Is this the easiest Souls game to 100%?

[TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire]

Think about it, they’ve sold at least fourteen million copies on Steam. 10% of the players got the 100% trophy which means at least 1.4 million people managed this great feat. Does this make it easier to 100% than the rest, or is just because of the scaling that it makes it appear easier.

Edit: I’m not saying it’s easy; I’m just wondering. I’ve never 100% a single Souls game.

[HumbertoDiabetes]

Good evening warrior, as we all know, get all achievements FromSoftware games is not difficult, even my grandmother can do it, the real focus is on getting good at PvP and crushing the randoms

[TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire]

Originally posted by csand:

Yes, I would say, largely because you don't need to grind covenant items to do it

That actually makes perfect sense

Originally posted by HumbertoDiabetes:

Good evening warrior, as we all know, get all achievements FromSoftware games is not difficult, even my grandmother can do it, the real focus is on getting good at PvP and crushing the randoms :er_uwu:

lol

[JellyPuff]

Not necessarily the easiest, but definitely the least grindy and most entertaining one to 100%, because there aren't any covenants to farm thirty ~1% drop-chance items for.

With every Dark Souls, there's at least one doodad that requires to play roughly half-way to NG++ with the same character (Sif-boss weapon in DS1, BoB/BS covenant spells in DS2 and Life Ring+3 in DS3). And while you do need to beat the game at least 3 times to 100% ER, it's only for the different endings which you can get on 3 different characters, so you can make each playthrough feel fresh with an entirely new build. No achievement requires NG+ or beyond.

[theseeker52]

Originally posted by TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire:

Think about it, they’ve sold at least fourteen million copies on Steam. 10% of the players got the 100% trophy which means at least 1.4 million people managed this great feat. Does this make it easier to 100% than the rest, or is just because of the scaling that it makes it appear easier.

Edit: I’m not saying it’s easy; I’m just wondering. I’ve never 100% a single Souls game.

Easy ? No ! Still.. the mechanics are unique, for single players, who don't care to get invaded, then the spirit summons , used as a distraction buying you time . So, bottom line, more people play that don't want to be dependent on co-op , if they are single players .

[seouilms109]

definitely the easiest to 100% achievements

[causality]

Easiest/fastest to 100% is probably Sekiro or Bloodborne since both these games are really short.

[TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire]

Originally posted by JellyPuff:

Not necessarily the easiest, but definitely the least grindy and most entertaining one to 100%, because there aren't any covenants to farm thirty ~1% drop-chance items for.

With every Dark Souls, there's at least one doodad that requires to play roughly half-way to NG++ with the same character (Sif-boss weapon in DS1, BoB/BS covenant spells in DS2 and Life Ring+3 in DS3). And while you do need to beat the game at least 3 times to 100% ER, it's only for the different endings which you can get on 3 different characters, so you can make each playthrough feel fresh with an entirely new build. No achievement requires NG+ or beyond.

Makes sense.

Originally posted by causality:

Easiest/fastest to 100% is probably Sekiro or Bloodborne since both these games are really short.

Haven’t heard that before.

Originally posted by theseeker52:

Originally posted by TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire:

Think about it, they’ve sold at least fourteen million copies on Steam. 10% of the players got the 100% trophy which means at least 1.4 million people managed this great feat. Does this make it easier to 100% than the rest, or is just because of the scaling that it makes it appear easier.

Edit: I’m not saying it’s easy; I’m just wondering. I’ve never 100% a single Souls game.

Easy ? No ! Still.. the mechanics are unique, for single players, who don't care to get invaded, then the spirit summons , used as a distraction buying you time . So, bottom line, more people play that don't want to be dependent on co-op , if they are single players .

I’m confused….

[Ironwu]

Originally posted by TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire:

Think about it, they’ve sold at least fourteen million copies on Steam. 10% of the players got the 100% trophy which means at least 1.4 million people managed this great feat. Does this make it easier to 100% than the rest, or is just because of the scaling that it makes it appear easier.

Edit: I’m not saying it’s easy; I’m just wondering. I’ve never 100% a single Souls game.

Yes, it is VERY easy. Especially since you can Save-Scum the final endings achievement with manual saves at the proper points in the game. Thus, you really only need on play through for 42/42 completion.

True 100% completion though? That is a different matter and will necessitate multiple play through games. And there is no tracking for it other than what you can find outside the game and your own records.

[Papi_Teflon]

I managed to 100% Dark Souls Remastered and the only challenging part about getting achievements was acquiring every special weapon in the game. Other than that, and the atrocious learning curve in the beginning when you start off, it wasn't terrible. I also 100% Sekiro and I can tell you THAT one was hell on earth to 100% lol

[CB]

i still haven't been able to 100% dark souls remastered, that game is one tall order my dude. but i am almost done with this

[NisseDood]

In terms of how tedious it is to 100% its probably.
DS3 > DS1 > DS2 > ER.

[Solem]

No covenants so no demand for pvp or max item find grinding for 200 hours. :p
You don't need all the endings either. Just Stars, Frenzy and Elden Lord.

The spells are easy to get, and so are the items. Only some of the items are considered 'Legendary' so the list isn't that massive.

[DarkOutX]

Just easy to spend 100+ hours here due to large amount of content, and achis just require time, not skill
Here you need, as I understood, 2 runs, coz each boss have drops 1 of 2 unique weapons, achi requires you to get all unique weapons
Idk about endings achis, I believe if all depends on your final choice, you can just save backup to get it all, but if endings depends on quests, 2 runs won't be enough

Lies of P took me much less time, so I would say Lies of P easier for 100%, it also requires 2 runs + save-backup for ending, but single run is just much faster

[Artek [General]]

Yes, most certainly. No rare spells or rings hidden because maximum tier covenant awards = no need to grind those like a madman.
I've honestly been surprised how easy it was to get "Acquire Rare [Family of Items]".
The hardest achievement was getting each major ending (without save abuse that is).

[TheAlmightySunBro, Silkaire]

Originally posted by Papi_Teflon:

I managed to 100% Dark Souls Remastered and the only challenging part about getting achievements was acquiring every special weapon in the game. Other than that, and the atrocious learning curve in the beginning when you start off, it wasn't terrible. I also 100% Sekiro and I can tell you THAT one was hell on earth to 100% lol

Originally posted by CB:

i still haven't been able to 100% dark souls remastered, that game is one tall order my dude. but i am almost done with this

Two very different views on DSR’s 100% completion