Myst
em_t_hed Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:18pm
Blue, Red, or White?
??

I got the roommates ending and honestly, all things considered seems the best ending right now.

None of what the 3 say sound better to me....

Blue, Red, or White?
Last edited by em_t_hed; Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:21pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 57 comments
Zapix Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:32pm 
white page is technically the proper ending.
em_t_hed Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:44pm 
Originally posted by Zapix:
white page is technically the proper ending.

Technically how? Because by what the Father says... He was victim to all the power and greed he fought against with his sons.

The wife put him there and died making sure all 3 stayed in their books...

Or that is how the blanks in the story fill out in my mind
Henry Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:51pm 
No.
Zapix Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:58pm 
Atrus is far from a bad guy. His sons on the other hand grew greedy with the power of their bloodline and the world Atrus created. Was fortunate they sprung the trap set for them. Note with the white page, Atrus also lets you come and go as you please and to use the books. Not that this has any impact on the game itself. Lore wise, Atrus is pretty cool.

Also Catherine isn't dead, nor did she put him there. Dunno where you picked up that idea! I think you've been dipping into Achenar's kool aid lol
Last edited by Zapix; Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:02pm
em_t_hed Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:03pm 
Originally posted by Zapix:
Atrus is far from a bad guy. His sons on the other hand grew greedy with the power of their bloodline and the world Atrus created. Was fortunate they sprung the trap set for them. Note with the white page, Atrus also lets you come and go as you please and to use the books. Not that this has any impact on the game itself. Lore wise, Atrus is pretty cool.
Also Catherine isn't dead, nor did she put him there. Dunno where you picked up that idea!


The tombstone across from the library surrounded by blue flowers. the brothers talking about someone being a murderer...
Henry Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:20pm 
The tombstone is not Catherine’s. It was not there in original game, was added in RealMyst I think. It’s Ti’Ana’s, Atrus’ Grandma I think...
Rezeero Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:21pm 
Originally posted by em_t_hed:
The tombstone across from the library surrounded by blue flowers. the brothers talking about someone being a murderer...

That tombstone actually belongs to Ti'anna - Atrus' grandmother. It was an interesting choice to make the text in D'ni in this version of the game, as the original Myst had it in English.
Zapix Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:21pm 
miss the note and the message that Atrus left for Catherine?
Zapix Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:23pm 
Ti'ana... She was a nice lady, did a fine job raising Atrus. His father is a total pos.
This comes from having read the first book.
Last edited by Zapix; Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:23pm
em_t_hed Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:27pm 
ok so i have to have read the novels then.... smh
ghost wolves Aug 31, 2021 @ 5:56pm 
Originally posted by em_t_hed:
ok so i have to have read the novels then.... smh

Yeah you do. Probably the only game series I can think of where the novels are required. The good news is they're quite good.
Adeon Aug 31, 2021 @ 7:39pm 
"Roomates" achivement ending is a bad ending. There are three bad endings and one good "ending", which will lead into the next game, Riven.

(Technically the good ending doesn't end - no credits roll.)
Last edited by Adeon; Aug 31, 2021 @ 7:40pm
LucidEpyon Sep 1, 2021 @ 2:17am 
It can be a bit hard to follow the full story the first time playing (reading the first novel fills in a lot, but is not requited as it is a bridge between the first and second game). To summarize what is going on:


Atrus has the power to write Ages/Linking books, he sees himself as an adventurer but some of the inhabitants of the worlds he goes to sees him as a god. When his sons are old enough to travel with him, he takes them to some of his Ages. And after some time he is comfortable letting his sons travel alone.

Over time the brothers become corrupt and see themselves as superiors to the inhabitants of each of the ages and they start to lord over them. I think Atrus finds out and there is some kind of falling out between them (the exact nature of what this looks like is never covered in the games or books).

To "get back" at their dad the brothers burn most of the linking books and they trap their mother in Riven, a dying world. In order to stabilize Riven and save Catherine, Atrus travels to D'ni (this is why he is always writing in a book at the end). Before he left, the brothers devised a plan to take one page out of his Myst linking book, essentially trapping their father in D'ni. They think their father is as good as dead (they likely assumed is linked into the unstable Riven), and this is the "murder" they keep talking about.

Once free from their father, the bothers decide to travel to the forbidden ages of the red and blue books, not knowing that both of the books were traps Atrus set up many years ago in case any greedy travelers stumbled across Myst.

The first book and Riven both go much deeper into Atrus, Atrus's father, and Catherine's stories and how exactly this family got so messed up. The book also explains that the grave is Atrus's grandmother (likely the last decent person in their family before all the drama took hold).
Last edited by LucidEpyon; Sep 1, 2021 @ 2:19am
MaGi Sep 2, 2021 @ 9:06pm 
I wouldn't say the novels are "required". Let's not go scaring off the new players telling them to read three novels to enjoy a video game :)

You can perfectly enjoy the first two games, or indeed the whole series, without reading any books. There's enough detail in the in-game journals and environmental clues to give you all of the information required to understand the direct plot of the games.

If you read the novels, you will understand more about the characters and their motivations. The first novel (Book of Atrus) is the most relevant to the first two games. It's a prequel to Myst, and it goes into deep detail about Atrus, Catherine and Atrus's father (who you will meet if you continue into the sequel Riven). It's also easily the best book in the series.

The other two novels are much less important and I would only recommend it if you're a huge fan of the series and want to know all the lore. The second novel (Book of Ti'ana) goes into ancient history of the D'ni civilization, which isn't directly relevant to any game unless you play the spinoff title Uru. The third novel (Book of D'ni) is set in between Riven and Myst 3, and is the most skippable. It is mentioned in passing at the start of Myst 3, and has some thematic significance in Uru, but that's about it.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 57 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Aug 31, 2021 @ 4:18pm
Posts: 57