finger snap gesture

[anders22]

iwent to the church of ellah to get the finger snap gesture, but no kale, so how do i get the gesture

[echo_ML]

I'm pretty sure you can't get it if you already progressed Bliadd's quest (I.E: talking to Ranni, Killing Radahn)

[Ironwu]

Did you kill Kale? If so, that gesture is not available anywhere else. Kale does not appear anywhere else. Kale cannot be brought back to life.

[anders22]

Originally posted by echo_ML:

I'm pretty sure you can't get it if you already progressed Bliadd's quest (I.E: talking to Ranni, Killing Radahn)

thx for your help, this is the biggest problem with this game,if you do something wrong there is no way you can put it right. totally ruins the game

[Ironwu]

Originally posted by anders22:

Originally posted by echo_ML:

I'm pretty sure you can't get it if you already progressed Bliadd's quest (I.E: talking to Ranni, Killing Radahn)

thx for your help, this is the biggest problem with this game,if you do something wrong there is no way you can put it right. totally ruins the game

It is an intentional design decision. Unlike Baldur's Gate 3, where the designers went to great pains to be sure there were ways to progress in almost every situation, that is not the case in Elden Ring.

In Elden Ring, the designers intent seems to be to let the player do what they want, but will not prevent them from bricking a quest line or progression goal permanently. That's just the way the game is, so need to go with it.

I would probably start over as I would assume that not to much progress will be lost. Before you kill an NPC, be sure you know what the consequences will be and that you can live with them. Some are very serious indeed.

Good Luck

[Drybonz]

Originally posted by anders22:

this is the biggest problem with this game,if you do something wrong there is no way you can put it right. totally ruins the game

All of the NPCs that you can talk to are part of some storyline and generally have something you want... so try not to kill them.

[Uncle BuLLee]

if you spoke to him about the howling it is guaranteed in your inventory, and never bugged. people dont know that you cant find it in your swap, even if you swap and open the window of all the gestures it wont appear for some people who have all or most gestures..

Solution:
Unequip one of your gestures completely, leave it empty, and then click on it to fill it again, you will find the snap then.

Dont forget, you have to UNEQIP one of the slots completely empty.