What was your favorite and least favorite boss in the game?

[KaiZar]

I define by Boss every Enemy with a boss bar, you can name stalkers too, if you had difficulties with em.

I have to say my favorite Boss is the nameless puppet, cause it reminded me a lot of Souls-Bossfights like Artorias, Orphan of Kos or Soul of Cinder. I liked its pattern, the dodging was well-designed (except for two attacks where you almost had to parry) and it looked cool.

I think my least favorite boss is the Mad Clown Puppet. I beat it one time and skipped it on my second playthrough, I think it's just pretty boring to fight to and the one time I killed her, it took me like 15 minutes.

[Abysswalker]

Favourite: Between Simon Manus and Puppet King
Least Favourite: 2nd Brotherhood Fight

[Napalm®]

Originally posted by Farkus:

Originally posted by Napalm®:

Can that be done after Nameless Puppet? Or I need to start over?

You would need to save scum back to before you beat NP to get the ending.

Ah never mind then, my only save backup was before Walker of Illusions, don't really wanna do rest of the game for the third time.
Thanks!

[Krazy Wallet]

Originally posted by Napalm®:

Originally posted by Krazy Wallet:

At the end of the game, when you have the option to give your heart, you need to refuse.

In order to refuse, I heard you need to have some degree of humanity, but not a lot. Just lie a little and listen to some music.

Hey mate, I need your help again :D
Through the magic of savescumming I went back and defeated the Nameless Puppet, but I did not get the ending with the blue haired puppet girl coming alive.
What did I screw up this time? :D

As someone said, there are three key elements to keeping Sophia alive, which is quite counter-intuitive given the options.

1) Have very high humanity
Lie every chance you get, give stalker greetings to the stalker at the tram, pray at the alter right before the cathedral bonfire, and listen to all the records you pick up. You don't need to do everything, but you do as much as you can to get that humanity.

2) Give Sophia Peace
When you pass Laxasia and find Sophia all melted, you have the option to keep her alive or give her peace. By giving her peace, you will take her Ergo with you. This should give you white hair.

3) Keep your heart
When Geppetto asks for your heart after defeating Simon Manus, click the option to refuse. If you've done it correctly, your end cut scene will start the same once you defeat the Nameless Puppet, but P will start to cry. Do not instantly go into NG+. Load back in after getting the Rise of P achievement and go upstairs. There's a blue letter waiting for you which will give you another achievement for Sophia's story. If you haven't picked it up already, you should be able to get the Golden Lie as well.

Since lying is required, it's difficult to save scum the Rise of P and Free from the Puppet Strings achievements as you build humanity throughout the playthrough. I'm sure there's a threshold of X lies, but I don't know what that number would be. I just played through the game 3 times (4 actually because I made a mistake!) to get all endings.

[Deathwing1306]

I don't really have favorites, but Romeo and Green Monster are quite good.

I hate Walker of Illusions (if that counts as a boss) and Simon so much...

[Bahamut]

I haven't gotten very far, but right now I REALLY hate Fuoco, this as*hole is just not fun to fight and It's taken me dozens of tries.

[opvaskebjørn]

i didn't really find any of the bosses fun, worst for me is probably both the rabbit fights. if i had to pick a fav i'd say victor since he felt the fairest, simon phase 2 feels really good until the arena starts fighting you too.

[2olluxander]

My favorite fight was the King of Puppets. It was between him and the Nameless Puppet, but it didn't take me as long to beat the Nameless Puppet, so King of Puppets wins.

My least favorite was the Door Guardian. Between the Shock mechanic and the invincible metal leg, it's just not a fun fight. In fact, it's the only boss in the game I thought was just flat-out bad.