Tomb Raider or Max Payne 3

[GalacticAngle]

Which game should I buy Tomb Raider or Max Panye 3? and Which game is more active in mp?

[Dr. Zaius]

Tomb Raider

[Microshock]

I never played Max Payne 3 but Tomb Raider is an amazing game. It's a game with tons of spectacle.

[Sinistral]

I've had a terrible time with multiplayer for Max Payne 3 since launch. It's very hard for me to connect to servers (all necessary ports have been opened) and many people have had a difficult time logging in to Rockstar Social Club (necessary to play online). I have not played Tomb Raider multiplayer but MP3 multiplayer felt like a grind and can get boring real quick when up against fully unlocked players. This has been what I've experienced and I've had it since launch.

[James_789]

I have played both games and both are great games. It all depends what kind of a game you want to play right now. If you want to have more like a shooter type game, go with Max Payne 3 but if you are looking for a more platforming and alternative shooting gameplay, go for Tomb Raider. If you are looking for a solid Multiplayer experience choose MP3 over Tomb Raider because in my opinion Max Payne 3 has a much better multiplayer and Tomb Raider never should have had multiplayer anyway (let's hope they don't focus on multiplayer on the sequel and focus more on the story and the gameplay and please without the next-gen Lara face).

[wyresie25]

Tomb raider has always been agood game so I would suggest that over max payne 3

[Rednecksith]

Both are very good games, but if you're looking for multiplayer go with MP3.

The focus on multiplayer DLC for TR is quite honestly my only real letdown with the game. I don't think it sold all that well though (DLC, not the game), so hopefully CD pulls their heads out of their a$$es for the sequel and focuses on the SP experience.

[Devekta]

Tomb Raider is a lot more fun and better than Max Payne 3. Max Payne 3 was in fact the worst of the series, and if you're here for the multiplayer of it, then im sorry to disappoint you, but it's quite dead.
Tomb Raider, even though it was actually different from the previous series, it was still really enjoyable and awesome. If i were you, Tomb Raider is the choice.

[AtlasF]

Dude, I played both of them. Oscar goes to.... Tomb Raider. But I don't mean that Max Payne 3 is bad. It is awesome too.

[AtlasF]

Prentice eredeti hozzászólása:

I have played both games and both are great games. It all depends what kind of a game you want to play right now. If you want to have more like a shooter type game, go with Max Payne 3 but if you are looking for a more platforming and alternative shooting gameplay, go for Tomb Raider. If you are looking for a solid Multiplayer experience choose MP3 over Tomb Raider because in my opinion Max Payne 3 has a much better multiplayer and Tomb Raider never should have had multiplayer anyway (let's hope they don't focus on multiplayer on the sequel and focus more on the story and the gameplay and please without the next-gen Lara face).

I agree with him also.

[Jynk]

Max Payne 3 for the fun shooty mechanics.
Tomb Raider for the story, visuals and a much more likeable protagonist.

Personally I preferred TR.

[TRAITOR]

Get both for the price of not even close to either of them at release date

[Flapjack Willy]

Both are completely different experiences and are both worth getting especially at the price they are both at right now. I mean 15 dollars for more than 30+ hours of gameplay is a steal in my opinion.

[Pr3St0niAn]

kafkafcan eredeti hozzászólása:

Which game should I buy Tomb Raider or Max Panye 3? and Which game is more active in mp?

Buy both they are cheap enough

[Mr Long Pants]

Liquidus eredeti hozzászólása:

See if you can give the guy specifics in differences of game experience/adventure type (as well, as controls). That's probably what he's looking for.

Max Payne 1 & 2 were the only stories worth relating to MP, in my mind, sort of how Terminator 1 & 2 are the only movies worth accounting to the original Director's script.
Expect a drunken Charlie Sheen of a Max Payne, story wise, for MP3, although he can still shoot.

This this 1000x this.

Max Payne 3 I thought had better shooting mechanics but thats it, the story I thought went from being Sam Lake/Remedy awesomeness to Sam Houser/Rockstar awfullness. What made the original MP games so great was a perfect combination between story, gameplay and style. MP3 only gets one of those right IMO and Max comes off like a parody of the drunken burnt out cop from one of Tony Scott's more forgettable action films.

Tomb Raider was a full on reboot intentionally and like what has been said it is one of the best games of the year. In fact I would say with how overhyped Last of Us is and how dissappointing the last few hours of GTA5 were this probably IS my personal GOTY. The game would get a perfect 10 from me if only it had a decent prologue to help set up the supporting characters.

Max Payne was fun to play but due to personal taste I was severely let down by it and i'm probably not going to play it again. Again it had really well polished gameplay but not the stuff which made the original MP games great.

I think Rockstar just wanted to make another action game using the bulet time gimmick of Max Payne but weren't actually interested in making a "Max Payne 3". Whereas Crystal Dynamics actually wanted to reinvent a character and series which had fallen into obscurity and what they came out with was a brilliant new start.

TL;DR - Max Payne 3 for gameplay but Tomb Raider 2013 for the cvomplete package and the direction the game takes the series as a whole.

[Undahill]

Tomb Raider is way better. If you want a shoot gallery cut scene type of game then get Max Payne 3. MP3 is like the 3rd person Call of Duty these days.