Diablo 4 or Starfield? Which game is better?

[76561198055083273]

And if you say Starfield don't fake like it and say fake nice things about the game like everyone did for Diablo 4 saying fake positive things about the game at launch then tricking hard working people like myself to spend my hard earned money on that crappy Diablo 4 game

[KingOfFriedChicken]

BG3

[jamesc70]

Diablo 4 sucks.

It does combat right with fast paced placement and skill use, but everything else is meh. Loot sucks and is forgettable (mortal sin for an ARPG). The skill trees are simplistic. World bosses and events are 'simply show up and you win'; zero challenge. Endgame has like 12 dungeons.

The jury's out on Starfield.

[leqesai]

I haven't played Diablo 4 so take this with a grain of salt, but I think Starfield is the clear winner in this. Diablo 4 is just more of the same while Starfield is at least something different. It is the first solid game with space and ground gameplay in a long time (no man's sky is also good but it doesn't have boarding, crews, compelling combat, leveling etc...). In fact the only other game i cant think of that reminds me of starfield is the space content of Star Wars Galaxies.

[Necromanu Lord of Souls Games]

Diablo 4 if you are a serious gamer ,, most of people bought diablo 4 by a comercial at KFC or TV ,, if you are a hardcore gamer for Diablo 4 , you will not get dissapointed

IF you known ,, you have to farm gear for long periods ,, and you understand what is endgame .. as someone with level 100 on both Season and Non-Season i can say .. Diablo 4 for casuals is a bad game ,, and i don't recommended

[HeyGetOffMylawn]

Get Starfield. Diablo 4 is a ♥♥♥♥ game

[mav001au]

Starfield all the way

[FallenActual]

Honeslty I grinded d4 pre season hit 100 and killed Uber lilith but I never played after that I heard season 1 was a joke and as for starfield it has alot alot of issues idk neither is really great tbh

[Azrael ♡]

D4 > Starfield
D4 = Bad

[jamesc70]

Originally posted by Necromanu-Gaming-Veteran:

IF you known ,, you have to farm gear for long periods ,,

D4 gear progression : get something like X damage, 20% dmg to close enemies - get something like X+1 damage, 30% dmg to distant enemies, rinse and repeat. Yes I know they have more stats...

I've farmed thousands and thousands of hours in D2. High Runes, great white socketed bases, uniques and sets, keys for uber, gold find barb horking corpses at Trav for 150,000 each to gamble, and more. This is fun; why I've run Pindle 10,000 times.

I have all the horses and cosmetics that drop for them in D4. The only thing left to farm for is a piece of gear with 10% more vulnerable damage? How is that remotely fun?

[Mittens]

Originally posted by ケツデカピングー:

choosing between poop flavour curry and curry flavour poop is not good

I feel like this is a much more compelling question than the Starfield v Diablo 4 one. I think I would go with poop flavored curry. Sure, it would taste bad, but I wouldn't actually be eating poop.

[Mittens]

Originally posted by Necromanu-Gaming-Veteran:

Diablo 4 if you are a serious gamer ,, most of people bought diablo 4 by a comercial at KFC or TV ,, if you are a hardcore gamer for Diablo 4 , you will not get dissapointed

IF you known ,, you have to farm gear for long periods ,, and you understand what is endgame .. as someone with level 100 on both Season and Non-Season i can say .. Diablo 4 for casuals is a bad game ,, and i don't recommended

I recognize the words you are using, but I can't make sense of what they mean jumbled together as they are.

[CassieX]

Diablo 4 was fun till I completed the campaign and ran out of things to do in 80s. Then it was fun again in Season 1 till I hit 80s on that character, completed campaign and ran out of things to do. I think its too grindy for Glyph skills and there's not much else to do. It probably will be same on future seasons unless they improve the content. I did the early access on Starfield, its worked flawlessly on my Alienware Desktop via SSD so far without any crashes. I like the game-play, the game doesn't spoon feed you everything the way some games do, but the regular combat is pretty fun and star-ship battles are doable once you figure out how to speed up and slow down effectively to maneuver(before you upgrade systems and invest a bunch of skill points). The inventory and storage is light years ahead of its predecessors. Comparing Diablo 4 to Starfield is like comparing Apples to Oranges. I've been playing Diablo games since the original first came out, same for Fallout series and I still remember Daggerfall and Battlespire If I had to choose, I would choose Starfield as I think I will probably still be playing it years from now, especially if the modding community gives it the same love it gave to Fallout and Skyrim. Diablo 4, imo just doesn't have the same hook at the moment.

[Glorified Toaster With Legs]

TLDR:

Starfield, but partially because I hate what Blizzard has done to Diablo as a series.


Starfield, at least so far.

Diablo 4 immediately put me off with the whole battle-pass and live service BS that every multiplayer game with more than 2 stats needs to be now. Not to mention the company... But I've never actually played it myself, so it could be the best 100GB+ Live ARPG out there and I would never know.

Starfield is just a decent space RPG, nothing overly extraordinary, but very pretty with decent storytelling (again, so far). Most of the combat and looting seems to be copied straight out of Fallout 4, which some people might see as lazy development work, I see it as improving on features that their fans are already familiar with, and as a plus.

The menus get pretty annoying after a while, but it's more navigable on KB+M than FO4 was imo. And all the issues people have with the base game mechanics can, and will, be fixed with mods.

[RTX 5080 FE(Mr Happy)]

Originally posted by 76561198055083273:

And if you say Starfield don't fake like it and say fake nice things about the game like everyone did for Diablo 4 saying fake positive things about the game at launch then tricking hard working people like myself to spend my hard earned money on that crappy Diablo 4 game

Hi I own both and enjoy both.


You cant really compare as one is a RPG and one is an ACTION RPG.

Starfield Pros

Single player game.
Play without internet
Play on Steam.
Mods

CONS

Requires a beefy pc

Diablo 4:

Pros

Its fing Diablo Man!!!

Loot

Co Op

Loot

Loot
Loot

Did I mention the loot?

Cons

Requires an internet connection and downloading a different launcher.
Both are great games, really depends what you want. Cant go wrong with either.


Note. I am a fan of both but if you force me to pick.


Buy Starfield then download Path of Exile. POE is free and will scratch your aRPG itch while you still get to enjoy Starfield

[FAIR]

Neither.