Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

View Stats:
DISCOLORED Feb 12, 2024 @ 4:35pm
Why do people go on about how good this game is
Since this game came out, I've heard non stop about how RDR2 is the best game ever made.

About 50 hours in and I find it very meh, the graphics are the only thing that's good, everything else just sucks.

I hate the movement, it's seems sluggish, slow paced, the guns recoil are not accurate (something battlefield 5 got hated on for) the voice acting is alright, don't like the story of Arthur compared for RDR1, the multiplayer is really really fun but again is held down by the complete slaughter of what RDR1 built.

I have a feeling y'all only like this game because your told to like it and it's made by rockstar
< >
Showing 1-11 of 11 comments
Bradsha Feb 12, 2024 @ 4:57pm 
I’m in the camp it’s a masterpiece of storytelling but overall I wouldn’t go as far as call it the GOAT. RDR2 is a slow game but I like it. Just take your time with the game don’t rush it cause you don’t gain much doing so.
Fishercat Feb 12, 2024 @ 5:50pm 
I don't care for it either and am glad I only wasted 20 bucks on it.
jswarpaint Feb 12, 2024 @ 5:52pm 
When ya compare it to OTHER games with the open world and all ya can do ... if you just go for a ride you easily get caught up in other stuff - compared to other games its at least in the top 10.

n fact, 16.7% of the top 1,000 console games and 18.7% of the top 1,000 PC games feature an open-world mechanic. In this article, we'll use data from the Newzoo Platform (Expert subscription) and the Newzoo Games Taxonomy to dive deep on all things open world.May 28, 2021

18 % of 1000 = so of the open world games thats 180 and they are all top games so its in the top 10 of 180 top games that are open world ...

maybe its not in the top 10 but thats my opinion the game I played before this was pong

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fiShX2pTz9A
FreedSnipers Feb 12, 2024 @ 8:25pm 
I find the story so far. (only 13 hours in) kinda aggravating.. The beginning was great I freed Micah and Sean. I really wanted to leave Micah and let him hang.. so far my biggest complaints are....

1.) couldnt leave Micah behind

2.) Dutch tells everyone to lay low and stay out of trouble.. then the next minute "LETS GO ROB A BANK THEN A TRAIN! YEAH YEAH YEAH LETS MURDER HALF A TOWN ITS FIIIINNNEEEE"

3.) i guess this is with 2 but meh... the lack of choices in the story. I am trying to be somewhat good while the story makes me free Micah who is someone I tried shooting the entire time. idk. that annoyed me the most.
kreeg Feb 12, 2024 @ 11:14pm 
Originally posted by UwU tee hee:
Why do people go on about how good this game is

Since this game came out, I've heard non stop about how RDR2 is the best game ever made.

About 50 hours in and I find it very meh, the graphics are the only thing that's good, everything else just sucks.

I hate the movement, it's seems sluggish, slow paced, the guns recoil are not accurate (something battlefield 5 got hated on for) the voice acting is alright, don't like the story of Arthur compared for RDR1, the multiplayer is really really fun but again is held down by the complete slaughter of what RDR1 built.

I have a feeling y'all only like this game because your told to like it and it's made by rockstar

"I can't imagine people would have different interests and likes. Obviously, everyone hates and enjoys the same things that I do." - OP & Topic Creator - AKA 'UwU tee hee' at this time of this post
Last edited by kreeg; Feb 12, 2024 @ 11:16pm
Blackout Feb 12, 2024 @ 11:22pm 
Originally posted by UwU tee hee:
Since this game came out, I've heard non stop about how RDR2 is the best game ever made.

About 50 hours in and I find it very meh, the graphics are the only thing that's good, everything else just sucks.

I hate the movement, it's seems sluggish, slow paced, the guns recoil are not accurate (something battlefield 5 got hated on for) the voice acting is alright, don't like the story of Arthur compared for RDR1, the multiplayer is really really fun but again is held down by the complete slaughter of what RDR1 built.

I have a feeling y'all only like this game because your told to like it and it's made by rockstar

It is a fun game, that has a lot of issues. However, just like the Mass effect series- it is not a masterpiece by any means.
Kind. Feb 12, 2024 @ 11:23pm 
i like it cause it has horses.
i literally can't stand being around anyone except horses.
Sebastián Feb 12, 2024 @ 11:44pm 
Originally posted by UwU tee hee:
I have a feeling y'all only like this game because your told to like it and it's made by rockstar
Yeah dummy shills. Gta5 is overrated and boring with unnecessary toxicity in online mode. Gta6 will also be the same.
in Feb 13, 2024 @ 12:02am 
Is valve going to start banning clown award farmers?
Redarmy Feb 13, 2024 @ 1:12am 
Its a masterpiece and GOAT category because

it has amazing animations,graphics,story,weapon customisation,gear customisation,lots of items to unlock and find,173 highly detailed animal models well textured with their own AI, horses implimented betrer than any other game, poker,dominos,blackjack and another game,stealth mechanics done right so many quests and so much more.

yes its a slow burn but thats ok . it wont appeal to people with attention disorders most likely.

just look at this map,turn on all legens,and you can see just how much there is in the world to find,do,see etc etc: https://rdr2map.com/

The witcher 3...now THAT is OVERATED. AS is Skyrim.
Last edited by Redarmy; Feb 13, 2024 @ 1:13am
ProperCharva Feb 13, 2024 @ 1:16am 
thats because people have different opinions yours just happens to be very weird if i do say so the voice acting is amazing not a game out there with better
< >
Showing 1-11 of 11 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 12, 2024 @ 4:35pm
Posts: 11