SpaceBourne 2
BalkanBiker Mar 23, 2023 @ 1:21pm
Is this really better than Star Citizen?
I don't want a biased, fanboy answer. I want honesty from people who have played both.

I didn't get into Star Citizen because of its higher asking price, as I know I will probably dump €200+ on it because I'm a sucker for collectibles.
This would cost me 10th of Star Citizen price. It's not about cost but time vs money investment. Regardless what I get, I probably won't play more than 3-5 hours per week and if SpaceBourne 2 is 95% of Star Citizen, then I'll pick SB2.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 110 comments
Noobelwerfer Mar 23, 2023 @ 1:39pm 
I had a similar discussion going on in my head, but I play a lot more than 3-5 hrs pw. I have never played SC as I disagree with buying stuff IRL, it looks epic, but the friends I have to do play say it is quite good with some serious flaw. SB2 on the other hand, is cheap, really good as a space game in its own right (without comparison to either ED or SC. I really think that SB2 is simply a great game in the making.
2ugly Mar 23, 2023 @ 2:07pm 
TLDR: No, but it has potential as an alternative.

Has some nice visual elements and comparable mechanics. 1p view only in certain situations. No ship interiors, no seamless space. Planets have designated landing areas, no exploration or very little. Lots of empty in the settlements I've seen.

The dev has done a superb job with what it is. He's basically trying to give the gameplay without all the simulation aspects, and waste of space that space can be.

I got lured into the game because of the comparison, but found it highly incomparable in, mechanics, scope, and scale. Heard there was no 1p view but saw a streamer on foot using 1p ingame, so I went ahead and bought the game. Also there's a cockpit view, but as soon as you go EVA in a suit... no 1p view. It's aggravating.... even for the streamer when he tried going into a 1p view using the mag boots after using 1p on foot back on the planet.

All depends on what you like. You could like it alot. I'll give it some more time. After running into the limitations, then seeing how the dev intends to work around them. Example, the first time you fly to a planet...... as in SC you must have your warp drive on to see the locations on the planet. Then use the warp drive to fly there as you load into that map. If you fly into the atmosphere it will automatically put you above a target. Either way it's an automated entry process and you have no input until you almost crash into the ground. Once the dev irons out the mechanics and the player isn't lost in the moment the game will be more like a slimmed down version of SC.
MarDanJPL Mar 23, 2023 @ 2:46pm 
Nooooo
ilumino Mar 23, 2023 @ 2:52pm 
Yes. Absolutely.
I would say that SP2 has way more playable content right now than SC. Star Citizen is still just a glorified tech demo. Lots of pretty stuff, but not much to actually do yet.
Last edited by ilumino; Mar 23, 2023 @ 3:01pm
mariovic20 Mar 23, 2023 @ 2:52pm 
NO!!!!
sedman Mar 23, 2023 @ 3:31pm 
1
Originally posted by BalkanBiker:
probably won't play more than 3-5 hours per week and if SpaceBourne 2 is 95% of Star Citizen, then I'll pick SB2.

If you buy SB2, you'll be lucky if you get 3-5 hours sleep in the first few days.
SB2 is the sister you should have married.
ZythaR Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:08am 
The SC reference is hilarious, Sc is on another level totally, an its hilarious. I find it funny just cause have you really played SC? lol.

Sc is like playing next amazing space ship star system game, this is not terribly bad, but the graphics and ships overall areas are totally different by miles. You think about seamless space travel, not cut scenes etc...

Yet they did do good job for 1 person developer for sure.
Last edited by ZythaR; Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:32am
RetroGrade Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:32am 
Cant compare them but I am having more fun currently with Spacebourne 2.
J4N Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:45am 
I have a starter pack for SC and it was worth seeing what SC is at this point. It has its moments but that is mostly based on good graphics. The fidelity is unreached compared to other games. But it lacks gameplay loops and is often nearly unplayable because of disconects, patches that break everything and other gamebreaking bugs that never get fixed. There are enough videos about that. Check youtube.
SC still was worth the price of that starter pack to me, just to the the technological achivements (and its problems). They have invented some interesting systems like their planet tech, which really looks good, but once you did and saw it all, it gets old quickly. The bugs are really frustrating most of the time.
SC tries to reinvent the wheel on every little system they do and fail to do that in most situations. Elevators in ships and stations are often broken. Sometimes your ship just explodes out of nowhere. The game crashes often or you get disconnected from the server again and again. You spawn in space if you log off in your bed inside the ship sometimes and die..
So you die often and loose a lot of stuff. Untill you know all that and find ways around it. The NPCs t-posing on chairs sometimes. And so on. I would still check it out on your own. Get a cheap starter ship when they have a sale and just check it out. The graphics are awesome and worth seeing.

On the other hand there is SpaceBourne 2. It's not multiplayer like SC and never wanted to be. The dev seems to use a lot of assets which is ok to me. He gets some progress done.
You can see placeholders all over the place but somehow it' s not a problem to me. The game is still more fun and encouraging to play than SC (once the screenshot awe is over).
I had a lot of fun already with SpaceBourne 2 and am really hyped for the next update and eveyrthing coming in the future.
The dev just excused himself for not delivering the weekly update:D I mean that is some passion right there. He seems to really work hard on his project and I respect that.
With SC you can be happy if you get an update every 3 month and most of the time it gets shifted because they can't make it work with about 700 employees! and a lot bigger budget.
I think SpaceBourne 2 deserves every support it can get to become an even better game.
Last edited by J4N; Mar 31, 2023 @ 8:48am
SpaceDust Mar 31, 2023 @ 10:01am 
Simple answer NO its not. But its working :steamhappy:
Nostromeo Mar 31, 2023 @ 10:07am 
Not better but it will be completed one day unlike Scam Citizen :happyio:
torrrkon Mar 31, 2023 @ 10:20am 
Originally posted by BalkanBiker:
I don't want a biased, fanboy answer. I want honesty from people who have played both.

I didn't get into Star Citizen because of its higher asking price, as I know I will probably dump €200+ on it because I'm a sucker for collectibles.
This would cost me 10th of Star Citizen price. It's not about cost but time vs money investment. Regardless what I get, I probably won't play more than 3-5 hours per week and if SpaceBourne 2 is 95% of Star Citizen, then I'll pick SB2.
dude, I threw away $ 1,000 on star citizen for all this time, but what I got is nothing compared to this is a live game and the developer is rooting for his business without 550 million, he does what we lacked neither in the elite nor in the star citizen
Cuchilain Mar 31, 2023 @ 10:44am 
Originally posted by sedman:
Originally posted by BalkanBiker:
probably won't play more than 3-5 hours per week and if SpaceBourne 2 is 95% of Star Citizen, then I'll pick SB2.

If you buy SB2, you'll be lucky if you get 3-5 hours sleep in the first few days.
SB2 is the sister you should have married.

Thats so Bama.
Darzik Mar 31, 2023 @ 10:55am 
I'll be completely honest. I have put far more playing time into this than I have into Star Citizen. SC just bored me any time I tried playing alone. And it was a pain to learn only to have things change up on me when I came back months later to try again. I had some fun when some local friends invited me to play with them but the fun was more the fact that we were on a discord chatting and not much the game aspect of it.

SB2 as a solo player is much more entertaining to me. yeah doesn't compare in many other ways as mentioned above but I don't look at this as an SC clone but more a stand alone alternative to games like SC, ED and NMS.
Spidder81 Mar 31, 2023 @ 11:07am 
I play Star Citizen a lot (love it solo and with friends) and bought SB2 last weekend. They are the same but different games in their own right. Im a big space geek (real life and fiction) and also play the likes of NMS, Empyrion and ED (not so much ED these days).

With Star Citizen you do not need to dump a lot of money. I bought the Cutlass Black starter and will not spend anymore money. I will buy other ships with money I earned in game as to me that is a massive part of the game loop. People who spend a ton of real money in SC are the real ones that will miss out. Plus anything in the sub store and all other ships will eventually be findable/buyable in game.

SB2 is an amazing game and is singleplayer. It does things a bit different to what SC is doing so they different games and highly recommend SB2 if you are a fan of this genre of games. Despite its jank (which to me adds to its individual charm) and flaws, the game is a lot more in depth than I ever thought it was before playing it, and just convinced a couple friends to buy it.

If you are still on the fence just buy it, i was on the fence then i leaped off after watcjhing a couple youtubers and havent regretted 1 second of it. I put in 25 hours in the first 2 days I bought it as I could not stop.
Last edited by Spidder81; Mar 31, 2023 @ 11:20am
< >
Showing 1-15 of 110 comments
Per page: 1530 50