Achievements not unlocking

[Harrikiri]

I´m trying to do some of the achievements and it is very inconsistent. I tried the "The G.O.D. of O.S.P." (no loadout)
I killed now charlie and Fia several times with the flooding but this doesn´t work. I also didn´t kill any Eternalist, but "Only the guilty" didn´t unlock.
Later I did the achievement were I kill both with a single bullet and here it unlocked "Silent Disco" and "Only the guilty".

I beat the game obviously and killed several visionaries but "Play It Again, Colt" is still not unlock.
I read that there were problems in the past, but they should have been fixed. Maybe the new patch introduced them again. Does anyone have definitive information regarding this?

[M1K4]

I was able to unlock all the achievements except "Play It Again, Colt"

[苍井松岛玛利亚]

关于“柯尔特，再玩一次”的完成描述不准确，简略了很多东西。
一、条件补充
“通关一次游戏”，的确是指完成“一了百了”任务，但注意该任务有隐藏环节，要求杀死第9先知，所以你得先杀朱莉安娜，然后跳下去自杀。所以，只能选择打破循环结局。
“杀掉地图上的所有先知者并逃离”，注意这里描述的地图是具有排他性的，但并未限制时间段。也就是说要杀死一张地图上在所有时间段存在的所有先知且不能去其他地图。
二、真实能拿到该奖杯流程
1、重玩“一了百了”任务，杀朱莉安娜，然后自杀完成破循环结局。
2、看到恭喜完成游戏的提示并重新进游戏后，立即选择卡儿湾地图，杀了哈丽雅特并破坏弗兰克的烟花装置。
3、跳过中午和下午。
4、晚上时间再进入卡儿湾地图，听完广播并等到弗兰克自爆后，退出地图，拿到奖杯。

[WesmanPipes]

I have about 5 different ones that aren't unlocking. May have to go to Arkanes site and post there. Doesn't seem like they visit this board like some developers do.

[M1K4]

Originally posted by 苍井松岛玛利亚:

关于“柯尔特，再玩一次”的完成描述不准确，简略了很多东西。
一、条件补充
“通关一次游戏”，的确是指完成“一了百了”任务，但注意该任务有隐藏环节，要求杀死第9先知，所以你得先杀朱莉安娜，然后跳下去自杀。所以，只能选择打破循环结局。
“杀掉地图上的所有先知者并逃离”，注意这里描述的地图是具有排他性的，但并未限制时间段。也就是说要杀死一张地图上在所有时间段存在的所有先知且不能去其他地图。
二、真实能拿到该奖杯流程
1、重玩“一了百了”任务，杀朱莉安娜，然后自杀完成破循环结局。
2、看到恭喜完成游戏的提示并重新进游戏后，立即选择卡儿湾地图，杀了哈丽雅特并破坏弗兰克的烟花装置。
3、跳过中午和下午。
4、晚上时间再进入卡儿湾地图，听完广播并等到弗兰克自爆后，退出地图，拿到奖杯。

Holy moly, that actually worked! With that I managed to unlock all the achievements! Thx mate

[Blockenstein]

Definitely still broken, or at least 'Judgement Day' and 'Spice of Life' are. Shelving this for now. I figure there's no point in trying for any of the others I'm missing only to discover they're bugged after I put the time in.

I really hope they fix this soon. I'd like to wrap up the few missing achievements before I move onto my next game.

[M1K4]

Those are not broken, they are just hard. "Judgement day" took me like 15 tries to get

[Harrikiri]

Ok I have now all the achievements. Most of them finally worked more or less as designed.
"Play it again, Colt" is just weird. Some guys on the discord channel really helped out.

For the achievement you need to complete the game or the loop and then go to KB. Kill Harriet and sabotage the fireworks, because it seems that the game thinks that Frank is also part of this map. Also kill any invading Julianna just to be sure.
Leave the map and come back to KARLS BAY in the evening and just wait until Frank is dead.
Leave the map and I got it. Again: Karly Bay in the evening is important. I went to Updaam in my first try because out of habit.

For some other problematic achievement, where every guide says kill Charlie and Fia with the water in the pump station. Don´t do that, it doesn´t work anymore. For GOD with OSP you need to kill the physically (grenades and slash them with the machete for instance)

Judgement Day and Spice of Life worked for me normally. Judgement Day is hard though, because Harriet mostly ignites the gas clouds and dies like that, but she must day from the gas, not from the explosion.

[Peach]

Originally posted by M1K4:

Those are not broken, they are just hard. "Judgement day" took me like 15 tries to get

It's ABSOLUTELY broken. I've finished all other achievement instead of "play it again colt", and I've tried many different ways including the one in Chinese above but still cannot work. I sent email to Bethesda support but seems like they are not helpful for the achievement

[Harrikiri]

I also contacted Bethesda support. Needless to say, that they were absolutely no help. They told me, they cannot do anything and it has something to do with steam, even though the game patches each time had fixes for achievements in them. Oh, well, normal customer support.

Have you tried the way I described it? It is absolutely insane, but for me it worked, after nothing else worked.

[Peach]

Originally posted by Harrikiri:

I also contacted Bethesda support. Needless to say, that they were absolutely no help. They told me, they cannot do anything and it has something to do with steam, even though the game patches each time had fixes for achievements in them. Oh, well, normal customer support.

Have you tried the way I described it? It is absolutely insane, but for me it worked, after nothing else worked.

YES, I killed Harriet in the morning, sabotage the firework, skip to the evening and escape till Frank's death, but the achievement still did not pop up. But I think I gonna go through these steps again though I am really tired of doing this.

[Harrikiri]

It could be that you have to complete a whole loop before with killing Juliette and yourself and then do the Harriet/Frank thing.

[Peach]

Originally posted by Harrikiri:

It could be that you have to complete a whole loop before with killing Juliette and yourself and then do the Harriet/Frank thing.

bro😂 definitely I do it after the whole loop. I even tried to kill Juliana in different ways

[rkeezy]

When did you try to get Judgement Day? I've probably put in 30 attempts - yes there are some explosion deaths, but kicking her into the gas, or even tele-swapping her always kills her but the achievement never pops. I'm 53/54 and simply can't get this to unlock.

[Peach]

Originally posted by rkeezy:

When did you try to get Judgement Day? I've probably put in 30 attempts - yes there are some explosion deaths, but kicking her into the gas, or even tele-swapping her always kills her but the achievement never pops. I'm 53/54 and simply can't get this to unlock.

Just do what i say next and you can unlock that, TRUST ME. Use the pistol with gas to kill her and DONT try other way.
Before killing Harriet, silently kill the people surround her. Then use your shot to knock her to the ground and spread the gas with your shot but DONT shoot her. The achievement only pop when she dies with the gas but not your bullet. If she stands up again, do the same loop: knock her to the ground, spread the gas with your shot.

[Blockenstein]

Originally posted by 𝓹𝓮𝓪𝓬𝓱:

Just do what i say next and you can unlock that, TRUST ME. Use the pistol with gas to kill her and DONT try other way.
Before killing Harriet, silently kill the people surround her. Then use your shot to knock her to the ground and spread the gas with your shot but DONT shoot her. The achievement only pop when she dies with the gas but not your bullet. If she stands up again, do the same loop: knock her to the ground, spread the gas with your shot.

It. Doesn't. Work.

I get that it worked for you, but I have done that exact thing at least a dozen times and it doesn't work. The achievement is not working. No amount of people saying, "it worked for me" is going to make it work for the rest of us. It is BROKEN.

And it needs to be fixed.