'T. IT IS NOT ALLOWED.

And why is the Key Map Window so small? In Neverwinter, you can change the size like any Window in Windows, and see dozens of key functions instead of just a few. That way, you can more easily see if a key you want to use is already in use.

I had read that DODO was better then Neverwinter, but I have sadly seen no evidence of it so far.


Cheers!

~

Hmm.. how to respond... I'll start with: Sorry, but you were NOT clear that you had found the mapping options and that mapping Forward to LMB was unsupported by the game. The 'I cannot even look around by moving the mouse' strongly suggested you had not found the Key Mapping, as there are several options there that allow that. Clearly I misunderstood or you were unspecific.

Second, when you said 'I am not prepared to learn a new method using WASD', it strongly suggested that you had some other method in mind for the ASD part or simply hadn't considered it at all.

Third, not sure how my posting how to do what you requested amounted to 'juvenile fanboy defense of the game'. If you can't see that the tone of your original posting was argumentative and critical rather than open and inquisitive, I'll never convince you that calling it an 'attack on DDO' was justified (which, btw, is the game, not the company). Maybe I am 'juvenile' in thinking that the first response to a problem should assume a positive outcome is possible. If so, I think I'll stay that way.

In short, I do regret that your specific desired keymapping isn't supported by DDO. Frankly, with all the flexibility there, I hadn't even imagined such a thing was possible. But definitely my bad that I looked at the screen but didn't actually attempt to make the changes I suggested to test their validity. My only defense is that I didn't want to mess up my own key mappings (which are far from default). Still.. I DID take the time to look.. with no expected reward other than the good feeling I get from helping people.

Regarding possible solutions:

Have you considered an external mouse mapping software? Swapping left and right mouse buttons can be done in Windows itself, last I checked. The biggest pain would be having to swap back after playing. 3rd party software like what comes with most Logitech mice (and can probably be downloaded free) will attach itself to the game and make the swap on launch and undo it on exit. If that worked, it would be the least inconvenient workaround until and unless DDO changes the prohibition on the mapping you seek. (This does, of course, assume that DDO's mapping won't simply override the external one. Cross your fingers.)



Última edición por Doug; 14 AGO 2014 a las 11:08
Doug 14 AGO 2014 a las 10:59 
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:

And why is the Key Map Window so small? In Neverwinter, you can change the size like any Window in Windows, and see dozens of key functions instead of just a few. That way, you can more easily see if a key you want to use is already in use.
~

I don't know why some features of DDO are not resizable, but it IS a bit older than a lot of its competition. The reason it's so small is because it's not resizable and has to fit on every screen resolution that might play the game... fwiw.
Shadowblade001 14 AGO 2014 a las 15:23 
They also allowed mouse buttons to be re-mapped. Same with Skyrim.
Doug 14 AGO 2014 a las 16:54 
Everyone is entitled to the control system that works best for them. That's why key mapping exists. I personally hate WASD. It feels awkward and limiting to a touch-typist. Any game that allows, I map those functions 1 key right (ESDF) so that my fingers can rest on the home row as they do for typing. That way, when I play without looking, I have the tiny bump on the F key to demonstrate I have my fingers in the right places. Also, since I already have learned the 'reaches' from those keys to things like <TAB> and <ESC> and <SHIFT> it both works more naturally and allows me another set of 4 keys within the reach of my left hand's fingers. 'Course, the more dependent I get on it, the more frustrating it is to play anything that won't allow that remapping; everything has a downside.

I've also remapped the <CAPSLOCK> as a second <F1> key at the Windows level. That way I never yell by accident in chat, and selecting myself in DDO is an easier reach. This is some of what works for me.. my preferred setup, if you will.

Arguing that someone's setup is sub-par seems counterproductive to me. Either he can do it the way he wants or he can't and either has to go play something else or learn a new approach. That's all there is to it.

Shadowblade001 14 AGO 2014 a las 19:17 
Publicado originalmente por LilAngelKilla:
Whos They

ALL of them, except Warner Brothers in DODO.

I put in a tech support ticket and they suggested I put a post into the Suggestion Box forum as the Devs read it and respond regularly. I signed up there about 5 minutes after making my OP here, but I am not allowed to make new posts. Must be some 24 hour cooling off period or something.

So, they can enable mouse button re-mapping like every other game company I can think of, or they won't get my $99.00. I don't want to play another Cleric, I wanted to play a Druid.


Publicado originalmente por LilAngelKilla:
u are acting like ASDW is new to gaming.

No, you are acting like a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ troll who did not read my post. Either that, or it went completely over your head even though you read it very, very slowly with your lips moving and your index finger following every line.

~
Doug 15 AGO 2014 a las 8:25 
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
Publicado originalmente por LilAngelKilla:
Whos They

ALL of them, except Warner Brothers in DODO.
~

FWIW, Warner Brothers didn't create DDO, they bought it and inherited what I gather is a mass of spaghetti code. One of DDO's ongoing issues is that when they code something new or fix something, often something apparently unrelated breaks. Unfortunately, that has made them some skittish about fixes, especially those not demanded by a large number of people. Personally, I think DDO is good enough to justify a 'ground up' rewrite which would breathe new life into the franchise, but I'm not the bean counter.
Shadowblade001 17 AGO 2014 a las 14:15 
LilAngelKilla's posts have disapeared, but he said something like where have I been for 20 years, he's never heard of my setup etc.

Just a few examples:

Arena (1994) - Where you look is where you go, LEFT mouse to move forward, A,S,D for left, right, back
Heretic (1994) - Where you look is where you go, LEFT mouse to move forward, A,S,D for left, right, back
HeXen (1995) - Where you look is where you go, LEFT mouse to move forward, A,S,D for left, right, back
Daggerfall (1996) - Where you look is where you go, LEFT mouse to move forward, A,S,D for left, right, back
Age of Empires (1997) - LEFT click where you want to move
Baldur's Gate (1998) - LEFT click where you want to move
Planescape: Torment (1999) - LEFT click where you want to move
Icewind Dale (2000) - LEFT click where you want to move
The Temple of Elemental Evil (2003) - LEFT click where you want to move

Dungeons and Dragons Online (2004)
Sorry, we are breaking with tradition and will NOT ALLOW YOU to do that. And if you have a problem with your left shoulder, arthritis, tenosynovitis and/or carpal tunnel syndrome, TOUGH. Go play Neverwinter instead.

I am quite sure that this was not their intention. So we are back to my initial impression that it is a clunky, daft system that seems to have DEvolved into something unusable for me.


Thank you for the helpful suggestions.

~
殺してあげる 18 AGO 2014 a las 0:48 
BG, Planescape and Icewind were top-down 3/4 isometric view stuff.. where space bar paused the game, you couldn't sidestep/evade... it was a bare step-up from turn base to be honest here.

Might as well include Pool of Radience if you're going that left-field. 'Where you want to move' ...so what if i'm circle strafing backwards ?


If you want a counter...haven't heard of the rest of those but in passing, but i HAVE heard of Quake (1996)..which used.. WASD

And to use a game I was just playing 3 minutes ago... World of Tanks... WASD to move and rotate hull. Mouse to move/rotate turret... and left click to put 90mm of explosive pain in your tank, regardless of the fact i'm hulldown angling my armour and reversing back the hill as I shoot.

Honestly every character in DDO I have would do horrid if left click was movement..I'd lose agility to dodging spells and end up having to use another key for attacks (right-click isn't an option..i tend to spin the camera angle independant my actual movement. people looking over my shoulder mention something about naseua, but I prefer having 360 degree effective vision). That and if you have 7 hotbars... you can't keymap them.. would that mean need a modified click to use them instead of move/look?

*shrug* regardless, do hope you find a way to finangle it to working...personal preference for movement and such IS an annoyance when a game won't let you use 'your style'. Know of a few people turned off different games solely because the interface wasn't 'intuiative' to them. Lousy reason to lose a player.
Doug 18 AGO 2014 a las 9:41 
Publicado originalmente por Shadowblade001:
LilAngelKilla's posts have disapeared, but he said something like where have I been for 20 years, he's never heard of my setup etc.

I've been constantly calling him on his BS in another thread and now he's gone everywhere. Idk if he had to manually delete every post he ever made or if he deleted his Steam account and this is the result. Either way, I think it's my fault.
Doug 18 AGO 2014 a las 9:43 
Publicado originalmente por 殺してあげる:
*shrug* regardless, do hope you find a way to finangle it to working...personal preference for movement and such IS an annoyance when a game won't let you use 'your style'. Know of a few people turned off different games solely because the interface wasn't 'intuiative' to them. Lousy reason to lose a player.

Yep. I'm not gonna judge another person's style, but it's definitely a terrible reason to be unable to play a good game.
Doug 18 AGO 2014 a las 9:46 
Publicado originalmente por Doug:
Regarding possible solutions:

Have you considered an external mouse mapping software? Swapping left and right mouse buttons can be done in Windows itself, last I checked. The biggest pain would be having to swap back after playing. 3rd party software like what comes with most Logitech mice (and can probably be downloaded free) will attach itself to the game and make the swap on launch and undo it on exit. If that worked, it would be the least inconvenient workaround until and unless DDO changes the prohibition on the mapping you seek. (This does, of course, assume that DDO's mapping won't simply override the external one. Cross your fingers.)

Did you try this? It was at the bottom of a longish post, so it's possible you overlooked it. Also possible you are opposed to the idea, of course. But feedback would be appreciated either way. (Did it work or what objection to the idea do you have?)
< >
Mostrando 1-15 de 17 comentarios
Por página: 1530 50

Publicado el: 14 AGO 2014 a las 1:18
Mensajes: 17