The eye vs the lodge (possible spoiler)

[Ansakura]

Hello, i am wondering if any has made it to the point were you have to pick to either go to the eye or defend the lodge. I am told that one of your companion will die depending on your choice

My question is how is that determined? is it buy who you have the best realtionship with or are there other factors?

I mainly ask becuasei have a high relation ship with Andreja, ok realtion ship with sara and nearly a non exsistant one with sam and barret.

[UNBREAKABLE]

Spoilers ofc but

I believe during this mission the game picks the top 2 constellation companions you've bonded with the most. One will be in the lodge, the other in the eye. Then the mission happens for reasons and you have to pick which place to save. The companion at the place you choose is saved and the companion in the place you don't choose is killed.

So in your case, it's probably Andreja and Sarah in play. If say Andreja is in the eye but you choose to stay at the lodge during the attack, she'll die. But if you go to the Eye you can save her, but that would kill off Sarah. So the one you don't help has to die.

For me Sarah was saved but Sam got oofed. Some say Barret is always a possible contender no matter what but I'm not sure if that's true, I didn't bond with him much and he lived in my playthrough.

[Ansakura]

Ok, i just did the first mission with sara (to gain 1 artificat) then did the mission to save andreja, if i dont use her anymore and keep her status were it is, is there a chance she can end up at the eye instead of the lodge?

[Ansakura]

or is it random which is were, i mainly ask beucase i have seen a few videos and they all seem to always have sam, andej and sara at the eye with berret and the others at the lodge

[fauxpas]

Yep, the person who dies is whoever you have the highest relationship with at the place you aren't.

[Ansakura]

Welp i guess im gonna work up berret, he kinda has it comin :)

[fauxpas]

Originally posted by Ansakura:

Welp i guess im gonna work up berret, he kinda has it comin :)

I personally like the mechanic as it's bittersweet and think trying to engineer a disliked NPC dying takes away from that.

[Ansakura]

Ok, according to some info i just found, The compaion with the lowest chemistry stays at the lodge if you go to the eye and the ones with the highest chemisty are at the eye

[Ansakura]

https://www.gamerguides.com/starfield/guide/missions/main-quest/high-price-to-pay-walkthrough-in-starfield-who-dies-and-fighting-hunter