Give Elden Ring an Honest Rating

[Dr.God]

Elden Ring is one of the highest-reviewed games in modern history

Performance issues aside, please give Elden Ring an honest rating between 1 (lowest) and 10 (highest).

Please avoid any toxicity, just share your honest opinion without fear of criticism.

My rating:
10/10
Honestly the best game I've ever played. It's like Dark Souls, Zelda, and Skyrim all in one beautifully crafted open-world game... a true masterpiece.

[Dr.God]

Elden Ring is truly a masterpiece... It's like Dark Souls + Skyrim + Zelda all in 1 game.

[Warnstaff]

7/10
-2 for port status
-1 for some asinine UI designs, like not being able to compare what you're wearing to stuff from a merchant.

[David Benioff]

1/10. Not trying to stir ♥♥♥♥ up, I just am not enjoying this game at all.

[logan]

I can be held. 10/10

[Otaku]

Originally posted by David Benioff:

1/10. Not trying to stir ♥♥♥♥ up, I just am not enjoying this game at all.

Understandable, not every game is for everyone

...
I would rate the game a 9/10 right now & 10/10 once the performance issues get fixed.

[Grandson]

9/10

[PianoBoy]

8/10
-2 for bugs and crashes

[Rord64]

9.5/10, which is the highest rating I can give.

[arador]

8/10 1 for port status and 1 for coop status. i am sick of seeing ''a connection error occured''. i had no such problem in other games. i didn't play these coop too much but when i tried there was no problem at all.

[Goosetave]

9/10 for almost the entire game, and then drops to a low 6 after you reach the fire giant.
The last part of the game is unbelievably tedious and poorly designed, so much so that it's hard to believe it was made by fromsoft.
It's 80% of a masterpiece, but the remaining 20% is actually putrid.

[Grumpy Old Guy]

8.5 out of 10.

Has some issues that need fixing but it's a great game.

[Legendairy2]

7. UI layout is still dog water even after all the previous games they could have learned from, the coop is a complete joke just like the performance. Fix those and 10/10

[Snefru]

Originally posted by David Benioff:

1/10. Not trying to stir ♥♥♥♥ up, I just am not enjoying this game at all.

Not agreeing or disagreeing, but this implies you are still playing it. So why still playing a 1/10 game you aren't enjoying? If I find a game 1/10 and not enjoying it, I move onto something else. Genuinely curious.

[Legendairy2]

Originally posted by David Benioff:

1/10. Not trying to stir ♥♥♥♥ up, I just am not enjoying this game at all.

Dont know why you keep coming to the discussion section if you hate the game so much. You have complained in multiple threads about how bad you are at dodging and learning boss mechanics, why not just move on to another game that you enjoy lol

[Sanders]

6/10
-♥♥♥♥♥♥ port/performance
-bugs
-bad boss design/reused enemies as bosses
-♥♥♥♥♥♥ pvp/connection issues
-camera issues when locking onto bigger enemies

It could have been great but ♥♥♥♥ can't code.