Gothic 1 Remake

Gothic 1 Remake

Original game is smooth compared to this.
I feel like i am controlling coal wagon instead of human character, pls hire some1 who knows how to make good movement/controlls and rewrite this from scratch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lScEVn1ryF4

Edit: added random youtube clip.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0TwvCpD8Ik

Edit2: Another one with movement
Last edited by Thats How We do action in Uganda; Feb 24 @ 3:44pm
< >
Showing 1-14 of 14 comments
I have to agree with you.
So the first part may be clunky and from a different time, but this is really bad. an old man in a wheelchair would be easier to control than this.
Bliccer Feb 24 @ 2:41pm 
Isnt the original also pretty slow. Character needs to start running walking?
Daruwind Feb 24 @ 2:43pm 
Agree, world is nice, responding but characters feels as after smoking tons of weed. Pickaxe as weapon was always slow but this...movement, attacking...Too much slow for start.
realism momentum movement thats why. probably crank it down little bit.
happyPig Feb 24 @ 2:44pm 
Originally posted by Bliccer:
Isnt the original also pretty slow. Character needs to start running walking?
Indeed.
But combat in OG is lightning fast and I prefer the slow one of the remake where I actually can react and do something instead of predicting.
TheXell Feb 24 @ 2:46pm 
Gotta agree, "realism" is never an excuse for movement that feels unsatisfying or clunky.
Bliccer Feb 24 @ 2:48pm 
I myself am absolutely happy about the slowness, movement and that nothing gets explained - no weird tooltips popping up. Feels as if devs trust the player for once that they are intelligent enough to understand a game...

Not sure how progression will help to master one or two handed weapons, but for me it actually feels like that weapon - a stupid pickaxe with this size, if lifted wrong can throw you backwards, actually has weight to the swing. Like it
Sadly, I have to agree. This game doesn't feel good to me. If you're going to remake something, it can't just look better, it should feel better than the original given how things have evolved. It feels slow and clunky, completely unsatisfying. Also, i don't particularly care for the look of the game. While the original has a charm to it, this remake just looks very bland to me.
DaS Feb 24 @ 2:53pm 
I get the realism argument, but this doesn't feel real it feels like input lag. If you want real do mo cap of a real person turning.

EDIT at the moment I'm bouncing off, barrier to entry for me. I loved 1 and two but I don't recall this feeling (and yea could be rose colored glasses) I'll go get out side a case and see if that helps. see ya in a few
Last edited by DaS; Feb 24 @ 3:01pm
Sadly to say, but the movement in the prologue is highly unsatisfying and feels really clunky; like, there is a roundabout each time we change direction... and the cicle between walk/run... oh man, please... NO! I wanted to keep playing, but it was so frustrating that I ended up turning it off.
Originally posted by Bliccer:
Isnt the original also pretty slow. Character needs to start running walking?
Nope movement in original is instant, also most actions including combat attacks are like 50% faster.
Sven. Feb 24 @ 3:27pm 
agree
DaS Feb 24 @ 3:31pm 
6 pack in, no noticeable improvement, but I care a bit less
Radam Feb 24 @ 4:29pm 
Booted up the old G1 install, definitely feels smoother there.
< >
Showing 1-14 of 14 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 24 @ 2:23pm
Posts: 14