wtf !?Why John Marston cant swim ?! while Arthur can ?! :: Red Dead Redemption 2 General Discussions

Store Page

Red Dead Redemption 2

All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Red Dead Redemption 2 > General Discussions > Topic Details

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 6:35am

wtf !?Why John Marston cant swim ?! while Arthur can ?!

< >

Showing 1-15 of 32 comments

Sabatoc

May 17, 2020 @ 6:38am

Because, just like in the real world, there are people who knows how to swim while others don't. Although it may be somewhat inconsistent from a game-perspective, I'd say it's still realistic to some degree.

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 6:42am

Originally posted by Sabatoc:
Because, just like in the real world, there are people who knows how to swim while others don't. Although it may be somewhat inconsistent from a game-perspective, I'd say it's still realistic to some degree.

lol yeah obvius but is make no sense i mean why create a game with 2 protagonist and make one swim and one cant swim ?! ...i am curious about RDR 1 now .:D

Sabatoc

May 17, 2020 @ 6:43am

Originally posted by Kassandra ⚔:
Originally posted by Sabatoc:
Because, just like in the real world, there are people who knows how to swim while others don't. Although it may be somewhat inconsistent from a game-perspective, I'd say it's still realistic to some degree.

lol yeah obvius but is make no sense i mean why create a game with 2 protagonist and make one swim and one cant swim ?! ...i am curious about RDR 1 now .:D

I strongly recommend the original game. Story is really good, and the Undead Nightmare expansion is also tons of fun. :)

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 6:46am

Originally posted by Sabatoc:
Originally posted by Kassandra ⚔:

lol yeah obvius but is make no sense i mean why create a game with 2 protagonist and make one swim and one cant swim ?! ...i am curious about RDR 1 now .:D

I strongly recommend the original game. Story is really good, and the Undead Nightmare expansion is also tons of fun. :)

yeah...well for me this will never happen since never came on pc and wont buy a ps3 or xbox just for a game :D

Thomastronaut has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 7:20am

John couldn't swim in the first game either.

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 7:29am

Originally posted by Thomastronaut:
John couldn't swim in the first game either.

What about Jack ?

AC Denton

May 17, 2020 @ 9:27am

John couldn't swim in the first game, they just never added the mechanic.
So in RDR2 they had to make it so he can't swim either, as it's set before.
There's many jokes and references to it throughout the game.

Jack can't swim either.

Mav

May 17, 2020 @ 9:27am

Nope. Neither John or Jack can swim. So if John didn't know how to swim in RDR1, it makes sense he can't swim in RDR2 either.

samcharles77 has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 9:30am

Because it's funny when John wades into a stream barely above his neck and starts waving his arms around.

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 9:55am

Originally posted by DatGrunt:
Nope. Neither John or Jack can swim. So if John didn't know how to swim in RDR1, it makes sense he can't swim in RDR2 either.

I never played it so i didnt know until today :D

#10

Sgt. Pepper May 17, 2020 @ 11:23am

Because RDR1.... but I suppose Rockstar only did that in the first game so the player couldn't cross borders early. Because obviously CJ could swim in San Andreas which came out before RDR1.

#11

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 11:26am

Originally posted by Sgt. Pepper:
Because RDR1.... but I suppose Rockstar only did that in the first game so the player couldn't cross borders early. Because obviously CJ could swim in San Andreas which came out before RDR1.

i dont know how exactly map was in RDR and what about borders but in san andreas dont had to cross borders swimming :D ..you had planes and such :D

#12

Sgt. Pepper May 17, 2020 @ 11:30am

Originally posted by Kassandra ⚔:
Originally posted by Sgt. Pepper:
Because RDR1.... but I suppose Rockstar only did that in the first game so the player couldn't cross borders early. Because obviously CJ could swim in San Andreas which came out before RDR1.

i dont know how exactly map was in RDR and what about borders but in san andreas dont had to cross borders swimming :D ..you had planes and such :D

In RDR1 you go to Mexico about half way into the game, but the game doesnt want to swim there early so you gotta progress the story until the train bridges are built. I only mentioned SA because obviously they had a swim mechanic already.

#13

⚔ Kassandra ⚔ has Red Dead Redemption 2

May 17, 2020 @ 11:32am

Originally posted by Sgt. Pepper:
Originally posted by Kassandra ⚔:

i dont know how exactly map was in RDR and what about borders but in san andreas dont had to cross borders swimming :D ..you had planes and such :D

In RDR1 you go to Mexico about half way into the game, but the game doesnt want to swim there early so you gotta progress the story until the train bridges are built. I only mentioned SA because obviously they had a swim mechanic already.

ahh i see :D ..intersting :D

#14