Rank the Amnesia games here

[Server Jester]

Ill start:
Dark Descent and Justine > Bunker > Machine for Pigs > Rebirth

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Postat inițial de noisyturtle:

Postat inițial de Ethnarch Samael Mal Caligora:

Honestly, the single most diehard rebirth aficionado would have provided an opinion tenfold worthier (and smarter) than that of yours. Go relish some trash produced specifically for minors with attention spam predicaments. Alternatively, a head on dive into a properly utilized piss pot would do!

Also, what exactly was YOUR response? Exactly - some regurgitated drivel, spammed endlessly by people who are exactly like you

All this coming from someone who dropped out of college first year and lives with their parents in their mid 20s while working a minimum wage retail job. You can barely even afford your car payments, and that's even with the free housing and food your mommy provides. You'll never amount to anything, we all know it.

You wanna know how I know all this specific info about you? I'm the one banging your mother. Lovely lady btw.

Another exercise in futility courtesy of a truly gifted individual who's wretched existAnce, the fact of, solely attributes to the omnipresently lackluster sexual education. Can your sticky würsts ever utter anything not resembling a Reddit rant? I observed your lack of articulation with the only language familiar, but omission of effort will only deepen the pit. English is my 3rd, by the way, and it truly is pisseningly-sad seeing a native so neglectful and boorish. Not that it's a novelty either... The selection in your game library truly speaks volumes - another case for prejudice and elitism apologetics won fair and square

What's the weight tho?

[noisyturtle]

Postat inițial de Ethnarch Samael Mal Caligora:

What's the weight tho?

You got some kinda fetish bby?

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Postat inițial de noisyturtle:

Postat inițial de Ethnarch Samael Mal Caligora:

What's the weight tho?

You got some kinda fetish bby?

Only disdain, Mr tub'o'lard

[Heuristicus]

I wonder why they never made SOMA part of the Amnesia series. You do sort of wake up in that state a few minutes into it.

[WuffWabbit]

Postat inițial de Tokida_san:

Postat inițial de Comrade Rusty:

Dark Descent and Justine> Bunker >Rebirth >Machine for Pigs

This.

I also agree with this order.

Soma>TDD/Justine>Bunker>Rebirth>Penumbra>AMFP

[Roy]

Postat inițial de WuffWabbit:

Postat inițial de Tokida_san:

This.

I also agree with this order.

Soma>TDD/Justine>Bunker>Rebirth>Penumbra>AMFP

I second this, except i prefer Rebirth over Bunker.

Bunker is a beter horror/survival game, Rebirth is a better story game with more varied setpieces and storytelling.

[sstern]

1. The Bunker
2. The Dark Descent
3. Rebirth
4. A Machine for Pigs

[Roy]

What makes a machine for pigs so bad?
It's the only amnesia title i haven't played yet.

[sstern]

Postat inițial de Roy:

What makes a machine for pigs so bad?
It's the only amnesia title i haven't played yet.

The boring gameplay. But ironically this game has the best plot of the series

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Postat inițial de Roy:

What makes a machine for pigs so bad?
It's the only amnesia title i haven't played yet.

Average gamer's attention span of 3 seconds.
Although it really isn't as good as the pinnacle of FG - SOMA and Dark Descent

[Anonymusx]

Am I the only one who didn't like Amnesia Dark d.?
I didn't like anything about it, I liked the other parts better.

[Roy]

Postat inițial de Anonymusx:

Am I the only one who didn't like Amnesia Dark d.?
I didn't like anything about it, I liked the other parts better.

I don't dislike it but i prefer the newer titles to be honest.
It was hands down one of the greatest horror games at the time due to the superb psychological horror and ambience.

The monsters were a bit anti climactic though, i don't really understand why people would choose it over the newer Amnesia games or even Soma.
Maybe nostalgic value?

[WuffWabbit]

Postat inițial de Roy:

Postat inițial de Anonymusx:

Am I the only one who didn't like Amnesia Dark d.?
I didn't like anything about it, I liked the other parts better.

I don't dislike it but i prefer the newer titles to be honest.
It was hands down one of the greatest horror games at the time due to the superb psychological horror and ambience.

The monsters were a bit anti climactic though, i don't really understand why people would choose it over the newer Amnesia games or even Soma.
Maybe nostalgic value?

Well, in context of the time and how refreshing and new a game like it was. It was insanely good. Now stacked next to Bunker and Soma (Gameplay and Story done better respectively) it doesn't hold up true. That's why I recommend people start with TDD, because it's easier playing new titles after as opposed to going back and noticing how dated it is.

[🍊σяαηgє נυι¢є🍊]

1) amnesia the bunker ( because of the gun )
2) dark decent ( og )
3(machine for pigs )
4) rebirth and justine

[chakkman]

The Dark Descent was kind of the original, perfect experience. A Machine For Pigs felt like a different game (no wonder, being developed by The Chinese Room...), and had a lot of dumbed down mechanics, Rebirth annoyed me with a "gasping for air" pregnant female protagonist I couldn't bond with, and with some political messages I don't like, and, I still gotta finish The Bunker, which I only played briefly on release. It looked much better than Rebirth though, which I consider a really bad game.

Also, SOMA. A bit silly in terms of story, but, also a great game. Not as brilliant as Dark Descent and Penumbra (especially that one) though.