Moonstone Island

Moonstone Island

View Stats:
X Lord X Sep 20, 2023 @ 8:47am
17
2
Why does every single farming sim need "romancing"?
Does anyone else find this feature thats included in EVERY harvest sim unecessary? I really don't see the connection between farming for upgrades and buying/selling foods to a dating simulator for lonely guys.. there are games that cater for those types of people.

I know i'm probably a minority here but does anyone else find this "copy cat" feature offputting? Come up with your own ideas please devs, no need to literally rip every feature from other popular games in the genre. Make it stand out.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Razzle Sep 20, 2023 @ 8:55am 
idk why you had to lump'em up as "lonely guys" "those types of ppl" very werirdchamp thing to say there buddy.

I dont think every faming sim has romancing, quite a lot that I played didn't have any, a very small amount does so Idk what games you been playing tbh.
RPGenie Sep 20, 2023 @ 9:04am 
I don't think i've ever played one where it was required to romance an npc.
Cabrita Alada Sep 20, 2023 @ 9:16am 
2
No, probably just you, the only person on a planet of 8 billion. The chosen.

Firstly, in no game are you FORCED to interact, so much so that it is a feature that I ignore in most of them.
Secondly, since Harvest Moon in 1990, this type of game goes beyond farming, it has relationships, stories, discoveries. If you just want to farm, there's a great game for you: Farming Simulator.
Fae Farm also has a very weak social side, if you're interested, but surprise: it also has history and the focus is not the farm.
Stop being a jerk saying things like "lonely guy" and referencing as "those type of people", you are no better than anyone for liking binding of isaac instead of nekopara. :cupup:
CeliriaRose Sep 20, 2023 @ 9:30am 
First off, some people enjoy romance stories. The idea that the only people who would like this sort of thing are "lonely guys" is nonsensical on top of being rather insulting especially given there is an entire genre of storytelling called romance which is enjoyed by many people from all walks of life both single and in relationships.

Second why does it have to have any deep connection to farming. The genre these games fall under isn't just farming sim but also involves lite life sim elements. Farming isn't the only piece of the equation. Getting to know the other residents and characters around you, finding romance, and other activities like town festivals, fishing, mining, etc are also common features even when they have little to do with farming. If you just want a pure farming simulator there's the aptly named Farming Simulator 22. But this genre this game is branching off from isn't the same thing as that.

Also the game is putting it's own spin on things and making itself stand out. The alchemist focus, the mechanics of how romance works in the game, spirit collecting, the card battle system. 100 procedurally generated islands to explore. That's a fair bit to differentiate itself from the other Harvest Moon/Stardew Valley type games. It's not like they are just putting out some bog standard release that just imitates Harvest Moon and that's it.
Aerond Sep 20, 2023 @ 10:12am 
What a rude thing to say.
Espresso Depresso Sep 20, 2023 @ 10:29am 
10
1
this guy farming clown awards give em to me instead <3
Arcvas Sep 20, 2023 @ 10:32am 
Its just a carry over from harvest moon, where marriage was often the plot itself (like wonderful life) and not just a side quest.
lusciouslanguidity Sep 20, 2023 @ 11:45am 
firstly, your statement is false -> not every farming sim has it.

secondly, sure it might be generally a copycat feature but if that's the standard, then literally almost every game has significant copycat features. for example, so many games have combat systems in games where it's not needed. so many games have levelling systems in games where it's not needed. etc.

thirdly, romance in the farming sims that have it are implemented differently. maybe you should be focusing on finding new ways to implement it or ways to better integrate it into the game.

fourthly, farming sims almost always have NPCs where you go around and talk to townsfolk. Since romance is a huge part of socialization, it makes sense to have some of it in there.

fifthly, romance is often semi-optional as in you don't need to engage in it to do most of the game's progression, unlike so many other games which use combat or other "copycat" systems.
Texus Sep 20, 2023 @ 12:15pm 
After reading another comment I got that image in my head how they could fix romance for him, maybe falling in love with a turnip you meet when it grows on his field or something.

In a way I could understand him not liking that feature even if i do like it and see it as some kind of slice of life element.
That would be also part of what makes these worlds more normal for me I suppose?
However yes, the rest from what I reading was rather insulting.
Picotrain Sep 20, 2023 @ 1:56pm 
I mean, it's a feature that you can choose to completely ignore. That being said, farming games are very often about community building, (which involves relationships) as well. If it's not for you, then just don't engage with that aspect of the game.
ichigokage Sep 20, 2023 @ 2:49pm 
I think the only farming game where you are required to marry someone is Harvest Moon/Story of Seasons: A Wonderful Life. But those very rare exceptions aside, you can ignore romance altogether. The romance and even just friendship building is there for people who want to pursue it. It's very easy to ignore if it's not your cup of tea.

I personally love romance. I find it beautiful. All forms of love even platonic are wonderful. So I like having the option. Plenty of people in relationships play these types of games and even full on dating sims. So you really don't need to push the whole 'lonely' thing. It's just sad, dude.
X Lord X Sep 20, 2023 @ 5:20pm 
Do you know what makes something funny? Having truth to it.
Byakko Sep 20, 2023 @ 5:24pm 
Originally posted by Nevzat:
Does anyone else find this feature thats included in EVERY harvest sim unecessary? I really don't see the connection between farming for upgrades and buying/selling foods to a dating simulator for lonely guys.. there are games that cater for those types of people.

I know i'm probably a minority here but does anyone else find this "copy cat" feature offputting? Come up with your own ideas please devs, no need to literally rip every feature from other popular games in the genre. Make it stand out.
It's a life sim thing not a farming game thing. Go play Farming Simulator.
unsynchronized29 Sep 20, 2023 @ 5:27pm 
I too rarely engage with the romance stuff in these games.

But what you said is just stupid.
76561199400003004 Sep 20, 2023 @ 5:31pm 
Originally posted by RPGenie:
I don't think i've ever played one where it was required to romance an npc.

Harvest moon, (SoS) a wonderful life.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 47 comments
Per page: 1530 50