Rank Elden Ring from 1 to 10

[Patrick Wayne]

Include the whole experience. Not leaving anything out.

[COOM_Eternal]

10/10, love the part where the game plays a white screen for 15 seconds then crashes to desktop even though my PC had no problems running it for 70 hours.

[topgun43]

A very solid 7 at this moment in time on the PC. There is a chance FROM will stick the landing with their first good patch......the score would go up a bit. It will never be a great PC port. This game was made for consoles. After watching my son play on the Xbox Series X and another friend play on the PS5 this game was meant to be played on the Xbox, hands down. Game is a solid 9.5 on Xbox Series X and a solid 8.5 on the PS5.

[Kwame™]

8.8/10

if they fix the performance on PC might be 9.5/10.

[kredou]

8

[GeneralAkAbA]

8/10 because I wished that with J.R.R. Martin the storytelling would be different from past From's works, and because it has all the flaws that DS3 had, but that's because of the engine.

[Midnight Rider]

Solid 7 until they fix the performance. Pirated version runs almost perfectly with no stutter, bought it on Steam, dogsh*t experience lol.
If they patch it, 9/10.

[Thine Very Own, Nemesis~]

from what I've heard it's a 10/10
from my own personal experience it's a 2/10
They really need to fix matchmaking so I can play this game with my friend XD

[Cold_Blade]

6-7, mainly don't like open worlds and the crafting just made me go insane, enemies are to few in different types need more variants, to many of the mines and catacombs are copy and paste, plus.. why have questlines that gives items that dont have any purpose currently the ultimate type of troll when im sure theres players that would run across the entire map trying to find it on top of needing a couple hundred balance updates, the spirit summons need a nerf or to add to boss as phantoms would

overall would rate it good though the open world might be generic as hell but the actual level designs are great, the combat is decent, the artwork is sexy, the nutty amount of items/weapons/spells/etc is amazing, and the sheer amount of exploration you can do is mind numbing lol, its still in its early stages though so opinion could easily change..

[Peelsepuuppi]

The Dark World of Open Souls games / 10

[Namsum]

8.5/10

I need skill for the game, but my brain is underchallenged.

[Patrick Wayne]

7

[IrtheWalrus]

5/10.
the boss fights are the worst in the series. meaning they are a chore that you just want to end.
most else is fine.
menu and UI could use some work though. (seriously, why is crafting between inventory and equipment!"

[DES-TI-NY]

I give it a solid 9 out of 10. It is everything expected it to be, open world dark souls. While it is my first game of it's kind and took some time to get used to mechanics, controls, difficulty etc...it has now set up a bar of how exploration should be done in games so high that I absolutely cannot play another generic game like AC or Horizons ever again.

[Ser Pounce]

Not a perfect game but I give it a solid 9/10. It's definitely up there for me.

[Comran]

1 - playing it on a PC without controller - controls not easy or to move to get to face your attacker. I cannot get past first boss soldier of godrick after 30 tries when playing a Prophet - Rubbish game for new starters!!! - there should be a difficulty level setting