Is this game better than rdr2?

[Patrick Wayne]

Let's compare the games.

[hemorrhage911]

RDR2 is just grand theft horse. If you enjoy those game immensely, then you will probably enjoy it more than Elden Ring. RDR2 just simply falls into too many pitfalls of the sandbox/open world games for me to say it's anything other than good. Same goes for Horizon Zero Dawn or whatever Ubisoft is puking out these days.

Elden Ring only negative right now is optimization.

[brownie689]

Considering how Dark Souls is literally the best game ever made I would say YES Elden Ring is one of the best games ever made also. Red Dead Redemption 2 is kinda boring after a few hours.

[EpirusWarriorμολὼνλαβέ]

Different sort of animals in many aspect. To cut it to the point: This Is is on Nioh, Dark souls, Bloodborne aspect of gameplay, but in my opinion is far better, maybe because I been a fan of all those games and see from some different angle, however its hard to say isn't a better game overall. My two cents anyway.

[brownie689]

I get bored as hell with Grand Theft Horse 15.

[Dregora]

Originally posted by hemorrhage911:

RDR2 is just grand theft horse. If you enjoy those game immensely, then you will probably enjoy it more than Elden Ring. RDR2 just simply falls into too many pitfalls of the sandbox/open world games for me to say it's anything other than good. Same goes for Horizon Zero Dawn or whatever Ubisoft is puking out these days.

Elden Ring only negative right now is optimization.

?? What pitfalls does RDR2 have that Elden Ring doesn't? Because they're pretty comparable open world wise.

[Sokurah]

cant compare them. too different. Makes no sense.

[hemorrhage911]

Originally posted by ZDuB:

why compare apples and oranges?

It's not apples and oranges - it's an action-adventure game set in an open world. Just because it is western doesn't change the fact they are within the same genre. Same as you can compare Elder Scrolls to Far Cry - they have very similar beats within them.

[One Whimsical Wordsmith]

Not even the same genre...

[☜☆☞ Shadow ☜☆☞]

Both are masterpiece, you can't compare them.

[hbyw618]

Originally posted by hemorrhage911:

Originally posted by ZDuB:

why compare apples and oranges?

It's not apples and oranges - it's an action-adventure game set in an open world. Just because it is western doesn't change the fact they are within the same genre. Same as you can compare Elder Scrolls to Far Cry - they have very similar beats within them.

Yea we know all those games have pigs and dogs and wolves, so let's put all games into the arena?

[Sokurah]

Originally posted by hemorrhage911:

Originally posted by ZDuB:

why compare apples and oranges?

It's not apples and oranges - it's an action-adventure game set in an open world. Just because it is western doesn't change the fact they are within the same genre. Same as you can compare Elder Scrolls to Far Cry - they have very similar beats within them.

Just because its both open world doesnt mean they are the same genre XD

Honestly i love RDR2 but this game is nothing like it.

[DarkWolf]

Why compare apples and Turkish Delights? They're not comparable.

[Drewculous]

I'll wait and see if my horse dies in ER

[hbyw618]

we have openworld survival, openworld construction, openworld RPG, openword.... well souls like?

Yea, that's the difference boys.

dont do that.

dont put different things inside.

[Darksurgeon]

Originally posted by Geist:

I think it is better than Dynasty Warriors.

Easy now