Sins of a Solar Empire: Rebellion

Sins of a Solar Empire: Rebellion

查看统计:
titmo427 2013 年 12 月 28 日 下午 8:42
star trek mods
went to download mod from moddb and noticed 2 star trek mods.which is is better?
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 59 条留言
El Vibranté 2013 年 12 月 30 日 下午 3:30 
I've been playing SOA2 for a while and i've never even seen a x class world!
psychoak 2013 年 12 月 30 日 下午 4:45 
What maps do you use?

The X1 system is fully integrated into all of the random maps with the exception of the ring map(X class next to home world could be catastrophic). They are not on the vanilla fixed maps.

They are otherwise normal planets, labeled as X Class instead of their respective terrain based classification, with an ability in the fourth button slot that runs off the top of the screen.
iFrame 2013 年 12 月 31 日 上午 9:18 
I played Star Trek Armada III mod. Its nice but quite early stages of release.

Plan to try SOA. The screens and gameplay video looks damn awesome.

Why don't both the modders of Armada and SOA join forces or something lol. We can get more races and features!!!!

And about the Borg, they are meant to be OP imo. I havent tried Borg in SOA but in Armada, an assimilation cube can wipe out 2-3 faction's fleet quite easily in late game with titans and single handedly at that. So much so that me and my friends and our AI buddies are kinda feeding the Borg Exp LOL. Its challenging but fun. Borg is not meant to be played by human players in multiplayer. To me they are like a 3rd party "control". Thats the beauty of it!!!!
最后由 iFrame 编辑于; 2013 年 12 月 31 日 上午 9:22
Altor 2013 年 12 月 31 日 下午 12:08 
引用自 Y SO SERIOUS?
Plan to try SOA. The screens and gameplay video looks damn awesome.

Why don't both the modders of Armada and SOA join forces or something lol. We can get more races and features!!!!

It is impossible to match both mods together. To put models, particles, abilities, buffs together would take alot of time. There is also alot of different minds how should a star trek mod look like. SOA2 team think there should be no titans and Armada III team wants to have titans. The modders of SOA2 and even Armada III think borg should be OP.

If you are looking for a mod with more balance and more races you can try mine. In my mod I have playable races (Federation, Klingon, Romulan, Borg, Dominion) and all other races as NPC. But you will be also like a Beta Tester cause it is not ready yet :-)
AzureAlliance 2014 年 1 月 1 日 上午 6:23 
引用自 Y SO SERIOUS?
Why don't both the modders of Armada and SOA join forces or something lol.

Because the two teams of mod devs don't agree with each other in design philosophy. Oil, meet water.

SOA2 is trying to be a Star Trek mod. STA3 is trying to be a Star Trek mod. Both are right.

SOA2 wants you to build frigate factories at every planet so you can get repairs. STA3 realizes repairs are a needed part of the game and gives you real repair platforms. STA3 is right.

SOA2 wants to pretend Sisko & Janeway don't exist, and therefore don't give them any voices on ships (SOA2 devs= TNG fanboys). STA3 doesn't try to ignore Star Trek series they don't like, and includes Sisko & Janeway voiceovers. STA3 is right.

SOA2 has faster moving ships, providing more exciting gameplay. STA3 has slower moving ships. SOA2 is right.

SOA2 provides only one kind of starbase with a large potential for upgrades. STA3 confuses the issue by providing two kinds of starbase; one weaker with more potential for upgrades, the other stronger with less potential for upgrades. SOA2 is right.

SOA2 thinks you can defend a star with 2 starbases. STA3 thinks you can defend a star with 1 starbase. Both are wrong; you need 4.

It's unfortunate that neither of SOA2 nor STA3 have made a 'Borg VOY' (theoretical & balanced) faction in addition to the 'Borg TNG' (current & overpowered) faction. Both are wrong; players should have the power to decide if they will allow OP factions in their games.

And on and on and on. Altor named a few more differences in his post too. And you can find a lot of people who don't agree with the opinions in this post. There will probably be as many Star Trek mods as there are opinion groups populated with mod-devs.
psychoak 2014 年 1 月 1 日 上午 7:27 
We're not hating on Janeway, just the absurdly lame Borg they threw in the last couple seasons, and we definitely aren't ignoring DS9. Sacrifice of Angels is an episode title, the mod is the Dominion war. The Borg are just in for the masochists.

In STA3, Sisko and Janeway are on individual "hero ships" as opposed to the Defiant and Intrepid class. SOA2 does not use "hero ships" and so has no individuals. Numerous ships all using the same highly recognizable voice is bad. Build lots of Sovereigns, and you'll get really tired of hearing Picard everywhere. They take 95 fleetpoints and max tech. If we had Janeway on the Intrepid, a 16 fleetpoint tier 3 unlock, well...
Altor 2014 年 1 月 1 日 上午 8:15 
引用自 psychoak
In STA3, Sisko and Janeway are on individual "hero ships" as opposed to the Defiant and Intrepid class. SOA2 does not use "hero ships" and so has no individuals. Numerous ships all using the same highly recognizable voice is bad. Build lots of Sovereigns, and you'll get really tired of hearing Picard everywhere. They take 95 fleetpoints and max tech. If we had Janeway on the Intrepid, a 16 fleetpoint tier 3 unlock, well...

It should be of course only 1 Picard ship with only 1 Picard. The same for others. I don't believe that in STA3 there are several hero or titan ships in one time.
Altor 2014 年 1 月 1 日 上午 8:27 
引用自 AzureAlliance

And on and on and on. Altor named a few more differences in his post too. And you can find a lot of people who don't agree with the opinions in this post. There will probably be as many Star Trek mods as there are opinion groups populated with mod-devs.

That is why it is better to make your own mod and play it how you would like to play Star Trek :-)
vasaforever 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 12:52 
I've played both and I agree straight up with El-Vi-Riachi and myfist0. Both STA3 and SOA2 are solid mods but offer different styles of gameplay. I enjoy SOA2 because I enjoyed the gameplay in the past and the update, and recent balance changes make it more enjoyable. STA3 looks amazing and I find myself staring at it more often than anything and look forward to it's development further.
El-Vi-Riachi 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 2:56 
引用自 vasaforever
I've played both and I agree straight up with El-Vi-Riachi and myfist0. Both STA3 and SOA2 are solid mods but offer different styles of gameplay. I enjoy SOA2 because I enjoyed the gameplay in the past and the update, and recent balance changes make it more enjoyable. STA3 looks amazing and I find myself staring at it more often than anything and look forward to it's development further.

Proof in the pudding right there, both mods are great and the fact we have the choice of star trek mods is a good thing imo. Pick what you like, or pick up some tools and start modding yourself.
Altor 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 4:06 
引用自 El-Vi-Riachi
Proof in the pudding right there, both mods are great and the fact we have the choice of star trek mods is a good thing imo. Pick what you like, or pick up some tools and start modding yourself.

Anyway if there are some good ideas for star trek mod or people who want to test my mod can contact me. Would like to find more star trek and sins fans to share.
最后由 Altor 编辑于; 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 4:07
KRT™Conner Fodder 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 4:16 
We have different end goals and objectives as well as opinions on what a Star Trek mod should be for Sins. People also want different things and the mods cater for it, yeah some things may not be to peoples taste but if the devs listened to everything the mod would fail. In the end if people would appreciate both for what they are and be productive in picking out the bugs then we all win. This results in getting a much more polished product on both ends.
GulSurvives 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 4:18 
So what I'm getting here is that our good friend Altor has ripped SOA2 off in order to make a knock off mod? On the back of this he's trying to bash these two existing mods to promote his own? What in the flying ♥♥♥♥ are you doing ripping off a brilliant mod, then telling them yours is better man? you should have been lobotomized years ago. I'm one of the STA3 dev's and I'm utterly outraged on behalf of SOA2. You ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ maggot.

On a nicer note, I'd suggest playing both mods. I do, and both satisfy different desires for me dependant on what type of game I want.
Altor 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 5:12 
引用自 Technophobeus
On a nicer note, I'd suggest playing both mods. I do, and both satisfy different desires for me dependant on what type of game I want.

I was playing SOA2 for a long time.
Sorry but both mods don't satisfy me in any way. That is why I made my own mod and I like it most. If there are people who don't like these 2 mods like me and would like to give a try for another one I would like to share it. Or do you want to tell me they have to like these two mods?

TeRroR 2014 年 1 月 1 日 下午 6:18 
SoA2 is older than Rebellio thats worng that was SOA...not SOA2..but oki..i like SOA2 more as armader because better detail better balance..oki no titans bit not needed
< >
正在显示第 31 - 45 条,共 59 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2013 年 12 月 28 日 下午 8:42
回复数: 59