Is there a legal way to be a poacher?

[ritzmax72]

I am running out of open world stuffs to do. Poaching could be fun but stolen goods take time to get whitewashed. Does anyone know if poaching quests can lead to legal poaching?

[Raywhisper]

In the first game some inkeepers at the outside of cities/villages usually bought out poached meat. I did not find any yet in KCD2 but I would presume it is similar.

Also every NPC that buys stolen goods will buy meat aswell.

[theo]

Nguyên văn bởi SomeoneSomewhere:

Nguyên văn bởi insert food here:

Just smoke or dry the meat. The stolen tag gets removed and you can sell without any fear of being found out. I also have sold heaps of poached meat with the stolen tag on it and no vendor has said anything to me so far.

That's because it's broken.

Probably not.
Stolen tag doesn't mean nobody will buy the item from you

[Replicant Six]

Nguyên văn bởi WarWolf:

Nguyên văn bởi ofcthatwaslag:

By definition poaching is illegal.

Why did you answer with a comment that belittles the OP when you know exaclty what he means. thats pretty toxic of you. i would like to know the asnwer to his question how to hunt with out being a poacher. Ritzmax72 I hope someone will answer this question and i hope there is a way

OP shouldn't have asked a stupid question.

Asking how to poach legally is an oxymoron.

[Ethan Tokes]

Many many people illegally poached deer irl and it was sorta seen as a victimless crime most likely. You don't have to think of yourself as a "criminal" if you are RPing or w.e. If anything you are just risking it for the biscuit, literally.

[Einherjer]

This question makes as much sense as like: Is there a legal way to be a thief or murderer?

[corthew]

I know when you do the quests for the drunk gameskeeper there is one point where he makes the remark that you could hunt deer, boar, etc, for their entrails when you need him to make string for the lute players minstrels...or you could wimp out and by the entrails. ;)
I think he's kinda giving you a pass as long as you're in his territory and you don't be too obvious and keep your kills down.
I really hope the lute minstrels get good at singing in Kuttenberg because at Zhelehov they really sucked. LOL

[Humble]

Nguyên văn bởi ofcthatwaslag:

By definition poaching is illegal.

Problem is that, in bible, it's not illegal, although it's illegal for humankind to eat unclean food but are okay to eat deer as it's clean food to eat, Funny Lord or Kingdom don't follow bible even they calm to be Christianity, although God do not command or approved that kingdom or Lord's rule/law they create, but too many people are uneducated and not even allowed to read or study bible at a time (I think?)

Of course once people study/learning, then they would be aware that it's their "God gave Right" to hunt deer to eat, it's do not belong to Lord or King at all but Lord or King don't want peasant or commoner to know that, and want secret keep more value meat for themself, and not share with peassant/commoner, I guess.

In world of faith keeper/religion, they would knew that is not illegal at all while Lord/King try create Law and keep people in ignorance, limited or not allowed common people to use resource for good healthy life (dog meat is nasty to eat, but Deer meat is very healthy. Hare is not good meat at least that what Bible said as humankind was not suppose to eat unclean food like hare, dog, boar, ect but deer, yes they can eat.

Sady, if one knew truth too much, then lord or King find you threat if you know too much of truth, even Church find you threat and want to kill you and burn you, like in KCD 1 quest called "Waldensians" I don't see Bauer as Heretic, but I do see Vicar and church as Heretic as they don't follow bible teaching.

All because they want control over people and not want share highly value resource with common people.

Lord and Nobility, and church too, can be very cruel to common people, like this one
https://www.medieval-life-and-times.info/medieval-life/medieval-hunting-history.htm#:~:text=Medieval%20peasant%20only%20had%20the,by%20some%20special%20royal%20grant.&text=The%20strict%20Medieval%20Forest%20Laws,resented%20by%20the%20lower%20classes.

Medieval Hunting History - Punishments for breaking Medieval Hunting Laws
The strict Medieval Forest Laws reserved the rights of hunting to the ruling class and were hated and resented by the lower classes. Punishments for breaking Medieval Hunting Laws were severe. Peasants accused of poaching were liable to hanging, castration, blinding or being sewn into a deerskin and then hunted down by ferocious dogs.

I know that Bible did command you shall not kill, I assumed it's meant for humnakind
do not kill other humankind, more or less but, not for animal or tick or mosquito apply that everyone is forced to kill tick or mosquito or animal for food.

[ofcthatwaslag]

People not knowing the difference between hunting and poaching.

[noxteryn]

Nguyên văn bởi Humble:

... in bible, it's not illegal ...

Poaching is not illegal because of the Bible. It's illegal because of feudalism. The lord owns literally all the land and everything on it, and that includes the animals. So, poaching is illegal, because you are stealing someone's property. Noblemen were generally excluded from this rule, and peasants were still allowed to hunt small game, which is why hunting hare is still legal.

[LeftPaw]

I guess you just kill the game warden and nick his cloths.

[Humble]

Nguyên văn bởi noxteryn:

Nguyên văn bởi Humble:

... in bible, it's not illegal ...

Poaching is not illegal because of the Bible. It's illegal because of feudalism. The lord owns literally all the land and everything on it, and that includes the animals. So, poaching is illegal, because you are stealing someone's property. Noblemen were generally excluded from this rule, and peasants were still allowed to hunt small game, which is why hunting hare is still legal.

You could said Lord is illegal own all land (they got land by murder, kill, steal, by force, ect, basic big thug who want control over people, it's how it's start, mafia, that turn into feudalism, that's how it's all start in, get loyal men with strong sword/arms then threat other to pay them food, and in return, they would keep them safe from enemies and their own army at same time. So it's nothing more than powerful men who happen to get follower who had similar same mindset bully on innocent people who had nothing to do with murder, steal, force yet they are forced into slave/peasant, that is from my understand from history all it's start, then many year later, they try romantic how good lord/kingdom is, and want people forgot dark history how it all start.

[theo]

Nguyên văn bởi Humble:

Nguyên văn bởi noxteryn:

Poaching is not illegal because of the Bible. It's illegal because of feudalism. The lord owns literally all the land and everything on it, and that includes the animals. So, poaching is illegal, because you are stealing someone's property. Noblemen were generally excluded from this rule, and peasants were still allowed to hunt small game, which is why hunting hare is still legal.

You could said Lord is illegal own all land (they got land by murder, kill, steal, by force, ect, basic big thug who want control over people, it's how it's start, mafia, that turn into feudalism, that's how it's all start in, get loyal men with strong sword/arms then threat other to pay them food, and in return, they would keep them safe from enemies and their own army at same time. So it's nothing more than powerful men who happen to get follower who had similar same mindset bully on innocent people who had nothing to do with murder, steal, force yet they are forced into slave/peasant, that is from my understand from history all it's start, then many year later, they try romantic how good lord/kingdom is, and want people forgot dark history how it all start.

Sounds like an attempt to justify communist thugs

[corthew]

Nguyên văn bởi noxteryn:

Nguyên văn bởi Humble:

... in bible, it's not illegal ...

Poaching is not illegal because of the Bible. It's illegal because of feudalism. The lord owns literally all the land and everything on it, and that includes the animals. So, poaching is illegal, because you are stealing someone's property. Noblemen were generally excluded from this rule, and peasants were still allowed to hunt small game, which is why hunting hare is still legal.

And since rabbits breed like...rabbits...no-one should ever go hungry.

[Sylvaa]

Nguyên văn bởi WarWolf:

Nguyên văn bởi ofcthatwaslag:

By definition poaching is illegal.

Why did you answer with a comment that belittles the OP when you know exaclty what he means. thats pretty toxic of you. i would like to know the asnwer to his question how to hunt with out being a poacher. Ritzmax72 I hope someone will answer this question and i hope there is a way

Ask stupid questions, get stupid answers.

No, there is no way to legally commit a crime.

[votadc]

Nguyên văn bởi noxteryn:

Nguyên văn bởi Humble:

... in bible, it's not illegal ...

Poaching is not illegal because of the Bible. It's illegal because of feudalism. The lord owns literally all the land and everything on it, and that includes the animals. So, poaching is illegal, because you are stealing someone's property. Noblemen were generally excluded from this rule, and peasants were still allowed to hunt small game, which is why hunting hare is still legal.

Even wolves are labeled as "corpse looted" in crime stats despite ingame info suggest that wolves and hares are legal.