All friendly NPC that we make quest, the end of quest is always DEATH ?

[FabioManoel1977]

Sorry bad english

All friendly NPC that we make quest to help the NPC, the end of quest his always the DEATH of the NPC that we are helping ?


I just finished Thops quest and he died. Also finished Irina quest and she died, a guys just spoiled to me in tiktok that Blaidd and Fia also dies in their quest end. Now Hyetta is begging to me to give her some Shabriri Grape, I guess I will not give her any because for sure she will die too.

I'm starting to get unmotivated in continuing to do the quests, since the result in all of them is always the same, death of the NPC.

What's the point in ending the game? Will everyone die? even our avatar and the Witch Renna too ?

[Silent Warrior]

That's the way all Souls games are designed. Many of the NPCs die or go mad at the end, and they'll do this even without your help. So don't worry too much.
And a few NPCs will stay alive, when you don't do their quests you would never figure out who survives. Well, and some stories are quite heartbreaking, per ex. a weakling will become a hero at the end of his story.

[FabioManoel1977]

At least our avatar and the Witch Renna will live or die too ?

[Silent Warrior]

Originally posted by FabioManoel1977:

At least our avatar and the Witch Renna will live or die too ?

This depends on your decisions during your playthrough. You can sit on the throne or burn the world or curse the world or marry someone....your choice.

[FabioManoel1977]

Why Rogier seeks the curse mark ? I do not get it.

[Aertes]

Not everyone dies, I can even say more than one lives on. I hope that gives you hope.

[CannedZephyr]

not, most of them actually survive to the end if you do it correctly, infact 4 of the quests have characters you can name as elden lord in your place at the end of the game after getting them to the throne, NOT including melina or ranni.

[CannedZephyr]

Originally posted by FabioManoel1977:

Why Rogier seeks the curse mark ? I do not get it.

he doesnt SEEK the cursemark, but he did want it at somepoint for studies, thats why he gives it back to you, he had no intentions of keeping it.

[Rando the Crit Clown]

A couple of them don't die, but most of them do.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g4RKDGybO0s

Originally posted by CannedZephyr:

not, most of them actually survive to the end if you do it correctly, infact 4 of the quests have characters you can name as elden lord in your place at the end of the game after getting them to the throne, NOT including melina or ranni.

Spoilers. Also you're blatantly wrong.

Irina, Edgar, Varre, D, Gurranq, Thops, Hyetta, Alexander, Jar Bairn's village, Blaidd, Fia, Sellen (either literally or effectively), Gowry, Corhyn, Selluvis, Yura, Bernahl, Rya, Millicent, Boggart, Ensha, Rogier, Diallos, Tanith, and Gideon die as a result of you doing their quests.

Roderika, Kenneth, Ranni, and Gostoc do not die as a result of them doing their quests.

Boc, Nephelli Loux, and Dung Eater may die depending on your choices.

I have no idea where you're getting the idea that most of them survive from. It's literally a 78-88% mortality rate.

Edit: I forgot about Hewg, who basically dies, so add another tally to the corpse pile. And all the extra NPCs who are only briefly there like Albus who dies as soon as you meet him. Everybody's dying. Except me, I don't die. Dying is for noobs, which all the NPCs are.

[FabioManoel1977]

This video is very cool and very true.

[FabioManoel1977]

Them just 7 NPCs not dies doing their quests ? all the others dies ? This really makes me very sad. I hate Gostoc, why this bastard not dies ?

[Rando the Crit Clown]

Originally posted by FabioManoel1977:

Them just 7 NPCs not dies doing their quests ? all the others dies ? This really makes me very sad. I hate Gostoc, why this bastard not dies ?

You can kill anyone you want to at any time. Well, except for people in safe areas like the roundtable hold.

[nuada7]

Originally posted by FabioManoel1977:

Them just 7 NPCs not dies doing their quests ? all the others dies ? This really makes me very sad. I hate Gostoc, why this bastard not dies ?

You want Gostoc to live. He can give you something of great value later in the game .

[yaemikosimp]

betraying millicent for a good acc
is the really sad part to me

[Rando the Crit Clown]

Originally posted by yaemikosimp:

betraying millicent for a good acc
is the really sad part to me

My least favorite part of Fromsoft games is that every single one has exclusive rewards for things I don't want to do, like kill friendly NPCs such as Patches & Millicent.

Or, the terrible netcode & matchmaking is the worst part I mean. But after that it's needing to betray my friends.

[Weedsmell]

at least dog pope lives on
that's all that really matters