Give Elden Ring an Honest Rating

[Dr.God]

Elden Ring is one of the highest-reviewed games in modern history

Performance issues aside, give Elden Ring an honest rating on a scale of 1 (lowest) to 10 (highest), and share your honest opinion without fear of criticism.

[Dr.God]

My rating:
10/10
Honestly the best game I've ever played. It's like Dark Souls, Zelda, and Skyrim all in one beautifully crafted open-world game... a true masterpiece.

[Dan_The_Noob]

9/10 until the end 2-3 areas. then it drops to an 8 for just being spammy bs

[DAWN OF THE DEAD]

-A/10 all good things about it outshines objective/subjective shortcomings

[Cold_Blade]

https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198054207268/recommended/1245620?snr=1_5_9__402

[Onni]

9.9/10, outside of the crashes which I haven't experienced since 2 days ago after that patch it has been a 10/10

[Janthis]

7/10, it's open world Dark Souls.

[Sgt. Flaw]

9.5

[chals]

birds are annoying

[warmy bear]

8.5/10.

Technically very mediocre in my experience but the general level design for Legcy Dungeons especially & Leyndell etc is absolutely stellar. Leyndell is one of the densest levels from have ever made, like one or two in Dark Souls come close...but overtuning ons ome bosses & overly packed world take it down

[BMN_Narrlequin]

easy 8-9/10 - might change once i finished my first playthrough.

[Dr.God]

Still just 87% average Steam reviews... the game honestly deserves at least 95%

[pıng]

I'd say it's a strong 8.5-9/10.

To me, Elden Ring has the same issue as the first Dark Souls did and the second half of the game is just not as fun. Too many reused bosses (I'm looking at you, Tree Spirit and Godskin Apostle/Noble) and some areas that just don't feel fun to play through (Haligtree/Elphael comes to mind). There's also some weirdness going on with input detection as well as input buffering is a bit too long if you ask me.

[pRaX]

8/10 because it is definitely not perfect. A great game nonetheless.

[[H34D]L3SSH3D(0f)ST4T3]

7/10
Sekiro is the best FromSoft game.

[Snefru]

7/10. Never played FS previous games so can’t compare. Parts of this are dragging, crafting seems %99 useless, cold magic isn’t great (sadly) and my rewards for exploration seem to be less the farther along I get.