Why is Dr. Eggman still the villain?

[Cwispy]

Why do they continue to use this Joke of a character as the bad guy every. Single. Game. I liked him way more in the adventure era because he’s about his business. Now he’s not serious at all and is a complete joke. After watching the trailers for this game, I was disappointed to see his robots out and about and other Eggman themed things. I want a different original villain and I think we got one but I really really hope she’s not over shadowed by Eggman. I’m tired of, you thought the villain was someone else the whole time but it was me, Eggman like we got in generations and forces.

[Eaarame]

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

[Cwispy]

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

[Cosgar]

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

Doctor Wily: "Am I a joke to you?"

[O5]

Doctor Eggman is the best shut up with your slander

[NBOX21]

Originally posted by Iggy:

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

Heck, Bowser isn't even the main villain in the Mario & Luigi games, Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door and the Super Mario Land games on the Game Boy, the last of which doesn't even feature Bowser in any way whatsoever. Even when those games get different villains, they still feel like a threat and aren't just there to be a joke.

I too miss when Eggman used to actually be serious and threatening. I'll gladly take this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkRZHS_a8ko
over anything he does in Colours onward any day!
I don't even mind when Eggman has his comedic moments every now and then. Even in Adventure and Heroes, he was able to have some funny lines that get a laugh out of me while still acting more serious when the situation calls for it.

[Princess Luna]

Why does nobody complains about Bowser being same?

Super Mario Bros. (JP: September 13, 1985)
Bowser can breath with fire


Bowser's Fury (2021)
https://youtu.be/ppkX8epoD9g?t=88
Bowser is fire-breathing

Whats new?

Eggman at least creates new machines.

[Grand Captain Speedy Dash]

Originally posted by NBOX21:

Originally posted by Iggy:

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

Heck, Bowser isn't even the main villain in the Mario & Luigi games, Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door and the Super Mario Land games on the Game Boy, the last of which doesn't even feature Bowser in any way whatsoever. Even when those games get different villains, they still feel like a threat and aren't just there to be a joke.

I too miss when Eggman used to actually be serious and threatening. I'll gladly take this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkRZHS_a8ko
over anything he does in Colours onward any day!
I don't even mind when Eggman has his comedic moments every now and then. Even in Adventure and Heroes, he was able to have some funny lines that get a laugh out of me while still acting more serious when the situation calls for it.

That is one of my favorite Sonic Cutscenes. It has some of the best moments for multiple characters, Eggman being a genuine threat, Tails being brave and Sonic taking the situation seriously.

[Seraphita]

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

I was literally gonna say that as soon as I saw the thread's title. There it is. That is all. XD

Originally posted by Iggy:

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

Play Sonic Adventure 2, thank me later. Or watch the movies or something. He's cool. At least Eggman never dressed in a cat suit to fight you. But yes, Bowser has moments too. lol

[Cwispy]

Originally posted by Seraphita:

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

I was literally gonna say that as soon as I saw the thread's title. There it is. That is all. XD

Originally posted by Iggy:

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

Play Sonic Adventure 2, thank me later. Or watch the movies or something. He's cool. At least Eggman never dressed in a cat suit to fight you. But yes, Bowser has moments too. lol

Did you read anything I wrote? I said I liked how he was in the adventure games.

[O5]

Originally posted by Seraphita:

Originally posted by Eaarame:

Its the same with Mario's villain Bowser and yet nobody complains.

I was literally gonna say that as soon as I saw the thread's title. There it is. That is all. XD

Originally posted by Iggy:

Bowser in my opinion is a different case. He’s a better character and in the rpg, he actually has really cool moments. He’s a joke yes, but when he wants to be bad ass, he can. Plus Mario always has villains that arent bowser. Sonic only had a few that weren’t Eggman and for some reason those titles happen to be my favorites. For example secret rings.
Like I said, I prefer evil Dr Eggman. The current Eggman gives me Dr Doofenshmirtz levels of evil vibes.

Play Sonic Adventure 2, thank me later. Or watch the movies or something. He's cool. At least Eggman never dressed in a cat suit to fight you. But yes, Bowser has moments too. lol

I will systematically destroy all of humanity dressed as a nekomimi maid, you won’t mock the cat suit then ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥.

[Ikagura]

Because he's the main antagonist of the series.

I mean Ganon is the final boss in almost every Zelda games.

[PwnyHipster]

Because they haven't brought in Dr.Starline or the IDW version of Zavok.

[O5]

Originally posted by PoniBeatnik:

Because they haven't brought in Dr.Starline or the IDW version of Zavok.

It’s pretty much guaranteed they’ll never bring in a character from third party stuff so Starline I’d never gonna happen

[Seraphita]

Originally posted by Iggy:

Originally posted by Seraphita:

I was literally gonna say that as soon as I saw the thread's title. There it is. That is all. XD


Play Sonic Adventure 2, thank me later. Or watch the movies or something. He's cool. At least Eggman never dressed in a cat suit to fight you. But yes, Bowser has moments too. lol

Did you read anything I wrote? I said I liked how he was in the adventure games.

I may have missed that part. But I just find weird you'd compare Eggman and bowser. Even if we go toward recent games, Eggman never dressed in a cat suit anyway. At any rate, he's the bowser of Sonic series. I specifically meant Adventure 2 anyway. Playable and he even helps you. (just like bowser did a few times when some stronger threat appeared.)

[Ikagura]

Originally posted by Princess Luna:

Why does nobody complains about Bowser being same?

Super Mario Bros. (JP: September 13, 1985)
Bowser can breath with fire


Bowser's Fury (2021)
https://youtu.be/ppkX8epoD9g?t=88
Bowser is fire-breathing

Whats new?

Eggman at least creates new machines.

Bowser's Fury is one of the best new form created for him.