Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition

Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition

View Stats:
Is this version good?
I am planning to buy to play the game like I did for the console version and to play online. Is this version good?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 37 comments
if you mod it, yes. By itself it's a ♥♥♥♥ port but the fans fixed it. FusionFix for Singleplayer, GTA Connected for Multiplayer.
Originally posted by SBeanie:
I am planning to buy to play the game like I did for the console version and to play online. Is this version good?
It's fine Vanilla, people say mod it. I will do that after finishing Vanilla. 4K @ 60fps on 3070/9900KF
Originally posted by Mad_Commander:
It's fine Vanilla, people say mod it. I will do that after finishing Vanilla. 4K @ 60fps on 3070/9900KF
At 60 FPS it's mostly okay indeed -- but you are going to have issues climbing up to the helicopter in the final mission (although it's doable at 60), and while you've up to now not noticed, for example enemies stayed in cover more than intended, cars and especially bikes controlled poorly, trying to get up to the truck in Truck Hustle is harder than intended ...

... so on, so on: https://github.com/GTAmodding/GTAIV-Issues-List/issues/112

And that's just the FPS issues. As in, no, it's not "fine vanilla". At 60 FPS you have the worst and most visible issues covered but only those.
For me it was nearly unplayable out of the box but after installing fusionfix and dvxk it's awesome.
Originally posted by Cap'n Crud:
For me it was nearly unplayable out of the box but after installing fusionfix and dvxk it's awesome.
why would you install dxvk if its a part of FusionFix already?
Originally posted by Yujah:
Originally posted by Mad_Commander:
It's fine Vanilla, people say mod it. I will do that after finishing Vanilla. 4K @ 60fps on 3070/9900KF
At 60 FPS it's mostly okay indeed -- but you are going to have issues climbing up to the helicopter in the final mission (although it's doable at 60), and while you've up to now not noticed, for example enemies stayed in cover more than intended, cars and especially bikes controlled poorly, trying to get up to the truck in Truck Hustle is harder than intended ...

... so on, so on: https://github.com/GTAmodding/GTAIV-Issues-List/issues/112

And that's just the FPS issues. As in, no, it's not "fine vanilla". At 60 FPS you have the worst and most visible issues covered but only those.
never had issues with the helocopter when using a 60fps lock, majority of the time in the past people were having issues due to the fact that they were using screens that were not multiples of 60 which would cause both tearing and input lag issues when trying to play at 60 without the proper settings.

the proper settings are simple tho, and do not require mods.

for instance: my monitor is 144hz, it will ONLY have issues with games like this, (including the helo issues,) if my rig isn't set up to properly play the game at 60 hz on this monitor, and im betting some of you don't understand how i could possibly get it to run at 60 without issue.

it's simple: enable triple buffering in your gpu control panel. - AND you need the ingame vsync to keep frames from tearing, the triple buffering allows the output from the gpu to be a multiple of the monitors framerate if divisible by 3, (all monitors are,)

what it does is makes the frame buffer render 3 frames instead of the standard 2.

if you don't know how the frame buffer works: it sets up frames for the monitor to "grab" on the fly to show to you.

144 is not divisible by 60, which is why tearing and input lag happens on games like this, (input lag is caused by the logic steps in the game being tied to the 60fps limit,) but it IS divisible by 3.

both 144 and 60 are divisible by 3.

understand?

so with triple buffering, you can actually force the game to play 60hz on monitors that are not divisible by 60, like those that are 144 hz or 90, or 150 even.

they are all divisible by 3, meaning triple buffering coupled with in game vsync, allows us to play the game at 60hz without any of the issues people have.

but you specifically need those two settings, gpu control panel triple buffering = on, and vsync on in game. - that's IF you have a monitor like mine or others that are not actually divisible in their hz by 60. - this fix is also how you play literally all other fps capped games on monitors with oddball hz ratings btw, rdr2 benefits from it as well as many others like the fallout and es series, pretty much if the game requires a 60fps limit and you have a monitor like im talking about, these two settings are the most important for no tearing or issues with logic steps.
Originally posted by f00god:
Originally posted by Cap'n Crud:
For me it was nearly unplayable out of the box but after installing fusionfix and dvxk it's awesome.
why would you install dxvk if its a part of FusionFix already?
Because the one that came with Fusionfix didn't work for me for some reason. It was a tiny bit better but was still stuttering constantly. So I kept looking for a solution and found a branch of dvxk that was made specifically for gta iv and after replacing the dll with the custom one everything worked perfectly, not a single stutter or frame drop since.
Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:
never had issues with the helocopter when using a 60fps lock
Although as said 60 FPS is still mostly doable, I and more importantly an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ of other people did, including f.e already on Xbox One/Series:

https://www.reddit.com/r/XboxSeriesX/comments/k2nltl/comment/gdvuisr/

This issue is about frame-rate and not divisibility, or refresh-rate other than in the sense that VSync limits frame-rate to refresh-rate. The core-issue is simply that GTA4's old engine derives timing from the frame callback, i.e., links its internal clock to frame-rate in that sense.

Sure, you might still be able to make it up there on 60 FPS, but on e.g. 120 you are not getting up. There's a few obvious ones -- I recall a boating-speed TBoGT mission-constraint for 100% where "distance/time = speed" goes haywire above 30 FPS making it unobtainable -- but mostly these timing issues are more opaque. I.e., how arm-wrestling in TLaD becomes impossible to win already on 60 FPS due to "taps/time=goodness-level" doing the same, bikes become unable to sanely round a corner, enemies cower in cover a lot more, ...

It's frame-rate. Not refresh-rate, divisibililty, tearing, triple-buffering, whatever. I've been spamming this link for by now years but also see

https://github.com/GTAmodding/GTAIV-Issues-List/issues/112

Note that bug-owner there as well as some people in that thread are in fact from the GTA modding community and know what they're doing/saying.

I expect you will not be convinced. Will leave this at that though.
Originally posted by Yujah:
Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:
never had issues with the helocopter when using a 60fps lock
Although as said 60 FPS is still mostly doable, I and more importantly an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ of other people did, including f.e already on Xbox One/Series:

https://www.reddit.com/r/XboxSeriesX/comments/k2nltl/comment/gdvuisr/

This issue is about frame-rate and not divisibility, or refresh-rate other than in the sense that VSync limits frame-rate to refresh-rate. The core-issue is simply that GTA4's old engine derives timing from the frame callback, i.e., links its internal clock to frame-rate in that sense.

Sure, you might still be able to make it up there on 60 FPS, but on e.g. 120 you are not getting up. There's a few obvious ones -- I recall a boating-speed TBoGT mission-constraint for 100% where "distance/time = speed" goes haywire above 30 FPS making it unobtainable -- but mostly these timing issues are more opaque. I.e., how arm-wrestling in TLaD becomes impossible to win already on 60 FPS due to "taps/time=goodness-level" doing the same, bikes become unable to sanely round a corner, enemies cower in cover a lot more, ...

It's frame-rate. Not refresh-rate, divisibililty, tearing, triple-buffering, whatever. I've been spamming this link for by now years but also see

https://github.com/GTAmodding/GTAIV-Issues-List/issues/112

Note that bug-owner there as well as some people in that thread are in fact from the GTA modding community and know what they're doing/saying.

I expect you will not be convinced. Will leave this at that though.
read the last sentence of my comment.

i clearly mention the reason why the *fps above* 60 fps causes the gameplay issues, it's due to the game engines logic steps being tied to the framerate.

the tearing issues are because people would turn the fps down on monitors like mine that are 144hz without doing the triple buffering setting and vsync option i stated, i was simply addressing both issues in kind.

60 fps is the limit for the game engines logic, anything higher will bug out the gameplay sensors and the like, (tapping buttons like in the helo,) because the logic-animation frametime difference will not allow the "tap" function in the sensor to work correctly.

it's actually super simple to reprogram an engine to automatically detect frametime differences with a world properties change in code, but most games back then didn't do this because they were specifically meant to be played with a console limitation, (rockstar specifically develops for consoles first with dev machines,) thus they never actually needed to include lines that pc games would utilize to sync up the game engines physics steps, logic steps, and animation frames.

basically all i was explaining was the issue many people faced when limiting to 60 was screen tearing due to monitor issues, to which vsync and triple buffering would fix and allow those of us with those oddball monitors to play the game at 60fps. - as in to avoid the helo bug you need the 60 fps limit is all, and if you have an oddball monitor like 144hz like i do, the ONLY ISSUE you would get is the tearing, to which i explained the fix.

fusion fix is not actually needed, but it's essentially the code programming that allows the game to sync logic physics and animation frames accordingly. - this is how people play the game with higher than 60 fps limits, and like i said it's not actually required.
Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:
Originally posted by Yujah:
At 60 FPS it's mostly okay indeed -- but you are going to have issues climbing up to the helicopter in the final mission (although it's doable at 60), and while you've up to now not noticed, for example enemies stayed in cover more than intended, cars and especially bikes controlled poorly, trying to get up to the truck in Truck Hustle is harder than intended ...

... so on, so on: https://github.com/GTAmodding/GTAIV-Issues-List/issues/112

And that's just the FPS issues. As in, no, it's not "fine vanilla". At 60 FPS you have the worst and most visible issues covered but only those.
never had issues with the helocopter when using a 60fps lock, majority of the time in the past people were having issues due to the fact that they were using screens that were not multiples of 60 which would cause both tearing and input lag issues when trying to play at 60 without the proper settings.

the proper settings are simple tho, and do not require mods.

for instance: my monitor is 144hz, it will ONLY have issues with games like this, (including the helo issues,) if my rig isn't set up to properly play the game at 60 hz on this monitor, and im betting some of you don't understand how i could possibly get it to run at 60 without issue.

it's simple: enable triple buffering in your gpu control panel. - AND you need the ingame vsync to keep frames from tearing, the triple buffering allows the output from the gpu to be a multiple of the monitors framerate if divisible by 3, (all monitors are,)

what it does is makes the frame buffer render 3 frames instead of the standard 2.

if you don't know how the frame buffer works: it sets up frames for the monitor to "grab" on the fly to show to you.

144 is not divisible by 60, which is why tearing and input lag happens on games like this, (input lag is caused by the logic steps in the game being tied to the 60fps limit,) but it IS divisible by 3.

both 144 and 60 are divisible by 3.

understand?

so with triple buffering, you can actually force the game to play 60hz on monitors that are not divisible by 60, like those that are 144 hz or 90, or 150 even.

they are all divisible by 3, meaning triple buffering coupled with in game vsync, allows us to play the game at 60hz without any of the issues people have.

but you specifically need those two settings, gpu control panel triple buffering = on, and vsync on in game. - that's IF you have a monitor like mine or others that are not actually divisible in their hz by 60. - this fix is also how you play literally all other fps capped games on monitors with oddball hz ratings btw, rdr2 benefits from it as well as many others like the fallout and es series, pretty much if the game requires a 60fps limit and you have a monitor like im talking about, these two settings are the most important for no tearing or issues with logic steps.
I'm using a 2160p Samsung Qled TV so 60hz and game is set to 2160p 60hz in settings so it shouldn't go above 60fps, i'm guessing this this is there version of Vertical sync.

I have done the helicopter mission where you chase the other one. I don't know if that is the last mission? Heli's fly just fine. Funky controls but no issues.
I've had almost no issues in game.
Originally posted by Mad_Commander:
I'm using a 2160p Samsung Qled TV so 60hz and game is set to 2160p 60hz in settings so it shouldn't go above 60fps, i'm guessing this this is there version of Vertical sync.
No, the game has an explicit VSync option in those same "Graphics" settings. With that disabled the game will, assuming your hardware can, happily run at FPS higher than your refrsh-rate.

Anyways. As said, even on 60 FPS you still have issues -- they're just relatively minor, and you haven't noticed yet.
Originally posted by Mad_Commander:
I have done the helicopter mission where you chase the other one. I don't know if that is the last mission? Heli's fly just fine. Funky controls but no issues.
I've had almost no issues in game.

No. Last mission in the base game (not DLCs) is the one where you are in a helicopter and have to face a main villain of this story that is trying to escape you in a boat, He will fire some rockets at you. Before that you chase him in a bike and have to jump into that helicopter. That part is buggy.

Personally I had no problems with this scene with FusionFix and 30 FPS lock (my older laptop is unable to run GTA 4 at 60 FPS even with FusionFix).

Currently playing first DLC and to be honest I enjoy it more than base game. I'm sorry Niko, you had good moments, but also many boring repetetive fetchquest like missions and annoying cousin...
Not too fond of TLaD -- but TBoGT is great (although/and 100% on all missions is damn hard...)
Originally posted by Yujah:
Not too fond of TLaD -- but TBoGT is great (although/and 100% on all missions is damn hard...)
If TBOGT is better than TLAD then I can't wait for it because I already have lot's of fun with TLAD. Less filler than in base game and in overall more interesting than base game for me.

Thankfully I'm not aiming for 100% completion.
When I recently replayed (on Xbox 360) I must say the filler got to me a bit as well. Basically all the mafia stuff. In a sense found it remarkable that, as far as I was concerned then, the game managed to save itself using just the few final back-on-track missions.

TLaD is too much not my thing I guess; am and very much do not want to be a moody biker-gang person for whom drug-wars and clubbing people off bikes is what passes for a good time. Now, admittedly, am nor would want to be Niko either, but at least he is not boringly but interestingly awful.

Luis; sure, I could be some of him (minus Catch the Bus -- you'll get there...)
< >
Showing 1-15 of 37 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Dec 7, 2025 @ 8:54am
Posts: 37