Help with Bandit 7 Challenge, Please. Rob $50 from townfolk

[GreedyLoU]

I cant rob a train cause im at the last Arthur mission and there isn't anymore trains and i screwed up the first pickpocket guy in saint denis cause i hogtied him and looted him. Pretty sure for it to count you have to tackle him and threaten. Question is will i get another chance at the picket pocket guy and does anyone know how long i might have to wait before he spawns again inside the gun store or tailor?

[Amadek]

I'm pretty sure you can just rob a train as John.

[Thomastronaut]

No need to tackle or threaten. Just aim at someone and pick the rob option. Doesn't have to be on a train either.

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Amadek:

I'm pretty sure you can just rob a train as John.

I know but i want to finish as much cause i cant move on with the story till Sunday...for reasons

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Thomastronaut:

No need to tackle or threaten. Just aim at someone and pick the rob option. Doesn't have to be on a train either.

yea bit you only get like 30-40 cents i kinda wanted to do it all at once with the pick pocket guy and was just wondering if ill get a second chance with pickpocket guy

[Amadek]

You can always roll back to some save assuming you have one and catch up, theres still some time utill Sunday.

[Mr_Purple]

Saint Denis. Arould Algernon's shop. A lot of rich snobs there. Usually gets you ~$1.5 on average. Just point a gun at them and press [E] for Rob option. But honestly just wait till Chapter 6 is over, you won't be able to finish challenges as Arthur anyway.

[Thomastronaut]

Can't you still purchase a train ticket, and then rob the train afterwards?

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Amadek:

You can always roll back to some save assuming you have one and catch up, theres still some time utill Sunday.

oh hell no, my friend im at 78.4% 3 challenges left and a few odds n ends and my honor is at 100% which is why im reluctant to rob people 1 by 1

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Thomastronaut:

Can't you still purchase a train ticket, and then rob the train afterwards?

you know what i havent tried. brb

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Thomastronaut:

Can't you still purchase a train ticket, and then rob the train afterwards?

i forgot ive tried, i always use a trains to goto riggs station and all destinations are greyed out

[Mr_Purple]

Originally posted by GreedyLoU:

Originally posted by Amadek:

You can always roll back to some save assuming you have one and catch up, theres still some time utill Sunday.

oh hell no, my friend im at 78.4% 3 challenges left and a few odds n ends and my honor is at 100% which is why im reluctant to rob people 1 by 1

There's no way to finish Bandit challenges without losing honor. If you care about it much, go fishing and release your catch. Alternatively you can run around greeting people in towns. You get one "tick" of high honor per three greetings.
You only need to be tiny bit over 50/50 of honor "scale" to get one or the other ending. Not having it at 100% doesn't matter, people in Epilogue will still speak of Arthur highly.

[GreedyLoU]

Originally posted by Mr_Purple:

Originally posted by GreedyLoU:

oh hell no, my friend im at 78.4% 3 challenges left and a few odds n ends and my honor is at 100% which is why im reluctant to rob people 1 by 1

There's no way to finish Bandit challenges without losing honor. If you care about it much, go fishing and release your catch. Alternatively you can run around greeting people in towns. You get one "tick" of high honor per three greetings.
You only need to be tiny bit over 50/50 of honor "scale" to get one or the other ending. Not having it at 100% doesn't matter, people in Epilogue will still speak of Arthur highly.

appreciate the kind explanation, sir. it's a... ocd thing. I've 100% this twice before in 2019 and sometimes i have to do things a certain way. Some reason I really wanted to do the picket pocket way for this bandit challenge especially since i ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up the first opportunity i got, I'd like to remedy that. I really just wanted to know if that can happen twice in saint denis. The one i messed up was at the tailors so every in game hour or so i keep trying the gun smith and he wont spawn

[GreedyLoU]

that all said, thanks for all the kind and helpful replies.