ELDEN RING
Spoilers - Lore Discussion - Is this the worst lore DLC From has made?
Let's talk the ending boss reveal - Radahn of all people. They ret-conned Malenia saying "promised cohort" to Radahn in their battle, something that has no other reference or hint in the base game. All the most likely theories for why Malenia was fighting Radahn involved her assuming he kidnapped Miquella, or some problem with Radahn holding back stars preventing Miquella from achieving his victories.

This is also somewhat tied into the Amber Starlight, which is found directly in front of a statue of Miquella/Malenia.

St Trina? She apparently is a manifestation of Miquella's love and is left in some cave in the shadow realm. How does that jive with all the other St Trina content, including her proselytizing around the lands between? What is up with St Trina basically killing people who imbibe nectar?

The entire concept of the shadow realm, why did Miquella even need to ascend to the shadow realm? Why is Messmer related and locked there and why did Messmer seal Miquella? These are all children of Marika and yet the story trailer implies these events kicked off Marika's ascension to god-hood, so she was having these kids before that? The timeline doesn't make any sense.

IMO it would have been much cooler if they at least left corroborating hints of all of this in the base game so they could point to a cohesive and consistent narrative, but it's almost like they left everything so intentionally vague and without context that they could do whatever they want in the DLC and just call it a day.

All throughout the DLC I got strong vibes of "they are just making this stuff up and not even trying to make sense" and it kind of ruined the base game lore for me.
< >
Сообщения 4660 из 110
I'm going to let you in on a little secret that's a very hard pill for most to swallow. None of these games have any deep lore. Fromsoft just slaps together a bunch of vague, cool sounding nonsense with no real story, and the fans make up their own head-cannons based on scraps of paper, random rock formations, and bits of vague dialogue while doing their best to ignore the hundreds of separate contradicting bits of vague texts that don't all add up together.

I believe they even said that it's supposed to be like reading a book when you don't know the language it's written in so you just imagine the story instead. That's intentional.
FromSoftware be like:

FromSoftware: I believe @vaatividya is going to enjoy this

FromSoftware: I think @vaatividya will enjoy dissecting this frame by frame

FromSoftware: Yes @vaatividya you should totally reply to our DM
I enjoyed the DLC, everything about it. EXCEPT the ending and the lore. Worst ending boss, worst ending to the story period.

I enjoyed the endings and the lore of the base game however.
Автор сообщения: Chris1
Let's talk the ending boss reveal - Radahn of all people. They ret-conned Malenia saying "promised cohort" to Radahn in their battle, something that has no other reference or hint in the base game. All the most likely theories for why Malenia was fighting Radahn involved her assuming he kidnapped Miquella, or some problem with Radahn holding back stars preventing Miquella from achieving his victories.

Ranni is the one who's destiny is being held back by the stars. I forget which item states it, I'll fork through them tomorrow and try to find it, but one of them talks about how Radahn was basically cleaning house after Morgott kicked him out of Leyndell, amassing an army to try and retake the capital from Morgott. And even though she was sworn to Miquella, Melenia was fed up when he was gloating over halting the stars, and even though Miquella pleaded her to not go, she went as she felt nobody else could stop him. It wasn't until she left that Mohg made his move.

Автор сообщения: Chris1
This is also somewhat tied into the Amber Starlight, which is found directly in front of a statue of Miquella/Malenia.

Melenia doesn't braid her hair. While it could be Miquella, the item affects God's fate, not demigods. It's far more likely Marika.

Автор сообщения: Chris1
St Trina? She apparently is a manifestation of Miquella's love and is left in some cave in the shadow realm. How does that jive with all the other St Trina content, including her proselytizing around the lands between? What is up with St Trina basically killing people who imbibe nectar?

So, body, mind, and spirit, are all very important and very real things in Elden Ring's world. It's why Margit fights you so many times, his spirit is possessing loyalist (weather he beat the loyalty into them is up for debate I think the intro shows him hopping from the throne dicing up some frail old dude), and they'll just come back if he fails anyways, because the rune of death is stolen. So, back to St. Trina, she was Miquella's lover, and was a real person and a very powerful. He may have been attracted to her because of her ability to put things in "eternal sleep". He really praised Godwyn, if the suggestion on the Golden Epitaph is indeed Miquella, so he could of "charmed her" in order to learn more about/from her to try and help Godwyn find "eternal rest". However, at some point, Miquella discovered the process Marika used to fuse with/make Radagon, as evidenced by the claims that "St. Trina was a comely young girl, others were sure he was a boy", and performed it with St. Trina. He needed to abandon his love for her (and everyone and everything by association, which is why there's a NPC stating he's "gone too far" near that footprint). As doing so, warped and disfigured her body. The poison she secretes is the only way for her to commune with people she seems worthy to assist her in her one and only goal now: making sure Miquella doesn't ascend to godhood. She did this with her arrows, too, if you read their description. If you think this is all a little much, wait till you hear my theories on your Messmer segment...

Автор сообщения: Chris1
The entire concept of the shadow realm, why did Miquella even need to ascend to the shadow realm?

Because mommy dearest is still running the Lands Between. She probably wouldn't be happy with him trying to userp her. The whole Haligtree might of just been one giant "Charm spell" on Marika/The Elden Beast to get them to think he's being innocent, and thus the best Empyrean to ascend to Marika's goodhood "goddess of "benevolence", don't forget (just don't talk to her about horns). If Ranni knows about the Erdtree and the Elden Beast, and her and Miquella were once so buddy-buddy, he probably knows how that whole machine works and why he's trying to build something completely, or at least moreso, detached from it's will in the land of shadow.

Автор сообщения: Chris1
Why is Messmer related and locked there and why did Messmer seal Miquella? These are all children of Marika and yet the story trailer implies these events kicked off Marika's ascension to god-hood, so she was having these kids before that? The timeline doesn't make any sense.

So, Messmer is a child of Marika. It's stated plainly so in his soul. I saw someone else saying he was "her favorite warrior but he loved all the heretical stuff", but he was born with red hair and a snake of the flame god in one of his eyes (don't ask me to explain, I'm looking at the same text, here) so I'm lead to believe he's the last "secret" son she had with Godfrey, after they killed the giants. She removed the eye, either to try and remove the curse or just out of spite for her old enemies. She tried to replace it with grace, but it still just wasn't good enough for her, so she put him in her own little pocket prison where she disappeared 1/7th of the continent.

Now, there's these new knights and nerds who believe in the stars leading to an order of the moon, and that's not gonna fly for the Erdtree order, so she needs to go to war, but she's a benevolent merciful "goddess" (feats like using the death rune to wipe out most of the giants probably helped here), so she can't do it. But she is a powerful faith user (given that Mimic Veils are called also called "Marika's Mischief") she could change her appearance or body to be this powerful warrior she needed. And who else than her beautiful cursed son, who's practically a doppelganger of Godwyn? This all does fit it nicely with Radagon seemingly showing up out of nowhere after Godfrey is exiled, and the crucible labeled heresy.

As for why Messmer seals Miquella, I see him and Margott being very good friends. I know they're brothers, but they have a very similar ideology/philosophy, in the sense that just because their mother and God turned their back on them, doesn't mean they don't love Marika back, and would die for her, they both do something they view as "unholy" during their fight with the Tarnished, and both feel apologetic for being forced to use their "unholy" gifts. He really is the Shadow's version of him, even protecting someone he doesn't like (Miquella/Godrick) from someone he fear might be stronger than him (you).

I'm stemming most of these stretches from the fact that Messmer's theme sounds so similar to Radagon's, but as we know by now, nothing is a coincidence in these games.

Oh, yeah, I almost forgot, Marika definitely had a bunch more kids than we see as bosses. All the wandering mausoleums are housing her "soulless, unwanted demigod children", as are the coffins you find in the dlc, I assume.

Автор сообщения: Chris1
IMO it would have been much cooler if they at least left corroborating hints of all of this in the base game so they could point to a cohesive and consistent narrative, but it's almost like they left everything so intentionally vague and without context that they could do whatever they want in the DLC and just call it a day.

All throughout the DLC I got strong vibes of "they are just making this stuff up and not even trying to make sense" and it kind of ruined the base game lore for me.

Like St. Trina being a boy or a girl by some accounts? I was one of the people in the minority who thought Miquella was the main, penultimate bad guy, and was defending Mohg (old American Dad joke my friends and I had about it: "there's a special place in hell for people like you! Right in-between the pedophiles and all the sexy children who seduced them!"). Anyone who knows how powerful and dangerous "charm/luck cranked up to 110/100" (I'm sure One Punch Man fans could think of a character that fits this bill) is, knows how bad of a dude he could potentially be, and everyone would still praise him as a saint. He seriously might of been the thing that made Ranni come up with the Night of the Black Knives. DLC has been fun to see the blood king vindicated. Miquella is definitely a crazy bunghole.

That same dude who said Messmer might be Marika's favorite warrior did also say that he thinks the only thing Miquella held onto was his Ambition as an Empyrean lord, which is a pretty horrific concept. The only thing he wants is to be a god, doesn't care how he gets there.
Отредактировано Chibbix; 28 июн. 2024 г. в 13:31
glad im not the only one looking at the lore like. uh. tf was that?

honestly theres some pretty solid lore in the dlc, but it does feel all over the place. and the miquella and radahn stuff is very forced. like why radahn? it would make more sense for it to be godwyn.

Автор сообщения: Aerieanei
I'm disappointed that the actual new ending was cut from the DLC. The Chinese players already datamined the dialogue from it and it's kind of similar to Ranni's. So there was an ending to siding with Miquella the whole time and those cut ingame cutscenes from the gameplay trailer for the DLC was a REAL THING.

wondering if you have a source on hand for this? id be interested to see what got cut.
I hate everything about the Radahn x Miquella story to the fact that the whole battle between Radahn and Malenia only exists so that FromSoft can make a Twin Princes reference and wank off Dark Souls, handing out memberberries to anyone who can't let the series go.

The whole DLC suffers worse than the main game with the story telling, because you have so many locations now that do not matter in slightest to the main story and you have no reason to go there except for finding Scadutree Fragments.
I don't care what item descriptions will say that explains in vague nonsense why the Scarlet Rot is here and why the Frenzied Flame is there that somehow magically makes it "the bestest thing evah" when neither of these things affects the main story at all and leaves no impact on the base game.

Radahn should NOT have been the final boss, he should have been an echo, memory or shadow fight. Let the player relive the battle between him and Malenia where she is a summon or something, a secret boss that is extremely difficult, because the 1st Phase is great.

I would have accepted Godwyn as a final boss, then maybe I would have been fine with the Twin Pwinces memberberries. As is it is a reused boss, reused assets, reused concept that only exists to Slop Souls fans to goon over, shafting Messmer and Godwyn as ideal final bosses.

So if I ever replay this game, I'll just stop at Messmer, he's the real final boss, I'll do the "interpretation" shtick and pretend my character traveled to the Shadow Lands by boat to defeat a tyrant and then sails home, taking Messmers flame with them.

Because guess what? The writers are so damn stupid that they wrote Miquella as a brilliant mastermind, then his plot gets completely broken when he has to rely on someone to do his job for him.
And because the damn fools are written to rely on eternally underestimating a literal GOD SLAYER, they come off as drooling tools.

So he can sit outside the shadowed gates of Enir-Ilim for all eternity crying "Bu' I a gawd! M'lard, m'lard, I a gawd!" (just read this in Ye Old English with a heavy cockney accent), while the Tarnished just goes home, because they're not going to stop him, these apathetic characters don't even care when the player is trying to be Lord of Frenzied Flame, so the Tarnished has nothing to fear from Miquellas Circus World Tour; they're not going to hunt him, they're written like DS characters, which sadly makes them braindead, because that only works in DS.
Sure hope Moghs corpse doesn't rot Miqy my guy, otherwise you'll have nothing but bones for your strongman to use and there won't be any flesh for you to bounce on if those morons you call "followers" ever stops hitting themselves with their own weapons long enough to actually chase after the player.

The writing in both Dark Souls and Elden Ring always had the NPCs be written to appear smart (ironically by just writing "x character is smart and brilliant and smart" over and over again), then treat the player as if they're always a lv 1 Wretch with a club with no brain and keep that mindset when the player rocks up in full armor belonging to a legend with a mythical sword of doom, having killed literally everyone else around them.

Miyazaki, writing "Miquella is a genius" on your paper DOES NOT make him one, because his entire plan can fail if the player just effing LEAVES after killing Messmer, with the Flame that Miquella NEEDS to enter the final stages of his ascension plans.

I feel insulted that you didn't think I would consider that after realizing Ranni also had "she is smart" written on her character sheet and then her entire plan was doomed to fail from the start, you blind, deaf, comatosed lobotomy patient!

Messmer The Impaler is the real final boss, I already defeated the Twin Princes in DS3, so the Miquella storyline is dead to me and does not exist, it is my opinion and I have a right to have it, if you like what FromSoft did, good for you, I do not and we can agree to disagree, end of discussion.
Отредактировано Jowain; 28 июн. 2024 г. в 5:57
honesty it seems like this is just a shot gun of idea at a wall. Like according to the rings of power inspired intro slideshow we the player, through three players of supposedly, should become elden lord..... but the developers seemed to have forgotten that and instead we spend all this time having to run though their art gallery of all the idea they had, but they never pulled the trigger on and did something with. the DLC is a perfect example of this, their is no reason what so ever for us the player to waste time with this DLC, and its only at the end do we finally get a reason for its existence. And that reason is to put down a potential challenger to the throne we do not yet even have, and we could have done at any time even after we got out throne.
I think Radahn was retconned in place of Godwyn honestly.

There's a ghost in Castle Sol in the main game that clearly states Miquella was attempting to revive his 'soulless brother'.
Автор сообщения: Jowain
Messmer The Impaler is the real final boss, I already defeated the Twin Princes in DS3, so the Miquella storyline is dead to me and does not exist, it is my opinion and I have a right to have it, if you like what FromSoft did, good for you, I do not and we can agree to disagree, end of discussion.

I bet you anything this was the ending they cut. Probably forced you into his ending, which the testers probably said people would complain about, so they just axed it.

I also very strongly believe that Godwyn will be the final boss of the next dlc.
Отредактировано Chibbix; 28 июн. 2024 г. в 11:38
Автор сообщения: Chibbix

I bet you anything this was the ending they cut. Probably forced you into his ending, which the testers probably said people would complain about, so they just axed it.

I also very strongly believe that Godwyn will be the final boss of the next dlc.

Sadly, it's extremely unlikely that there will be another DLC. While they didn't outright say there wouldn't be one, they did mention that they have no intention of doing so.
You guys know From made other games before Souls right?

Check out some of the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ they churned out like a year before Demons Souls released
I dunno, George RR Martin has given us an amazing dlc that features even more of the incestuous carousel that we know and love
You really do have to wonder what GRRM's obsession with incest is

Between Miyazaki's love of dirty swamp feet and GRRMs love of incest this might be the kinkiest souls ever
Отредактировано Settings; 28 июн. 2024 г. в 12:51
Автор сообщения: Valthejean

Sadly, it's extremely unlikely that there will be another DLC. While they didn't outright say there wouldn't be one, they did mention that they have no intention of doing so.

They did the same exact thing when Elden Ring was a year old people were asking for dlc and Fromsoft said the exact same thing. It's always 2 DLCs with them, and there's still way too many loose ends with Godwyn, the merging godhood ritual, the Godskin apostles, and the "gloam eyed queen".
Автор сообщения: Settings
You really do have to wonder what GRRM's obsession with incest is

Between Miyazaki's love of dirty swamp feet and GRRMs love of incest this might be the kinkiest souls ever
Miyazaki sent George an email that eloquently established the design philosophy of the story. Now, we can only speculate what this holy text said but I'll give my idea of the jist of it: "Hey bro, I want a family of demigods that rock that "Family Wreath" genetic fade". And just like that, love was in the air. George had found his next project.
< >
Сообщения 4660 из 110
Показывать на странице: 1530 50

Дата создания: 26 июн. 2024 г. в 12:07
Сообщений: 110