Sheriff badge

[J0LLY]

i cant progress though this mission called magicians for sport since the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ badge wont let me use weapons in rhodes and conveniently this mission is in rhodes so this ingame feature completely ♥♥♥♥♥♥ my ability to progress in the stoty any ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ further
any idea how to get this stupid badge off me without reseting?

[onanonehand8]

There is no need to go into Rhodes for that mission. Use your dead eye/track ability to find the path to your next mission encounter.

[firestorm]

It will be removed when you complete the mission with hosea giving out free drinks at the Rhodes bar. Name of the mission is American Distillation.

[Shaken_Widow]

that mission has no need for guns in rhodes.

you just track down trelawny and his kidnappers and you'll be outside of rhodes by then allowing you use of weapons.

Originally posted by firestorm:

It will be removed when you complete the mission with hosea giving out free drinks at the Rhodes bar. Name of the mission is American Distillation.

pretty sure that mission isn't available until AFTER you have completed the mission OP is referring to, magicians for sport is the story mission where you have to rescue trelawny from the bounty hunters at the braithwait manor.

it's one of the two first missions you get after becoming a sherriff that leads you down both paths, you go to trelawny to talk about the bounty hunters, (only to find out they nabbed him,) or you go and american distillation which is where you STEAL the moonshine first.

the mission "advertising, the new american art," is actually the one you go and hand out drinks in the bar btw.

american distillation is just where you steal the shine from the raiders with the sherrif.

[firestorm]

Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:

pretty sure that mission isn't available until AFTER you have completed the mission OP is referring to, magicians for sport is the story mission where you have to rescue trelawny from the bounty hunters at the braithwait manor.

it's one of the two first missions you get after becoming a sherriff that leads you down both paths, you go to trelawny to talk about the bounty hunters, (only to find out they nabbed him,) or you go and american distillation which is where you STEAL the moonshine first.

the mission "advertising, the new american art," is actually the one you go and hand out drinks in the bar btw.

american distillation is just where you steal the shine from the raiders with the sherrif.

American Distillation is actually the 29'th mission of the game.
Starts with Dutch at the Rhodes sheriff's office and raid the moonshine still.

The course of true love 1 & 2 are mission 30 part 3 is 31 (optional missions)

The story missions New American Art I, meeting Hosea and taking the wagon you got from American Distillation to Braithwaite Manor (and were the badge actually gets removed)
Catherine Braithwaite send's Arthur and Hosea with the wagon to The Rhodes saloon to give the shine away (which is titled New American Art 2)
New American Art 1 and 2 is the 32 mission of the game

#33 is Horse Flesh for dinner
#34 is The fine joys of tobacco

Magicians for sports is #35

Many can be done out of order throughout the entire game,
For example the 38'th mission "Preaching forgiveness as he went" can be done before anything listed above. Just depends who you talk to at camp, while going to see Dutch at the sheriff's office is easily overlooked, which kicks off American Distillation.

[Shaken_Widow]

Originally posted by firestorm:

Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:

pretty sure that mission isn't available until AFTER you have completed the mission OP is referring to, magicians for sport is the story mission where you have to rescue trelawny from the bounty hunters at the braithwait manor.

it's one of the two first missions you get after becoming a sherriff that leads you down both paths, you go to trelawny to talk about the bounty hunters, (only to find out they nabbed him,) or you go and american distillation which is where you STEAL the moonshine first.

the mission "advertising, the new american art," is actually the one you go and hand out drinks in the bar btw.

american distillation is just where you steal the shine from the raiders with the sherrif.

American Distillation is actually the 29'th mission of the game.
Starts with Dutch at the Rhodes sheriff's office and raid the moonshine still.

The course of true love 1 & 2 are mission 30 part 3 is 31 (optional missions)

The story missions New American Art I, meeting Hosea and taking the wagon you got from American Distillation to Braithwaite Manor (and were the badge actually gets removed)
Catherine Braithwaite send's Arthur and Hosea with the wagon to The Rhodes saloon to give the shine away (which is titled New American Art 2)
New American Art 1 and 2 is the 32 mission of the game

#33 is Horse Flesh for dinner
#34 is The fine joys of tobacco

Magicians for sports is #35

Many can be done out of order throughout the entire game,
For example the 38'th mission "Preaching forgiveness as he went" can be done before anything listed above. Just depends who you talk to at camp, while going to see Dutch at the sheriff's office is easily overlooked, which kicks off American Distillation.

advertising the new american art is the mission and it can in fact be done after this mission. - hence why OP still has the badge and hasn't done magicians for sport yet. - once you piss off both families and do micahs mission you lose the badge btw OP

they are labeled in order as:

advertising the new american art #32 and magicians for sport as #35 but you don't have to do them in that exact order, the game gives them to you after different prerequisites have been fulfilled.

[ThisGuyOverHere]

LMAO

[firestorm]

Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:

advertising the new american art is the mission and it can in fact be done after this mission. - hence why OP still has the badge and hasn't done magicians for sport yet. - once you piss off both families and do micahs mission you lose the badge btw OP

lol, new american art 1 is where the badge gets removed..
And part of the mission tree from American Distillation (what I was getting at)
Hosea removes it on the way to Braithwaite Manor with the moonshine wagon when he changes your hat and gives you a pipe.

All makes much more sense once you figure out the entire town of Rhodes is a Gray town.
And showing up at Braithwaite Manor wearing a Rhodes sheriff's badge (not good)

To get gold in New American art 2, you must head shot five Lemoyne raiders (Gray's) in the saloon when the saloon gets raided. Which is totally optional.
But more to the point, you loose the badge and are free to use weapons in Rhodes in New American art 1 when Hosea removes the badge.
Shootout takes place in new American art 2.