Resident Evil Village

Resident Evil Village

Ver estadísticas:
Elnaser80 12 MAY 2021 a las 12:29
( Spoilers ) Writing is So bad this time
Although i love the game and gave it a positive review and i love everything about it but ..

The writing and twist this time was so bad .. The ending was even worse .
You didn't respect your audience when you made the story such a childish twist !!!
Ethan was dead from just one Bunch !!! And he opened his eyes to see Jack dragging him !! although he was dead !!
Then he was a mold and no one in the game knew about it ?!! not even the molded creatures themselves ?!!! and the super molded Eve ? how come ?
And when every infected survivor was cured no one thought to run some tests on him or give him a cure for just in case ?!!
And even Mother Miranda was a mold she didn't know !!!
Ethan, Mia , Eve , Chris , The Bakers , The molds , Mother Miranda , Lady D and her daughters ( they did taste and smell his blood and said he is a human and Man's blood !! ) no one of those knew he is a mold ???????

And what it is about all the family thing ?
Ethan went after his family in RE7 and 8 , Eve wants a family , Mother Miranda wants her family and so Donna !! Lady D and her family And Morrou wants his mother to love him !!
No this time the twist was so bad and didn't convince a child .
Última edición por Elnaser80; 12 MAY 2021 a las 12:32
< >
Mostrando 76-90 de 102 comentarios
Gracey Face 13 MAY 2021 a las 21:47 
Publicado originalmente por Waylander:
Sure ignore the rest of the post that actually discusses the point and focus on me getting sick of you jumping to conclusions

I ignore the rest of your posts because you type things like this;
Publicado originalmente por Waylander:
If someone is watching Ethan for information on where Mia is then she is already basically screwed because surely someone would just follow/capture her instead. Her role relies on being under the radar so there is no downside for her to tell her husband real details which will be found out from her comings and goings anyway.

Her role relies on staying under the radar, you say, while also saying that this means she'd be perfectly alright to broadcast her location and intents to the world.

You don't stay under the radar by broadcasting. It's anathema.
Última edición por Gracey Face; 13 MAY 2021 a las 21:47
Waylander 13 MAY 2021 a las 21:54 
Publicado originalmente por Uosdwis R. Dawoh:
Publicado originalmente por Waylander:
Sure ignore the rest of the post that actually discusses the point and focus on me getting sick of you jumping to conclusions

I ignore the rest of your posts because you type things like this;
Publicado originalmente por Waylander:
If someone is watching Ethan for information on where Mia is then she is already basically screwed because surely someone would just follow/capture her instead. Her role relies on being under the radar so there is no downside for her to tell her husband real details which will be found out from her comings and goings anyway.

Her role relies on staying under the radar, you say, while also saying that this means she'd be perfectly alright to broadcast her location and intents to the world.

You don't stay under the radar by broadcasting. It's anathema.
She doesn't need to broadcast her location and intents. She just says to Ethan before she leaves " Oh I've been hired to babysit this girl coming home on a ship from (insert location here) her family is worried about her coming home on her own. The ship is called (insert ship name) if you wanted details of my itenary. I'll be back by x date."

That in no way exposes her to the world in any way that simply following her wouldn't also.
Publicado originalmente por BaLuX:
Eve wanted a family because she was a lab rat, very young, and didn't have any family.

You meant Eveline, right? Eve was Miranda's daughter taken by the Spanish Flu.
Alexbamm 13 MAY 2021 a las 22:57 
Publicado originalmente por Difference Engine:
Publicado originalmente por BaLuX:
Eve wanted a family because she was a lab rat, very young, and didn't have any family.

You meant Eveline, right? Eve was Miranda's daughter taken by the Spanish Flu.


Mmm, this is where I think it goes full circle, cause Eveline is a clone of Eva, and Eva comes from Miranda's story of wanting her daughter back (her family), so Eveline wants the same thing, lab rat or not. I don't know if I get my point across.
BassChamber 13 MAY 2021 a las 22:59 
Plot is an absolute nonsense. Better not think about it at all.
shado 13 MAY 2021 a las 23:08 
don't think too hard, just consume. :headcrab:
prototype81 13 MAY 2021 a las 23:12 
You guys are too funny.
Elnaser80 14 MAY 2021 a las 3:46 
Publicado originalmente por Alexbamm:

Look, Resident Evil isn't a saga known for it's plot and lore, let's be honest. But every story has plot holes on it, and if a story doesn't have plot holes, well then, it's not a story, it's a fact. .

Yeah well said my friend .. I can accept some plot holes in the story .. but .. never to make such a complicated story if it is full of such a big holes and critical ones too .. i mean they said in the Research notes in RE7 that the infection needs someone alive to be a mold and if he was dead the infection doesn't happens like in the deputy's case he didn't turn into a mold cause he was dead .. so how come Ethan turned after he was dead , also how he opened his eyes while jack was dragging him to the house after he killed him ? and when and how did the infection happened ? !!! i think it all just came up and they didn't prepared the story from the beginning as it is like now .. or maybe it is just me !!!
Elnaser80 14 MAY 2021 a las 3:56 
Publicado originalmente por The Seventh Son:
huh. I thought it was common knowledge before the game even begun that Ethan had taken in some of the mold and died in 7. Like, I went into the game knowing Ethan was infected.

I'm unsure on how this bit of information wasn't clear to others?

I think we all did suspect that he was infected in RE7 i mean Eve put him in a molded Cocoon and he can put his hands and legs back after being cut off .. but i don't think anyone thought he died from the beginning of the game and he was just a walking corpse !!
Soulkey 14 MAY 2021 a las 4:13 
Publicado originalmente por Elnaser80:
And even Mother Miranda was a mold she didn't know !!!
Ethan, Mia , Eve , Chris , The Bakers , The molds , Mother Miranda , Lady D and her daughters ( they did taste and smell his blood and said he is a human and Man's blood !! ) no one of those knew he is a mold ???????

Mia knew about it, but she chose to keep it a secret (she even mentions it during the cutscene with Chris) because the implication it would cause when it was found out if Rose would be a mutant/BOW.

The Bakers: The infamous "Welcome to the family son" line is quite intriguing in retrospect, since the Mutamycete had a collective consciousness of the infected individuals. That's why Jack was able to communicate with Ethan when he was knocked out.
As for the "why didn't they him?" question, I think from their perspective it was irrelevant. Eveline and the family simply wanted to kill him because he was getting in their way.

Lady D implied it Ethan is not really alive by saying "his blood is a bit stale" + he literally reattached his hand after she sliced it off.

Heisenberg and Miranda definitely knew about Ethan's powers.
Both of them were trying to pit him against another.

BSAA: did the testing but again at this point the BSAA was corrupt and might have falsified the testing results. At the end there's high chance they assaulted the village to get Rose.


PS: Op you might want to fix the quote on your profile:
It's a lamb and not a lamp. ;)
Elnaser80 14 MAY 2021 a las 4:16 
Publicado originalmente por Soulkey:
Publicado originalmente por Elnaser80:
And even Mother Miranda was a mold she didn't know !!!
Ethan, Mia , Eve , Chris , The Bakers , The molds , Mother Miranda , Lady D and her daughters ( they did taste and smell his blood and said he is a human and Man's blood !! ) no one of those knew he is a mold ???????

Mia knew about it, but she chose to keep it a secret (she even mentions it during the cutscene with Chris) because the implication it would cause when it was found out if Rose would be a mutant/BOW.

The Bakers: The infamous "Welcome to the family son" line is quite intriguing in retrospect, since the Mutamycete had a collective consciousness of the infected individuals. That's why Jack was able to communicate with Ethan when he was knocked out.
As for the "why didn't they him?" question, I think from their perspective it was irrelevant. Eveline and the family simply wanted to kill him because he was getting in their way.

Lady D implied it Ethan is not really alive by saying "his blood is a bit stale" + he literally reattached his hand after she sliced it off.

Heisenberg and Miranda definitely knew about Ethan's powers.
Both of them were trying to pit him against another.

BSAA: did the testing but again at this point the BSAA was corrupt and might have falsified the testing results. At the end there's high chance they assaulted the village to get Rose.


PS: Op you might want to fix the quote on your profile:
It's a lamb and not a lamp. ;)

Thanks Dude i did now :)
Alexbamm 14 MAY 2021 a las 5:05 
Publicado originalmente por Elnaser80:

Yeah well said my friend .. I can accept some plot holes in the story .. but .. never to make such a complicated story if it is full of such a big holes and critical ones too .. i mean they said in the Research notes in RE7 that the infection needs someone alive to be a mold and if he was dead the infection doesn't happens like in the deputy's case he didn't turn into a mold cause he was dead .. so how come Ethan turned after he was dead , also how he opened his eyes while jack was dragging him to the house after he killed him ? and when and how did the infection happened ? !!! i think it all just came up and they didn't prepared the story from the beginning as it is like now .. or maybe it is just me !!!

Ethan opened his eyes for contextual reasons, you has a player need to know where you're being taken. At least that's that's how I see it, because in RE7 Ethan "opens" his eyes again when Zoe is stappling his hand back. He was in reality uncouncious, cause if he wasn't he would have felt the pain the reacted to it, right?

Another thing to justify my thought process on this, when you're asleep and something happens in the room while you're asleep, for example you're mom comes in and idk shuts the window, when you wake up you "dreamt" about it and remember it happening. Didn't something like that happen to you before? It's quite common. So I see this literary figure of Ethan "opening" his eyes as exactly this example.

And I see the whole "you're dead" not being literal, like, the whole conversation in that limbo with Eveline is not to be taken literal. She doesn't say "you were infected" she says "you were murderded", because in the game Jack doesn't really do anything besides punching you. If anything it would have been Mia that killed him since she was the one that sawd Ethan's hand and that could cause a lot of blood loss until his death, but that's not the case. And later there's the secret foot being chopped off by Jack, but that's after Ethan's infected.

How did he get infected? We don't know how anyone got infected with the mold. In RE7 we see the transformation of Jack and Marguerite, but we don't know how they got infected either. Zoe got infected as well, and she didn't even show symptoms for example. I mean, I don't see the reason why that needs to be explained, for all I care you get infected like covid. It's irrelevant. It would do more harm than good. In classic REs, the viruses spread if you get bit, cut, etc by a zombie yet in gameplay you get bit hundreds of times and never get infected. You get what I mean? So i think they did a good job of not explaining stuff like this.

It's my vision on the take. Could I be wrong? Sure. But this is not a test, it's art, and that's the beauty of it, everyone gets to understand it differently, and that's ok :)
Alexbamm 14 MAY 2021 a las 5:07 
Publicado originalmente por Soulkey:

BSAA: did the testing but again at this point the BSAA was corrupt and might have falsified the testing results. At the end there's high chance they assaulted the village to get Rose.

Good point! I didn't think about that!
Elnaser80 14 MAY 2021 a las 5:17 
Thanks to all of you guys , the conversation with you was so much helpful and so much holes were cleared :) some key :re8beneviento: :re8dimitrescu: :re8heisenberg: :cleankey:points i mean
prototype81 14 MAY 2021 a las 14:12 
Publicado originalmente por Princess Button Masher:
Publicado originalmente por Uosdwis R. Dawoh:

The writing being ♥♥♥♥ is true, no doubt, I was just more pointing out that Zoe specifically isn't a plot hole.

Yes, Zoe is very much a plot hole, actually, Zoe even confirms after being infected for a long time, you cannot be cured, instead you'll calcify, yet Mia is cured, Zoe is cured and Ethan who was the only viable candidate never got one.

The story is a joke.

Youre missing one of the main themes of resident evil though. People make mistakes/ things are not always what they seem ( all the double agents and flip flops ). Im not sure why you take zoe as an all knowing god. She doesnt know wtf is going on anymore than anyone does.. They are all trying to figure it out. Also, the ♥♥♥♥ mutates ;) They are also in the dark of its origins and as we see in RE8 it seems umbrella might date farther back than we first thought. And they are going into a more supernatural realm as opposed to laboratory zombies.

There are so many ways to fill in the blanks I dont get why people are so confused as to why some things dont add up. Life doesnt add up either. I also think the different strains mutate and begin testing itself as it is parasitical in nature and those that utilize it never seem to be in full control of themselves.
< >
Mostrando 76-90 de 102 comentarios
Por página: 1530 50

Publicado el: 12 MAY 2021 a las 12:29
Mensajes: 102