Are Ranni and Melina the same person? (spoilers)

[Chaos]

I think they must have split after Ranni killed herself, you can see the burned corpse on top of Liurnia divinity tower.

Then the eye thing, they have opposite eyes closed. They are both related to black knife assasins.

In the frenzied flames ending, it seems Ranni and Melina are back to being one person again and have both of their eyes open.

There is also some evidence to indicate they are not the same person, for example Ranni's tattoo is that of the death curse symbol. Melina's tattoo is the frenzied flame symbol.

They are different characters with different names, but in this game nothing is as it seems, multiple times characters have tricked us or pretended to be something they are not.

[Kain]

I don't think so, they have the eye thing but I couldn't find much on their lore to link them together.

Ranni's body is dead and rotting and trapped in a doll. Plus Melina's tatoo looks more like a crow's feet. Maybe she serves the bird god.

[Blahness]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Kain:

I don't think so, they have the eye thing but I couldn't find much on their lore to link them together.

Ranni's body is dead and rotting and trapped in a doll. Plus Melina's tatoo looks more like a feet. Maybe she serves the bird god.

The one obvious thing that connects them is that when you summon Melina she fights in the same way as the black knife assassins. We will probably get more to the lore in the DLCs whenever they come out. She could be a black knife that betrayed Ranni, who knows.

[Thorn]

They're half sisters so I think when Ranni made her doll body she just based it on Melina

[ɸ It That Dwells ɸ]

No.

[them4pples]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Thorn:

They're half sisters so I think when Ranni made her doll body she just based it on Melina

the doll is modeled on ranni's secret mentor who was a snow witch. check the snow witch item descriptions.

[Valky]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Thorn:

They're half sisters so I think when Ranni made her doll body she just based it on Melina

All demi gods are children of Marika so obviously they're related.

Oprindeligt skrevet af Blahness:

Oprindeligt skrevet af Kain:

I don't think so, they have the eye thing but I couldn't find much on their lore to link them together.

Ranni's body is dead and rotting and trapped in a doll. Plus Melina's tatoo looks more like a feet. Maybe she serves the bird god.

The one obvious thing that connects them is that when you summon Melina she fights in the same way as the black knife assassins. We will probably get more to the lore in the DLCs whenever they come out. She could be a black knife that betrayed Ranni, who knows.

She's not a black knife. She uses order incantations.
She's also the only daughter of Marika that actually wants to save her mother. "For spoiler reasons that's as far as i'll go."

[Chaos]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Kain:

I don't think so, they have the eye thing but I couldn't find much on their lore to link them together.

Ranni's body is dead and rotting and trapped in a doll. Plus Melina's tatoo looks more like a feet. Maybe she serves the bird god.

regarding the tattoos, I watched this youtuber put melina's face over ranni's spirit's face and they matched perfectly, and the tattoos actually made a full picture and looked like a claw

https://youtu.be/jpMzm-32wp8?t=501

[The High Seraph]

Different mothers and different motives . They are different .

[Julymorning]

Can you guys please stop filling the forum with this cringe imbecile nonsense lol. literally no one cares

[grandma_moses]

Oprindeligt skrevet af The High Seraph:

Different mothers and different motives . They are different .

That's the hard thing with the lore, vagueness can lead to different perceptions.

While one is mothered by Marika, the other is fathered by Radagon, if I recall correctly.

Do you see where the problem lies?

Oprindeligt skrevet af Julymorning:

Can you guys please stop filling the forum with this cringe imbecile nonsense lol. literally no one cares

Lead by example, my man.

[Julymorning]

Oprindeligt skrevet af grandma_moses:

Oprindeligt skrevet af The High Seraph:

Different mothers and different motives . They are different .

That's the hard thing with the lore, vagueness can lead to different perceptions.

While one is mothered by Marika, the other is fathered by Radagon, if I recall correctly.

Do you see where the problem lies?

Oprindeligt skrevet af Julymorning:

Can you guys please stop filling the forum with this cringe imbecile nonsense lol. literally no one cares

Lead by example, my man.

You arent smart despite trying really hard lol

[grandma_moses]

And you in time will learn to spot irony, like say posting two times about not posting stuff that doesn't interest you. You'll have a good time then, too.

But it's too early in the morning where I live, so let's be friends and go our ways. And maybe next time we'll not instantly default to insulting a person's intelligence without knowing them, what do you think?

Have a nice day.

[Julymorning]

Oprindeligt skrevet af grandma_moses:

And you in time will learn to spot irony, like say posting two times about not posting stuff that doesn't interest you. You'll have a good time then, too.

But it's too early in the morning where I live, so let's be friends and go our ways. And maybe next time we'll not instantly default to insulting a person's intelligence without knowing them, what do you think?

Have a nice day.

Enough of this "nice guy with cool attitude". You are just hiding your hatred behind words and we both know it

[LongParsnip]

Oprindeligt skrevet af Julymorning:

Oprindeligt skrevet af grandma_moses:

And you in time will learn to spot irony, like say posting two times about not posting stuff that doesn't interest you. You'll have a good time then, too.

But it's too early in the morning where I live, so let's be friends and go our ways. And maybe next time we'll not instantly default to insulting a person's intelligence without knowing them, what do you think?

Have a nice day.

Enough of this "nice guy with cool attitude". You are just hiding your hatred behind words and we both know it

You are literally poking everyone with your toxic stick and calling others toxic. WTF.

[tallgeese]

It's been shown that Melina's face perfectly fits the ghost form present on Ranni's body...

They aren't the same person, but definitely do have a connection.

They are both Empyreans born from Marika.