Pals can't cut trees in base anymore?

[1Erik1]

I noticed that pals assigned to the base are unable to cut down normal trees (not the tree building that is working normal) since the last update. Anyone else having the same issue?

[KellyR]

This sort of thing is why I don't let my pals have any outside area. If everything is covered by foundations, trees won't regrow and my pals don't end up with buggy behavior. I can have the logging structure and the mining structure for wood and stone, no need to have pals mining the naturally spawning ones.

Only exceptions are the bases I make specifically for mining ore/coal/sulfur/quartz obviously.

[Tanyon]

Originally posted by KellyR:

This sort of thing is why I don't let my pals have any outside area. If everything is covered by foundations, trees won't regrow and my pals don't end up with buggy behavior. I can have the logging structure and the mining structure for wood and stone, no need to have pals mining the naturally spawning ones.

Only exceptions are the bases I make specifically for mining ore/coal/sulfur/quartz obviously.

Well this is an actual bug.. I mean.. it needs to be fixed regardless of how you personally like to play.

[Clueless Burger]

Originally posted by Kopparborg:

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

If you get the Bell and click it twice to cycle back to work mode that can reset and fix a lot of your pals not working also to get Fiber just use the crusher I find that's incredibly useful for fiber I just toss a water pal in my team and make work on the crusher to get a lot of fiber real fast there comes a point you'l never need to cut down another tree again in fact in most of my bases there's not a single tree.

Not really helpful as this is a bug report thread

Why is it not helpful?

[resonance]

Originally posted by Clueless Burger:

Originally posted by Kopparborg:

Not really helpful as this is a bug report thread

Why is it not helpful?

Because his advice is for "fixing" pals that are not working. The bug here is not that pals aren't working but that trees have somehow become invincible to base pals. The pals themselves are doing their job just fine so ringing the bell would do nothing at all here.

[Argile]

Having the same issue. Work pals just hit trees and nothing drops. Tested it with party pals and they can cut trees fine.

[АlphaWhelp]

Logging camp works. Trees don't.

[BEEP!]

Originally posted by resonance:

Originally posted by Clueless Burger:

Why is it not helpful?

Because his advice is for "fixing" pals that are not working. The bug here is not that pals aren't working but that trees have somehow become invincible to base pals. The pals themselves are doing their job just fine so ringing the bell would do nothing at all here.

So where in the OPs original post says anything about invisible trees.
And it's almost like I offered more than just ring bell & I even stated it can fix a lot meaning not all problems.

[Mogiaro]

It's not working even for me. I had 4 pal cutting a single tree without dropping a single wood. No comment.

[JHn]

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

Originally posted by resonance:

Because his advice is for "fixing" pals that are not working. The bug here is not that pals aren't working but that trees have somehow become invincible to base pals. The pals themselves are doing their job just fine so ringing the bell would do nothing at all here.

So where in the OPs original post says anything about invisible trees.
And it's almost like I offered more than just ring bell & I even stated it can fix a lot meaning not all problems.

Please stop.

Ringing the bell doesn't fix this, or anything for that matter. I tested it just for you.
If you don't care about the ACTUAL issue, please leave the thread.

Arguing over if you brought anything to the table is moot, because technically you didn't.

Now for everyone that ACTUALLY cares about this issue.

A) IT IS IN FACT, A BUG...
Confirmed repeatable testing. Base Pals with the logging ability will get stuck logging trees in your base, showing damage numbers. However, no items drop nor does the tree fall.
(No "workaround" anyone says here will change that. You are not imagining things. Here are the real "workarounds")
Logging Pals at base will still use the Logging Site. May need to manually assign them to it. This will prevent them attempting to harvest base trees.
Logging Pals in your personal team can still log effectively.

B) NO... Unfortunately ringing the bell does not fix this.
Nor does it actually do anything for "fixing" stuck pals on current version v0.1.4.0

[BEEP!]

Originally posted by JHn:

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

So where in the OPs original post says anything about invisible trees.
And it's almost like I offered more than just ring bell & I even stated it can fix a lot meaning not all problems.

Please stop.

Ringing the bell doesn't fix this, or anything for that matter. I tested it just for you.
If you don't care about the ACTUAL issue, please leave the thread.

Arguing over if you brought anything to the table is moot, because technically you didn't.

Now for everyone that ACTUALLY cares about this issue.

A) IT IS IN FACT, A BUG...
Confirmed repeatable testing. Base Pals with the logging ability will get stuck logging trees in your base, showing damage numbers. However, no items drop nor does the tree fall.
(No "workaround" anyone says here will change that. You are not imagining things. Here are the real "workarounds")
Logging Pals at base will still use the Logging Site. May need to manually assign them to it. This will prevent them attempting to harvest base trees.
Logging Pals in your personal team can still log effectively.

B) NO... Unfortunately ringing the bell does not fix this.
Nor does it actually do anything for "fixing" stuck pals on current version v0.1.4.0

Never said there wasn't a bug & me going out of my way to offer something that could help & offering a tip to help the situation at hand, is now me apparently not caring.
I mentioned the bell because ringing the bell does in fact reset some broken AI & fix some problems with the AI & I said it could help not that it will help I never said that the bell will fix it it's just a tip to help general problems with AI that could possibly help other AI related problems.

Like my god the first few post showed that yes it's a bug so I figured there's no point in me also saying yes it's a bug.
So I offered a tip to help with the fiber issue since they can't chop trees to get fiber, but the logger biulding was fine so I recommend the use of the chopper that way they can still get wood & fiber till the bug was fixed.

Is this some mistranslation or miscommunication or something I know english is my 3rd language but jeez why are some of you people so emotional over someone try to offer advice to help the situation till the bug is fixed.

[[GOD] DIFUNTO666]

same, now I just cut down the trees and plant a small plant pot on top of it to not respawn anymore and use the logging site instead

[Mowerman]

Originally posted by ministrog:

yes all my tree loggers will do the "action" of logging but there's no wood or fiber that drops.

strangely, the loggers in my party can do it just fine.

I notices this too. you can throw them at a tree and they will break it, then go back to this same spot, where there is no tree, and do the animation but nothing occurs. It only happens in certain areas though. My first base is down the hill from the start newbie area, near the decrepit building and the trees there my loggers do just fine with.

[JHn]

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

Originally posted by JHn:

Please stop.

Ringing the bell doesn't fix this, or anything for that matter. I tested it just for you.
If you don't care about the ACTUAL issue, please leave the thread.

Arguing over if you brought anything to the table is moot, because technically you didn't.

Now for everyone that ACTUALLY cares about this issue.

A) IT IS IN FACT, A BUG...
Confirmed repeatable testing. Base Pals with the logging ability will get stuck logging trees in your base, showing damage numbers. However, no items drop nor does the tree fall.
(No "workaround" anyone says here will change that. You are not imagining things. Here are the real "workarounds")
Logging Pals at base will still use the Logging Site. May need to manually assign them to it. This will prevent them attempting to harvest base trees.
Logging Pals in your personal team can still log effectively.

B) NO... Unfortunately ringing the bell does not fix this.
Nor does it actually do anything for "fixing" stuck pals on current version v0.1.4.0

Never said there wasn't a bug & me going out of my way to offer something that could help & offering a tip to help the situation at hand, is now me apparently not caring.
I mentioned the bell because ringing the bell does in fact reset some broken AI & fix some problems with the AI & I said it could help not that it will help.

Like my god the first few post showed that yes it's a bug so I figured there's no point in me also saying yes it's a bug.
So I offered a tip to help with the fiber issue since they can't chop trees to get fiber, but the logger biulding was fine so I recommend the use of the chopper that way they can still get wood & fiber till the bug was fixed.

Is this some mistranslation or miscommunication or something I know english is my 3td language but jeez why are some of you people so emotional over someone try to offer advice to help the situation till the bug is fixed.

Nope. I'm not emotional.
I just don't want to read you argue about something that means absolutely nothing to anyone.

Again, I tested your claim thoroughly.
It doesn't do anything in the current version of the game v0.1.4.0
The current version of the game that Steam says you don't have. Take that for what it is.

If you respond again you are officially trolling, and I will just block you going forward and suggest everyone else does the same.

[BEEP!]

Originally posted by JHn:

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

Never said there wasn't a bug & me going out of my way to offer something that could help & offering a tip to help the situation at hand, is now me apparently not caring.
I mentioned the bell because ringing the bell does in fact reset some broken AI & fix some problems with the AI & I said it could help not that it will help.

Like my god the first few post showed that yes it's a bug so I figured there's no point in me also saying yes it's a bug.
So I offered a tip to help with the fiber issue since they can't chop trees to get fiber, but the logger biulding was fine so I recommend the use of the chopper that way they can still get wood & fiber till the bug was fixed.

Is this some mistranslation or miscommunication or something I know english is my 3td language but jeez why are some of you people so emotional over someone try to offer advice to help the situation till the bug is fixed.

Nope. I'm not emotional.
I just don't want to read you argue about something that means absolutely nothing to anyone.

Again, I tested your claim thoroughly.
It doesn't do anything in the current version of the game v0.1.4.0
The current version of the game that Steam says you don't have. Take that for what it is.

If you respond again you are officially trolling, and I will just block you going forward.

So what your saying is you didn't read the part were I said the bell COULD fix it not that it WILL fix it because the bell can help reset some AI related problems which is why I said something about it because I thought it might help them or at least help them with another AI related problem.

And your also ignoring that I RECOMMENDED the use of the Chopper to get FIBER since they CAN'T get WOOD & FIBER from TREE'S context matters.

All I did was offer a tip to help get around the bug just incase they didn't know about the Chopper.
How is offering advice & a tip trolling....

Also by the way the bug exist in the gamepass version as well so I to have this problem & I got around it with the Chopper & Logger biulding which is again why I recommend using them.

I don't have to talk about the bug because others have already did that so I offered what helped me with the exact same problem.

And what a way to carry a conversation.
(If you respond again you are officially trolling, and I will just block you going forward.)

[Chimie]

Originally posted by 1080puktra:

Originally posted by JHn:

Nope. I'm not emotional.
I just don't want to read you argue about something that means absolutely nothing to anyone.

Again, I tested your claim thoroughly.
It doesn't do anything in the current version of the game v0.1.4.0
The current version of the game that Steam says you don't have. Take that for what it is.

If you respond again you are officially trolling, and I will just block you going forward.

So what your saying is you didn't read the part were I said the bell COULD fix it not that it WILL fix it because the bell can help reset some AI related problems which is why I said something about it because I thought it might help them or at least help them with another AI related problem.

And your also ignoring that I RECOMMENDED the use of the Chopper to get FIBER since they CAN'T get WOOD & FIBER from TREE'S context matters.

All I did was offer a tip to help get around the bug just incase they didn't know about the Chopper.
How is offering advice & a tip trolling....

Also by the way the bug exist in the gamepass version as well so I to have this problem & I got around it with the Chopper & Logger biulding which is again why I recommend using them.

I don't have to talk about the bug because others have already did that so I offered what helped me with the exact same problem.

And what a way to carry a conversation.
(If you respond again you are officially trolling, and I will just block you going forward.)

To summarize this conversation...


"Hey guys my sink seems to be broken, no water is coming out."

"If you go outside find some snow and melt it over a fire, you'll get all the water you'll ever need and you won't even need a sink!"

"Bro that's not the point, we're talking about the sink being broken"

"Why are you mad at me I was just trying to be helpful with other ways to get water"

"Getting water isn't the problem, the problem is my sink is broken"

"And I just gave you other ways to get water..."

"You're missing the point. We aren't struggling to get water, our sink is broken."

"You're a meanie I was just trying to be helpful"

"It wasn't helpful, you're answering a question no one asked, and are distracting from a legitimate bug report"

"English is my 3rd language tho why doesn't anyone recognize me for being helpful?!"