Gothic 1 Remake

Gothic 1 Remake

"Remake"
Tried the Demo just now...

Why do devs think they have to ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ insert their idea of the game nobody asked for?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 21 comments
Ryder Feb 25 @ 7:11am 
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours
chr.toon Feb 25 @ 7:11am 
I think the demo is very good, looking forward for the game!
ne_pavlo Feb 25 @ 7:16am 
next gen animation)))
Johnny Feb 25 @ 7:17am 
Originally posted by Ryder:
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours

Here's your feedback chuddy:

NPC's don't react to your weapon being in your hands
Movement is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Uncancelable animations

And i'm sure there would be more wrong with the game i just didn't bother with this game more because it simply isn't Gothic
Last edited by Johnny; Feb 25 @ 7:18am
chr.toon Feb 25 @ 7:19am 
Originally posted by J:
Originally posted by Ryder:
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours

Here's your feadback chuddy:

NPC's don't react to your weapon being in your hands
Movement is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Uncancelable animations

And i'm sure there would be more wrong with the game i just didn't bother with this game more because it simply isn't Gothic

It has very strong Gothic vibes for sure, its on the right track.
Last edited by chr.toon; Feb 25 @ 7:24am
Originally posted by J:

NPC's don't react to your weapon being in your hands
Movement is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Uncancelable animations

And i'm sure there would be more wrong with the game i just didn't bother with this game more because it simply isn't Gothic
This is gothic alltough.
Jean Feb 25 @ 7:25am 
Originally posted by HEX: 酒鬼:
Originally posted by J:

NPC's don't react to your weapon being in your hands
Movement is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Uncancelable animations

And i'm sure there would be more wrong with the game i just didn't bother with this game more because it simply isn't Gothic
This is gothic alltough.

It is. OP obviously never played Gothic before.
Johnny Feb 25 @ 7:25am 
Originally posted by HEX: 酒鬼:
Originally posted by J:

NPC's don't react to your weapon being in your hands
Movement is ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
Uncancelable animations

And i'm sure there would be more wrong with the game i just didn't bother with this game more because it simply isn't Gothic
This is gothic alltough.

Wdym? If you pulled out your weapon infront of anyone in OG gothic they would scold you and beat your ass eventually???

Movement was normal in original not like this slog moving trough mud

Animations were cancelable you were never locked into an animation

Sure G1 was clunky but it wasnt whatever the ♥♥♥♥ this is. All i can say is that this is certainly better than the PT but its still not Gothic it just has the look of it
Originally posted by J:
Originally posted by HEX: 酒鬼:
This is gothic alltough.

Wdym? If you pulled out your weapon infront of anyone in OG gothic they would scold you and beat your ass eventually???

Movement was normal in original not like this slog moving trough mud

Animations were cancelable you were never locked into an animation

Sure G1 was clunky but it wasnt whatever the ♥♥♥♥ this is. All i can say is that this is certainly better than the PT but its still not Gothic it just has the look of it
In 2001 Gothic had top tier animations.
Last edited by Maximum997; Feb 25 @ 7:27am
Originally posted by Ryder:
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours
They got their feedback in 2019. The feedback was "stay close to the original, don't do your own thing because your own thing, which was the playable teaser, sucked". But they couldn't help themselves and now everything feels, looks and sounds like an entirely different game. I just played the demo and it feels like an okay game. It's sluggish and blocking is beyond inconsistent but if it doesn't cost more than 40-50 Euros I'll probably buy it. But I never got the feeling I'm playing a Gothic game. And that's not surprising. I'm hunting tiny velociraptors in a sunbaked mediterranean location with a completely different protagonist.
Last edited by リアンダ; Feb 25 @ 7:36am
Johnny Feb 25 @ 7:34am 
Originally posted by リアンダ:
Originally posted by Ryder:
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours
They got their feedback in 2019. The feedback was "stay close to the original, don't do your own thing because your own thing, the playable teaser sucked". But they couldn't help themselves and now everything feels, looks and sounds like an entirely different game. I just played the demo and it feels like an okay game. It's sluggish and blocking is beyond inconsistent but if it doesn't cost more than 40-50 euros I'll probably buy it. But I never got the feeling I'm playing a Gothic game. And that's not surprising. I'm hunting tiny velociraptors in a sunbaked mediterranean location with a completely different protagonist.
Couldn't say it better.
Originally posted by リアンダ:
Originally posted by Ryder:
Thanks to this feedback, developers will now know what they need to do 100%
We need more constructive feedbacks like yours
They got their feedback in 2019. The feedback was "stay close to the original, don't do your own thing because your own thing, the playable teaser sucked". But they couldn't help themselves and now everything feels, looks and sounds like an entirely different game. I just played the demo and it feels like an okay game. It's sluggish and blocking is beyond inconsistent but if it doesn't cost more than 40-50 euros I'll probably buy it. But I never got the feeling I'm playing a Gothic game. And that's not surprising. I'm hunting tiny velociraptors in a sunbaked mediterranean location with a completely different protagonist.
Yep. It looks like every other UE5 medieval ARPG. Has bad performance as every UE5 game.
And has the same combat system as every single ARPG since Witcher 3, just badly animated, slow and clunky
Last edited by Maximum997; Feb 25 @ 7:37am
リアンダ Feb 25 @ 7:45am 
Originally posted by J:
Originally posted by HEX: 酒鬼:
This is gothic alltough.

Wdym? If you pulled out your weapon infront of anyone in OG gothic they would scold you and beat your ass eventually???

Movement was normal in original not like this slog moving trough mud

Animations were cancelable you were never locked into an animation

Sure G1 was clunky but it wasnt whatever the ♥♥♥♥ this is. All i can say is that this is certainly better than the PT but its still not Gothic it just has the look of it
I made a meme just for that occasion. It's a bit older but I have a feeling you'll like it :)

https://imgur.com/a/HViJd9I
chr.toon Feb 25 @ 7:53am 
Originally posted by J:
Originally posted by リアンダ:
They got their feedback in 2019. The feedback was "stay close to the original, don't do your own thing because your own thing, the playable teaser sucked". But they couldn't help themselves and now everything feels, looks and sounds like an entirely different game. I just played the demo and it feels like an okay game. It's sluggish and blocking is beyond inconsistent but if it doesn't cost more than 40-50 euros I'll probably buy it. But I never got the feeling I'm playing a Gothic game. And that's not surprising. I'm hunting tiny velociraptors in a sunbaked mediterranean location with a completely different protagonist.
Couldn't say it better.

Better than stalker 2 for sure!
< >
Showing 1-15 of 21 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 25 @ 7:04am
Posts: 21