Why do invaders get to leave the invasion without dying or losing anything? finger sever should not work for invaders

[Biggis Dickus]

Here I am beating these fools like my ex wife with my gank squad, and they can just leave? they should be forced to stay and fight and not be allowed to leave without losing a rune or something of value, at the very least they should be made to alt F4.

Finger sever should not work for invaders and they should be locked in your world. if they want to leave they should be forced to die.

[A1 Steaksauce]

Nice bait, but you won't be getting my Jester that easily

[815|Shouldabeen]

They get the choice to leave, just like your ex-wife. Seems pretty reasonable to me.

[Biggis Dickus]

Originally posted by 815|Shouldabeen:

They get the choice to leave, just like your ex-wife. Seems pretty reasonable to me.

I never said she was alive.......

[Kalameet]

Everytime an invader uses finger sever, he loses 900 ego points and his epeen turns flaccid and stinky.

That's no wonder they wouldn't want to leave, they value their machism more than anything else.

[Biggis Dickus]

Originally posted by Kalameet:

Everytime an invader uses finger sever, he loses 900 ego points and his epeen turns flaccid and stinky.

That's no wonder they wouldn't want to leave, they value their machism more than anything else.

Sad but true, but they should be forced to cash the check they wrote just to see it bounce.

[Loligo Vulgaris]

Originally posted by Grant:

Originally posted by 815|Shouldabeen:

They get the choice to leave, just like your ex-wife. Seems pretty reasonable to me.

I never said she was alive.......

Then don't say ex-wife.

[Biggis Dickus]

Originally posted by Extreme Boyheat:

Originally posted by Grant:

I never said she was alive.......

Then don't say ex-wife.

She would still be a ex-wife. Its till death due us part.

[815|Shouldabeen]

That feeling when you believe you have a good argument for something, almost finish typing it out and realize it's a bunch of crap lol. Truth is, the invader probably gets to sever because he's the one that initiates the invasion. Allowing the host this capability wouldn't make it much of an invasion.

To put it into a more real world situation. Imagine Russia (for whatever reason) decides that it's had enough of the fight in Ukraine. They have every right to leave whenever they want. However Ukraine isn't afforded that right. They can't just leave, lest they not have a home anymore.

That does bring on an interesting thought though. Imagine you could finger sever an invasion as a host, but your world is then taken over. Your bosses all get reset and you have to start the game over again from your current level and items that are currently on your character. Any item in storage is lost. I'd approve of this system.

[Biggis Dickus]

Originally posted by 815|Shouldabeen:

That feeling when you believe you have a good argument for something, almost finish typing it out and realize it's a bunch of crap lol. Truth is, the invader probably gets to sever because he's the one that initiates the invasion. Allowing the host this capability wouldn't make it much of an invasion.

To put it into a more real world situation. Imagine Russia (for whatever reason) decides that it's had enough of the fight in Ukraine. They have every right to leave whenever they want. However Ukraine isn't afforded that right. They can't just leave, lest they not have a home anymore.

That does bring on an interesting thought though. Imagine you could finger sever an invasion as a host, but your world is then taken over. Your bosses all get reset and you have to start the game over again from your current level and items that are currently on your character. Any item in storage is lost. I'd approve of this system.

LUL. But if you win the same happens to the invaders world? or you can Counter invade and attack him in his world?

I would LOVE it if you could counter invade by killing a invader. you get a 1 times use white finger of the golden order.

[Kleerex]

Severed Fingers actually should work on invaders too.

[815|Shouldabeen]

Originally posted by Grant:

Originally posted by 815|Shouldabeen:

That feeling when you believe you have a good argument for something, almost finish typing it out and realize it's a bunch of crap lol. Truth is, the invader probably gets to sever because he's the one that initiates the invasion. Allowing the host this capability wouldn't make it much of an invasion.

To put it into a more real world situation. Imagine Russia (for whatever reason) decides that it's had enough of the fight in Ukraine. They have every right to leave whenever they want. However Ukraine isn't afforded that right. They can't just leave, lest they not have a home anymore.

That does bring on an interesting thought though. Imagine you could finger sever an invasion as a host, but your world is then taken over. Your bosses all get reset and you have to start the game over again from your current level and items that are currently on your character. Any item in storage is lost. I'd approve of this system.

LUL. But if you win the same happens to the invaders world? or you can Counter invade and attack him in his world?

I would LOVE it if you could counter invade by killing a invader. you get a 1 times use white finger of the golden order.

I would totally be up for a "1v1 me bro" counter invade system. However, the same rule would have to apply to him. He'd only lose his world if he finger severed you.

It could make for some interesting rivalries. Just constantly counter invading eachother because you're alternating wins/losses.

[CB]

so to be fair there were ways to trap invaders in other games in like, NPCs and geometry, so them being able to leave is kind of a good thing. but also if you don't like invaders leaving that's on you, stop 'em from doing it.

Severed Fingers actually should work on invaders too.

do you really think that?

I would LOVE it if you could counter invade by killing a invader. you get a 1 times use white finger of the golden order.

i would like it if there were a sort-of sin system - closer to 2 than 1 - where if you have a pvp kill against a host in a non-duel setting you can be targeted by blues.

[Biggis Dickus]

Originally posted by CB:

so to be fair there were ways to trap invaders in other games in like, NPCs and geometry, so them being able to leave is kind of a good thing. but also if you don't like invaders leaving that's on you, stop 'em from doing it.

Severed Fingers actually should work on invaders too.

do you really think that?

I would LOVE it if you could counter invade by killing a invader. you get a 1 times use white finger of the golden order.

i would like it if there were a sort-of sin system - closer to 2 than 1 - where if you have a pvp kill against a host in a non-duel setting you can be targeted by blues.

yeah that would be great as well, right now the blue hunter system sucks, would be great if every time a invader kills a host the blue hunter can then invade the red players world.

[Kleerex]

Originally posted by CB:

Severed Fingers actually should work on invaders too.

do you really think that?

I'm not sure about the remake, but in the original Demon's Souls there was a spell called Banish. It's purpose was exactly that - sending invader back to their world. I wish there was a version of it in subsequent games, then people wouldn't disconnect. The closest version was Bloodborne's Quit menu option that wasn't disabled during multiplayer.

And yes, we do need such option, be it a spell, an item, a menu option, whatever. Invasions would feel less forced that way.

[urabe mikoto]

Nice bait