How many attempts did it take everyone to beat Malenia?

[N o d L]

I'm talking melee solo no summons nada,

I made the dumb decision to kill all the bosses in the base game then once done move to the DLC, I ain't good at this game and only doing melee and such so just wanna see how bad my decision was...

I've seen some stuff on people fighting her in the 300th's of attempts and honestly it worries me.

I've been keeping track of all the bosses killed so far on my profile with the attempts so still far away but the mere knowledge of her is enough to instill fear.

[Artek [General]]

About 30 i think? Might be more. It was pretty rough.

[Butterywalnut]

around 4 hours i wanted to learn the fight fully

[SnakeshyperTTV/Kick]

51 attempts

[LuckyCheshire]

The first couple times I killed her I used a summoning ash. The first kill with no helpers took me... maybe between five and ten tries? I had an idea of her moveset and Giant Hunt at that point, so it didn't take too long.

[★ Moonlight ★]

About 4 or 5 attempts on my first playthrough to beat her no summons.
I was using a greatsword so I abused the fact I could stagger her and knocker her over. Some builds are harder the others against her, so other runs gave me more trouble.

[fauxpas]

More than I could be bothered to count ... the achievement popped, then my game crashed and I was back to just before the fight... ☠️

[mitalieneekaan]

Originally posted by N o d l:

I'm talking melee solo no summons nada,

I made the dumb decision to kill all the bosses in the base game then once done move to the DLC, I ain't good at this game and only doing melee and such so just wanna see how bad my decision was...

I've seen some stuff on people fighting her in the 300th's of attempts and honestly it worries me.

I've been keeping track of all the bosses killed so far on my profile with the attempts so still far away but the mere knowledge of her is enough to instill fear.

i haven't even tried it yet but ill might just mod out that waterfall dance or whatever :D

[Sc0rpiTr0n]

Originally posted by mitalieneekaan:

i haven't even tried it yet but ill might just mod out that waterfall dance or whatever :D

I strongly recommend to not do that.
No need whatsoever.

There are ways to deal with WD
even if you have reflexes of a dead cat.

[EchoSON]

3 I think
1 death from each 'surprise' attack

Can't say I didn't use spells , cos I did... :L
Like Rot Breath

I've never bothered doing melee only

[Senki]

i never beat hear because I don't hit women

[GamingWithSilvertail]

12~

[Demox]

I don't remember the exact number but it was much much lower than I thought it would be. All I remember was just dodging and very easily staggering her even without huge weapons through jump attacks.

[An Irate Walrus]

Melee no summons solo?

Can't remember the exact count. Neighborhood of 15-20, best I can recollect.

[BiomageHun]

Originally posted by N o d l:

I'm talking melee solo no summons nada,

I made the dumb decision to kill all the bosses in the base game then once done move to the DLC, I ain't good at this game and only doing melee and such so just wanna see how bad my decision was...

I've seen some stuff on people fighting her in the 300th's of attempts and honestly it worries me.

I've been keeping track of all the bosses killed so far on my profile with the attempts so still far away but the mere knowledge of her is enough to instill fear.

in my first gameplay i was try kill her like 4 hour long and i was used spirit after and kill her, i'm not happy for i did that, it was way to easy, my first dlc gameplay i was kill her after elden beast and corsor radahn. and wasnt use cheese tactic or spirit :D was happy and proud myself :), you should not use spirit.

btw at night i was beat bayle 2nd time and first time without using cheese tactic, was kill him with Poison Mist first gameplay, but 2nd :D yes was with real damage sorceries :D

[Sayo]

1. I read and saw videos about how annoying she was so I just gave myself infinite health.