Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

View Stats:
Which weapons are worth buying?
Best weapons?
Should I buy or will I simply find them in game anyway?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 16 comments
For RDO: Mauser, Semi-auto shotgun, Carcano Rifle.
Other guns are trash but you can try them.

Good starter weapons: dual revolvers(any type), Carbine repeater.
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 8:57am 
Springfield Rifle with its variable scope.

Mauser as a side weapon yes for its rapidity of fire.

Carcano and Rolling Block Rifles are basically sniper rifles with a fixed scope that are very difficult to use when enemies are reasonably near or up close.

The Springfield Rifle is your best rifle and weapon for day to day use.

Any revolver or pistol won't really make much difference, save them for shooting birds etc.

Save the Carcano or Rolling Block Rifle for long distance sniping.

Don't forget that ammunition makes a difference.

High velocity rounds can go through two deers at once but I'd still recommend Express ammunition.
player7112 May 12 @ 10:15am 
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Any revolver or pistol won't really make much difference, save them for shooting birds etc.
Dude, dual wield pistol, when use with deadeye, can shoot up to 12 heads in a row, if you mean they were useless.

They are OP when you know how to use it.
Last edited by player7112; May 12 @ 10:24am
player7112 May 12 @ 10:19am 
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Save the Carcano or Rolling Block Rifle for long distance sniping.
Carcano rifle can have 3 level of scopes for all distances combat (except CQC). It's not only for long distance.
It's pretty OP for mid-to-long range combat.
Last edited by player7112; May 12 @ 10:20am
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 10:30am 
Originally posted by player7112:
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Save the Carcano or Rolling Block Rifle for long distance sniping.
Carcano rifle can have 3 level of scopes for all distances combat (except CQC). It's not only for long distance.
It's pretty OP for mid-to-long range combat.

With the Carcano or Rolling Block you can't switch between scopes, the rifle is always scoped.

The Springfield Rifle is able to switch between scope or no scope.
player7112 May 12 @ 10:31am 
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Originally posted by player7112:
Carcano rifle can have 3 level of scopes for all distances combat (except CQC). It's not only for long distance.
It's pretty OP for mid-to-long range combat.

You can't switch between scopes, the rifle is always scoped.

The Springfield Rifle is able to switch between scope or no scope.
I suppose I prefer the scope-only mode, since the accuracy is better.
For me, just mid scope is enough for most distances, since I use shotguns for CQC.
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 10:40am 
Originally posted by player7112:
Originally posted by Man o' War:

You can't switch between scopes, the rifle is always scoped.

The Springfield Rifle is able to switch between scope or no scope.
I suppose I prefer the scope-only mode, since the accuracy is better.
For me, just mid scope is enough for most distances, since I use shotguns for CQC.


That's your personal preference, it doesn't make for the best rifle or weapon.

I'm telling you my friend if you'll listen that the Springfield Rifle is the best day to day weapon in the game.
player7112 May 12 @ 10:53am 
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Originally posted by player7112:
I suppose I prefer the scope-only mode, since the accuracy is better.
For me, just mid scope is enough for most distances, since I use shotguns for CQC.


That's your personal preference, it doesn't make for the best rifle or weapon.

I'm telling you my friend if you'll listen that the Springfield Rifle is the best day to day weapon in the game.
I won't recommend Springfield to anyone here, the gun isn't very "best day to day" as far as I have tested.
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 10:54am 
Weapon Load out.

Side arm - Mauser or revolver, no real difference.

Sniper - Carcano or Rolling Block.

Main Use - Springfield Rifle.
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 10:55am 
Originally posted by player7112:
Originally posted by Man o' War:


That's your personal preference, it doesn't make for the best rifle or weapon.

I'm telling you my friend if you'll listen that the Springfield Rifle is the best day to day weapon in the game.
I won't recommend Springfield to anyone here, the gun isn't very "best day to day" as far as I have tested.


Could you give us the results of your "test".

Of course not.
player7112 May 12 @ 11:01am 
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Originally posted by player7112:
I won't recommend Springfield to anyone here, the gun isn't very "best day to day" as far as I have tested.
Could you give us the results of your "test".
Of course not.
Try it yourself, activate deadeye, how many heads can Springfield marked?
"1".
Compared with basic Carbine Repeater, Springfield is just trash.

That's why I recommended Carbine Repeater.
Last edited by player7112; May 12 @ 11:03am
Man o' War (Banned) May 12 @ 11:11am 
Originally posted by player7112:
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Could you give us the results of your "test".
Of course not.
Try it yourself, activate deadeye, how many heads can Springfield marked?
"1".
Compared with basic Carbine Repeater, Springfield is just trash.

That's why I recommended Carbine Repeater.

Now you're struggling mate, you best clutch hard at them floating straws or you'll sink.

Carbine repeater is a very weak weapon, I'd recommend a pea shooter before that.

Do you seriously believe that a repeater is better than a rifle?

Screw dead eye, just look at the stat's.
Originally posted by Man o' War:
Originally posted by player7112:
Try it yourself, activate deadeye, how many heads can Springfield marked?
"1".
Compared with basic Carbine Repeater, Springfield is just trash.

That's why I recommended Carbine Repeater.

Now you're struggling mate, you best clutch hard at them floating straws or you'll sink.

Carbine repeater is a very weak weapon, I'd recommend a pea shooter before that.

Do you seriously believe that a repeater is better than a rifle?

Screw dead eye, just look at the stat's.
What are you talking about? Carbine is one of the best, hit dead eye and you can hit at least 5 heads in seconds, effortlessly, While your Springfield still struggling with the first enemy. Because it can't mark multiple heads.

But sure, you can take your sweet time reloading a bullet one by one, while other veteran players dropped all the remaining enemies with deadeye for you.

"Best day to day rifle" huh?, Your day is very peaceful I guess. Are you only shooting rabbits for the whole day?

Never seen any veteran using nor recommending this Springfield trash, afaik.

Like, why recommending a slow and useless guns? Just spam snake oil and drop all enemies in one go, it's the most efficient way.
Last edited by player7112; May 12 @ 7:47pm
Originally posted by player7112:
Do you seriously believe that a repeater is better than a rifle?
Carbine has faster fire rate, good accuracy and range, scope, compatible with deadeye which can kill multiple enemies with ease, and it's free.

Hit the head and it kills, same result as Rifles.

Yes, it's better overall, for beginner.

Rifles have slightly better firepower but in serious missions, Some rifles, such as bolt actions, doesn't perform very well compared with repeaters.

Have you ever tried a "normal" game mode? Enemies won't let you be chill and relax, reloading a bullet one by one, they will kill you if you were too slow.

You don't want to rely heavily on you good, manual aim, harder enemies AI can "warp" away from your crosshair, only deadeye can hit their head easily.

Sure, you might have a good aim but what about a foggy weather, moonless night or thunderstorms? Enemies still see you clearly while you see nothing.
Last edited by player7112; May 12 @ 8:06pm
I prefer the springfield for hunting, you can put a scope on it and use it or not. I do not remember if it comes with a scope but you can buy one or upgrade it.

I also like the varment rifle for birds and small animals and I scope it or upgrade the scope first thing I can.

I hate the vulkan revolvers, but do ugly damage up close. Unless I need upclose like when attacked by pack of wolves I mostly use the springfield rifle.

The carbine repeater I don't like. I have dead eyed with the springfield so you can do it. Though when hunting I consider dead eye cheating.

Springfield I find to be more powerful and accurate than the carbine if use the express cartridges or split point. Though explosive ammo finishes encounters well.

The more you use a gun the better your arthur gets with that weapon. I like the springfield so use it the most. I think there are other bonuses you can get to enhance your shooting so overall it could be the time put in to the gun and other bonuses that impact how good you are with any of them.

I don't like the carbine repeater, used it for most of my beginning play 100 hours or so and switched to the springfield and stopped using the repeater. Is best gun for scope use that I have used.

If you are playing kill everyone and shoot as many people as possible. I just use explosive ammo and end it asap, doesn't really matter the gun.

High velocity ammo sucks for hunting, but there is a sweet spot in distance where you "can" get perfect pelts though is more a personal challenge than repeatable event.

The bow is useful but isnt my favorite weapon. Depends how you play. Is good for shooting fire and explosive arrows which makes fun time with the gang camps.

Havent tried poison ammo yet.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 16 comments
Per page: 1530 50