Does regen from Bestial Vitality stack with Crimsonburst physick?

[Foehn]

Some folks say it does. Wiki lists both under hp regen category and reads same category don't stack.

Anyone tested it?

[Chaos-Speaker]

I was looking for the answer to this too, so I tested it.
Bestial Vit is giving me 5hp a second vs Crimsonburst giving me 7hp a second. But the regen status overwrite each other, so whichever one I use second is active. You DO NOT get 12hp a second, which makes me sad :/

[Kerian Halcyon]

Originally posted by Chaos-Speaker:

I was looking for the answer to this too, so I tested it.
Bestial Vit is giving me 5hp a second vs Crimsonburst giving me 7hp a second. But the regen status overwrite each other, so whichever one I use second is active. You DO NOT get 12hp a second, which makes me sad :/

aw that sucks. I'll have to remember that next time I set up some builds.

TBF, I don't mind stacking some buffs, but I can understand why it's not a feature. Running into META builds is bad enough, it'd suck seeing people just stack buff after buff for combat in PVP.

[Chaos-Speaker]

I'm not 100% sure if there are ways to stack the same status, like hp regen, but I think that the way it works is, each buff/debuff counts as a specific condition. In the case of BV and CrimB tear, it's a "temporary hp regen" effect. That condition is a single effect for the player but it can be called by different abilities, which make it weaker or stronger. But you can only have that condition or not have it, which is why you can't stack it.

However, there is also a "permanent hp regen" effect the player can get, such as from the Blessed Dew talisman. The difference between these effects is that the temp one is consumable/activated, whereas the permanent one is from an equipment.

I don't know if the hp regen effect from the Royal Remains armour would stack with the Blessed Dew talisman but the armour would stack with the incantation/physick.

Another way to see the contrast between temp/perm effects is using a Golden Fowl Foot and the Golden Scarab talisman at the same time. One gives temp and one gives perm boost, so they stack for rune gain. Likewise with the silver versions for item find.