[Spoilers] Who is best girl

[Zerul]

Since this most important thread is missing I have to start it.

I'll post my thoughts first to get this topic startet, so here we go:

3rd rank goes to Allie as life would never be boring with her and the plan for the fourth date seems like quite the spectacle.

2nd is Violet as I want to see her happy after learning her backstory and how she kept going after reading her file.

1st I guess that it surprises noone that this rank has to go to Kat. I suspected that there is more to it as soon as I learned of her betrayal because it wouldn't explain her heavy drinking throughout the whole story we see and her reaction on her ending is almost heartbreaking.

[WholeWheat]

agree 100% but i'm afraid you'll start a war

[Zerul]

Originally posted by WholeWheat:

agree 100% but i'm afraid you'll start a war

Why would anyone start a war when the right answer is obvious?

But jokes aside, shouldn't we all be mature enough to discuss our rankings of the girls without starting a war?

[WholeWheat]

Originally posted by Zerul:

Originally posted by WholeWheat:

agree 100% but i'm afraid you'll start a war

Why would anyone start a war when the right answer is obvious?

But jokes aside, shouldn't we all be mature enough to discuss our rankings of the girls without starting a war?

I'm joking haha but I would defend kat's glory with my life. surely you would understand

[Zerul]

I wouldn't go that far as I like some girls from other VNs more, but she is in my top 20.

[quakatak]

You're all delusional best girl is obviously 5

[Zerul]

Originally posted by quakatak:

You're all delusional best girl is obviously 5

But why 5? 1 gets constantly thrown under the bus, can't you sympathise with people suffering?

[Kashtano]

Originally posted by Zerul:

Why would anyone start a war when the right answer is obvious?

Because your answer is obviously wrong. Being able to start a zombie virus plague and quelling it with devastating firepower just before breakfast seems exactly like the type of girl I'd like to cook for. And I'm a good cook.
Scarlett might have gotten the short end of the stick in terms of writing, but her pure awesomeness still makes her my favourite.

Kat would be third for me, after Yui. Yui has more different sides to her than the others, she can be caring, aggressive, naive or rational. She might seem plain as a person, but as a character, I would be interested in knowing her better.

[Miral]

I liked all of them, but if I had to choose an ordering, 1st = Kat/Terra tied, then Violet, Yui, Scarlett, and Allie.

(The latter two are fun, but too reckless for my taste.) Violet started near the bottom but moved higher really fast once we got to know her a bit better.

[Sparrow]

Kat is indeed best girl

[༼ つ ◕◡◕ ༽つ Dray2k]

Kat was set up to be best girl from the start. Unfortunately.

The entire game pretty much felt like the Meruem vs. Netero fight in which the audience believes that Netero would be easily stomped but it was the other way around. Sorry for the HxH spoiler but it is what it is.

First let the player believe that Kat is...the bad guy. Then pull on the heart strings and by the end establish that nobody ever had a chance. Even the redeeming qualities of the other characters stand no chance given Kats backstory. Kat basically called the shots but is basically the only real driving force in the entire story as the sole important character. In hindsight the impact of Katherine makes other girls feel like...pity choices to me. I hope if there is ever be a update that makes the Story complete, the other characters should have a similar backstory, perhaps even with flashbacks with unique art or other quirks that makes every character even more unique and funny.

I also remember that Yui out of all characters was all like "I kill everyone who stands in our way" or something Yandere-like during the first date. I looked for clues hinting that she was a sort of secret killer or something when I was playing this game but the writer essentially done a Checkovs Gun here, a huge shame and missed opportunity for many possible outcomes. I was expected 30 minutes into the game that ther is more to Kat than just her being the antagonist.

My personal taste waifu rank.

#1 Allie - Don't like her type at all but those eyes and smile were the best drawn ones and character and that she fakes her demeanor for the show. Allie also sounds like Ally, very based name and character.
#2 Violet - best backstory and most realistic/third-dimensional character but needs backstory through cutscenes.
#3 Five Guys - They need more backstory and actual faces.
#4 Terra - meme hacker-chan character but the most funny.
#5 Kat - She has the most plot and was written super sympathetically but I appreciate the effort.
#6 Scarlett - Resident Evil parody character which makes her better than Yui.
#7 Yui - Too perfect to be a choice. Worst written waifu, needed to let out her Yandere side more.

All of the characters need more content.

[血液月 jack]

My favorite girls were Kat, Yui, Violet and Terra.

[SansTheWildCardFool]

Yui is best girl. She's nice and sweet, but she also comes with a lot of cute animals at home plus the mischievous rascal Bunbunbun, who is an absolutely adorable bunny.

[McBomb]

Here is my list:

1 > Violet
2 > Scarlett
2 > Kat (tie)
4 > Allie
5 > Yui
6 > Terra

Really loved Violet. I'm okay with Kat being the "main girl" from a story perspective, there's usually a "main girl" in all of these games and that doesn't diminish any of the others. I will say that I liked all of them except for maybe Terra. I guess her type of character just isn't for me. It also seemed like she had shorter dates that were more one note and such.

[Kaitones]

Honestly, my best girl has got to be Allie, I have no idea how but, when I got to her segment of the date in Act 2 (i.e: the part after the first week), I somehow fell for her. Please don't ask why, even I don't know how that happened.

[Helion139]

1-Allie cos i dig tomboys and relavant to plot.
2-Terra cos i dig gamer girls.
3-Kat cos plot relavant.
4-Yui way too sterotypical girl next door but atleast doesn't sleep with mc on 3rd date.
5-Violet don't like rich ladies stereotype and girls who sleep on 3rd date.
6-Scarlett don't like scientist who give you suprise jabs and sleep with you on 3rd date.