The Planet Crafter

The Planet Crafter

View Stats:
saliddry Apr 14, 2024 @ 12:33pm
4
3 BAD ENDINGS ? thats it ???
go back to the ♥♥♥♥ company that sent you there to ave sucess or die and be put back into prison for unanounced amount of time ..most like get locked away forever

go with smugglers who from text will most likely take the crystals and vent you into space...

or with this guardian portal ... and end up on an death world and guardians are long extinct and most likely die there ..remember all the other terraformers that got booted into bad regions and died there with 0 chance ..you have seen there left behind messages


so wtf is that? i ruins the game for me

give us some alien cannon like in subnautica or chance to reconfigure the anomaly you block all ships from entering + communication you can peacyfully live on that planet .. maybe get the new guardian and make clones with all that technologie and repopulate the planet ... or an animal mixed with your dna a new intelligent species save within that system cause anomaly bubble .....

just an short end story i dont want that all added into the game .... but this 3 possible exit storys just suck all the ♥♥♥♥ you did was in vain...
Last edited by saliddry; Apr 14, 2024 @ 12:41pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 57 comments
Phoenix Cat Apr 14, 2024 @ 1:08pm 
Wow, guess your not happy... :steamsad:
saliddry Apr 14, 2024 @ 1:13pm 
nah why cant there be an good ending? feel the same as mass effect 3 endings everyone was raging about
maestro Apr 14, 2024 @ 2:05pm 
The reason why people raged about Mess Effect, is because they made a big stink out of "CHOICES MATTER" and at the end, you got the Red Pill, Blue Pill, or Green Pill choices, and here's the important part, regardless of the choices you made during the 3 games.

That's the part that PO'd everybody.

They made a big stink out of "CHOICES MATTER" but in the end, you could have been the most evil Renegade or the most Saintly of Paragons, and you got the same 3 choices with the same 3 outcomes, and all three endings of the game were exactly the same regardless of what you did.

It wasn't that the endings were bad (well, they were, kinda), it was that they went back on the very thing they advertised from the start of the series.
Last edited by maestro; Apr 14, 2024 @ 2:07pm
wyldfae28 Apr 14, 2024 @ 2:24pm 
2
I hear you. We either get jailed again indefinitely because Riley helped us with trade rockets and stuff. God forbid Sentinel would just be happy we built a freaking paradise planet for them to exploit. They actually said we would be freed. Right.

OR we follow the Wardens (which is kinda dumb anyway because the Wardens hate humans) don't know how that was ever supposed to turn out well.

OR We turn to a life of crime with shady people after spending all this time redeeming our LAST crime in the most spectacular way possible by managing to terraform a world that killed a bunch of other convicts.

PLUS the millions in hard cash we may now have accumulated goes where? AND our only "friend" will never be able to contact us again. AND we leave behind all the hard work we did for what, exactly?


Sucks all around. I love this game. It's a brilliant success in so many ways. But I'll just stay on my planet, thanks.
Last edited by wyldfae28; Apr 14, 2024 @ 2:26pm
maestro Apr 14, 2024 @ 3:34pm 
Originally posted by wyldfae28:
Sucks all around. I love this game. It's a brilliant success in so many ways. But I'll just stay on my planet, thanks.

Maybe that's the whole point of the game's endings.

The patch notes say it is "POSSIBLE" to end the game. In no way does it say you should. You know that famous line in Jurassic Park... "you spent so much time asking if you could that you never asked if you should".

Maybe the bad outcomes are the game's way of saying "you created your own paradise, maybe you should just enjoy it for the rest of your life"?

Is Homesteading on a planet you custom tailored to your own liking such a bad prospect?
Last edited by maestro; Apr 14, 2024 @ 3:39pm
wyldfae28 Apr 14, 2024 @ 6:29pm 
Originally posted by maestro:
Originally posted by wyldfae28:
Sucks all around. I love this game. It's a brilliant success in so many ways. But I'll just stay on my planet, thanks.

Maybe that's the whole point of the game's endings.

The patch notes say it is "POSSIBLE" to end the game. In no way does it say you should. You know that famous line in Jurassic Park... "you spent so much time asking if you could that you never asked if you should".

Maybe the bad outcomes are the game's way of saying "you created your own paradise, maybe you should just enjoy it for the rest of your life"?

Is Homesteading on a planet you custom tailored to your own liking such a bad prospect?

I don't know if it's the point of the endings or not. I would doubt it, the devs aren't usually that subtle.

However, homesteading on my planet is not a bad prospect at all. Lol. I assume I am somewhat nuts by now as that's what tends to happen to humans who have zero social contact. If they provided an ending in which Riley came to join me that would have been perfect as far as I'm concerned. I really don't want to leave. It's beautiful on my planet, where would I go that's better?.

If Sentinel hadn't been complete @$$hats, honored their word, offered to allow Riley to come, and went about respectfully colonizing the new Eden I created, that would have been a great ending. As it stands, I'm content to remain here and play in my sandbox and wait for Miju to hopefully make more content for the game. But better endings would have shown more respect for the player's accomplishment in my opinion.
Last edited by wyldfae28; Apr 14, 2024 @ 6:30pm
Thornwood Apr 14, 2024 @ 6:46pm 
I like to replay the game.

The 3 different endings let you play the game your way.

I do not like grinding the trading system for tokens or repeating the alien quest line. The Sentinel choice is the obvious choice for my personal preferences.

Others like to play it differently, so their personal preferences will lead to a different ending.

From a game play perspective, I like that the developers have given us a choice in how we play the game. It is brilliant compromise between different personal preferences.

I do agree the ending is dark. I personally prefer a more upbeat ending.
Katzenkopf Apr 14, 2024 @ 7:30pm 
It would be nice, the developers gave us a 4th ending - to reactivate the warden´s spaceships I found in a cave and to leave this planet on my own to travel through the space and to terraform other PLanets.
Mr Tophat Apr 14, 2024 @ 8:12pm 
Originally posted by Katzenkopf:
It would be nice, the developers gave us a 4th ending - to reactivate the warden´s spaceships I found in a cave and to leave this planet on my own to travel through the space and to terraform other PLanets.
If we are doing this the better path might not be terraforming but instead try to save other terraformers and bring them back to your planet
wyldfae28 Apr 14, 2024 @ 11:50pm 
Originally posted by Mr Tophat:
Originally posted by Katzenkopf:
It would be nice, the developers gave us a 4th ending - to reactivate the warden´s spaceships I found in a cave and to leave this planet on my own to travel through the space and to terraform other PLanets.
If we are doing this the better path might not be terraforming but instead try to save other terraformers and bring them back to your planet


Oooh, that would be fun! I always thought that huge ship sitting in dry dock in some cave was a total waste. If I were to leave my planet at all, it would def be on that ship. That way, I'd be the only one who could return as the Warden ship would probably not be affected by the planet's defenses. Although I'd be more tempted to go get Riley. No telling how crazy the other crafters might be after years on a desolate world. Lol.
archmag Apr 15, 2024 @ 12:05am 
3
Look more like three good endings to me.

1. Following wardens - leave your deals with humans behind, flee from imprisonment, go terraform a new planet, maybe discover more things that happened with the elder race. Travel around galaxy through portals terraforming one dead planet after another. Personally my choice and maybe hints at Planet Crafter 2. "Loner" path.

2. Going with Sentinel Corps - prisoner with a criminal sentence on review is better than prisoner with a criminal sentence, didn't we come to this planet for this? So we are in a better position than we were in the very beginning. We are working on our debts to society and maybe will earn a pardon one day. At least we made the first step now. One step may not be enough so we may end up being sent to another planet to terraform, hints at Planet Crafter 2, where we are again sent to some barren planet to pay for our criminal deads in the past. "Pacifist" path.

3. Going with Smugglers (didn't get this one yet, will get it today) - unless they clearly say that smugglers kill you sounds like a going back to crime route. You pay them their fee 500k credits and 5 yellow crystals, but if those crystals are worth anything you also have a knowledge on how to make more, so it is profitable for them to keep you alive. And remember that you are initially a criminal with a pretty heavy sentence where sending you to death on a barren planet is considered a better thing than just waiting it out. So you know the criminal ways and with the extra knowledge of being able to terraform whole planets you are a great asset in any criminal hands. This hints at Planet Crafter 2 where we control an organization terraforming planets and earning income from that. And there is also a chance to meet Riley, whoever she/he is. "Criminal baron" path.

So yeah, three good endings - "Loner" (travel alone, explore new planets, find history behind wardens culture), "Pacifist" (leaves control in Sentinel Corps hands, keep paying for your previous crimes), "Criminal baron" (back to crime, now in charge of a new organization, romance route with Riley).
Steve Apr 15, 2024 @ 2:36am 
Can you get all 3 endings on one save, or do you have to replay it for the others?
archmag Apr 15, 2024 @ 2:51am 
Originally posted by Steve:
Can you get all 3 endings on one save, or do you have to replay it for the others?
You should save before using the rocket to accept the ending. I think they also autosave you at the same moment. So yeah, you can get all three on single save. I got two, reloaded, working on my third on the same save.
Last edited by archmag; Apr 15, 2024 @ 2:51am
maestro Apr 15, 2024 @ 4:53am 
Originally posted by wyldfae28:
Originally posted by maestro:

Maybe that's the whole point of the game's endings.

The patch notes say it is "POSSIBLE" to end the game. In no way does it say you should. You know that famous line in Jurassic Park... "you spent so much time asking if you could that you never asked if you should".

Maybe the bad outcomes are the game's way of saying "you created your own paradise, maybe you should just enjoy it for the rest of your life"?

Is Homesteading on a planet you custom tailored to your own liking such a bad prospect?

I don't know if it's the point of the endings or not. I would doubt it, the devs aren't usually that subtle.

However, homesteading on my planet is not a bad prospect at all. Lol. I assume I am somewhat nuts by now as that's what tends to happen to humans who have zero social contact. If they provided an ending in which Riley came to join me that would have been perfect as far as I'm concerned. I really don't want to leave. It's beautiful on my planet, where would I go that's better?.

If Sentinel hadn't been complete @$$hats, honored their word, offered to allow Riley to come, and went about respectfully colonizing the new Eden I created, that would have been a great ending. As it stands, I'm content to remain here and play in my sandbox and wait for Miju to hopefully make more content for the game. But better endings would have shown more respect for the player's accomplishment in my opinion.

If you continue to Homestead on the planet, you have the added bonus of being (mostly) sure that nobody is going to come and take your planet away from you, thanks to the Wardens' little surprise assuming you left it alone.

Anybody that tries anything is gonna get a nasty surprise, lol.
archmag Apr 15, 2024 @ 5:36am 
Originally posted by maestro:
If you continue to Homestead on the planet, you have the added bonus of being (mostly) sure that nobody is going to come and take your planet away from you, thanks to the Wardens' little surprise assuming you left it alone.

Anybody that tries anything is gonna get a nasty surprise, lol.
Why not? Ships crash, but personel still can be armed and take everything from you if they survive. Many people crashed or were sent successfully to this planet before and survived for up to 20 years even with conditions worse than they are now and without a multitool. They can easily send a special force, sacrifice a ship or just send pods similar to yours but with armed personel and take control from you if you suddenly decide to oppose them. They didn't give you any recipes which can be used as defense and all those guns lying around seems unsalvageable.

Your only advantage was that there may be hundreds of such prisoners sent to different planets with low success rate of successful terraformation and controlled by automated systems. But at the last few message you have a text that it is not an automated message anymore so they are looking specifically at your planet now and whatever you decide will affect your fate. It's just how patient they are with you now, you completed their main task, they only give you the last mission as a final test. They don't need you specifically to complete it.

They know that this planet has this surprise - you can find a crashed ship which was sent to investigate the issue. They will know the coordinates of the anomaly after their forces land and take the base from you as it is directly displayed on the launch rocket panel. Then even know how to deal with it as they sent you a recipe for the bomb.

Holing up is useless if you try to do it forever (not in game though but in lore). You just lose any chance on redemption on your crime because the initial agreements says that you have no right to own anything on the planet, but well, at least you get a nice vacation away from the prison.

What you should have done was to prolong the terraformation process - the longer it goes, the more time you have without them noticing you. That is if you really want to be alone on this lonely planet instead of taking a risk taking any of the three other offers.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 57 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Apr 14, 2024 @ 12:33pm
Posts: 57