Can't kill Alidoro or refuse giving heart to Gepetto

[ChaosAndjey]

Started my Truth playthrough on NG+ to get last records and last ending. But stuck with that I cannot kill Alidoro for some reason. Thinking, that I'm not too human or I messed up the glove quest, that didn't answer to Eugenia after getting the response from him. But nevermind, I thought, at least will get the last ending. And in the end, I cannot refuse not to give my heart. I said during the playthrough 3 lies - 1 at the hotel, by the script and 2 times answered correctly to Riddler. Did it really break getting the last ending or is it a bug? Also, want to mention that to do it as fast as possible, I summoned a ghost for every boss fight. Could it also be a reason?

[Dollmaker]

Thats likely a bug

[SadPlatty©]

I thought you had to be human for all that though?

My first run I basically only lied and I answered all of the riddles correctly; then whenever Gepetto locked for an answer I said whatever sounded the nicest.

Managed to kill Alidoro (who also says something like "Such a human move") and then I did have the option to refuse at the end as well. Didn't do an all truth run, but I did look up the endings after beating it the first time and thought only lies mattered.

Edit : Double checked, and Alidoro doesn't seem to be related much to endings, though what you did for Sophia does also. Otherwise - only Rise ending seems to be tied to truths/lies (need max humanity essentially)

[bipoqrlz]

By chance after you beat brotherhood 2.0 and talked to him, did you leave the area before trying to kill him? This is what happened to me on my first run and was locked out of the option to kill him.

[bipoqrlz]

As far as humanity goes, on my current playthrough I lied twice and answered 2 riddles; still has the option to attack

[Apocalyptan]

You probably don't have enough humanity and you're just a puppet. You need some humanity for the refuse endings - it's not only about being truthful with answers as many guides state. Maybe try listening to recordings, or praying at the altar in cathedral? Get some humanity and try again with Alidoro and then with Gepetto.

[BradyBeVibing]

I play on playstation personally, but when googling this bug this was the only post i found that really explained my issue too. I didnt leave the area at all, i immediately ran to him in new game plus (that dark rabbit brotherhood fight is cancer in ng+) and im in the same boat. I asked him why he ratted the hotel out and no option to attack. Im ready to delete the game after all the hours and mental strain this game has put on me for the platinum just for this bs to lock me out of it unless i completely restart the game

[zab]

you will never be a real boy

[Rodi]

Originally posted by ChaosAndjey:

Started my Truth playthrough on NG+ to get last records and last ending. But stuck with that I cannot kill Alidoro for some reason.

You need some humanity in order to go against puppet laws and kill Alidoro or refuse to give your heart to Gepetto.
The game doesn't have an ending based on a truth playthrough. You should always lie in some occasions and make sure you have some humanity.