Question about Micah?

[Animecore]

I quit this game a ways back after I was forced to save Micah by busting him out of jail. I really hated how you and Micah go through town killing everyone. Did Rockstar ever address this? Probably not, but does the game make you do even more horrible choices after this as well? It really was not a choice for Micah. you were ordered to bust that piece of garbage out of jail, then he proceeds to kill everyone in town.

[Goneja]

This town was treating him like crap, no wonder he snapped

[½Pete]

Arthur Morgan is not a good man, he's killed innocent people before. Midway through chapter 2, really not long after you bust micah out of jail, you can start making good choices and role playing Arthur to be on his redemption arc.

[gotico gordo]

i think this game (rdr) maybe not for you if THAT got in your nerves, go play something else

[Hugh G Rection]

Miach gets his eventually . If that makes you feel any better .

[Jamesinator]

oh yeah gets way worse. Arthur kills millions including servicemen, and innocents, and anyone he just doesn't like. The game forces you into that. Otherwise free roam you can sort of avoid it. As for micah he is scum.

[max]

Well, that is the story and that is the character of Arthur (at least until some point in time). If you don't want to follow the story, then you can play the game as a sandbox and don't progress on the story.

[Jamesinator]

Originally posted by 卂几卂乂卂Ꮆㄖ尺卂丂:

This town was treating him like crap, no wonder he snapped

Bruh no way you defending Micah rn...
town treated him like crap and put him in jail cause he murdered somebody lol. He didn't snap he's just crazy.

[Goneja]

Originally posted by Jamesinator:

Originally posted by 卂几卂乂卂Ꮆㄖ尺卂丂:

This town was treating him like crap, no wonder he snapped

Bruh no way you defending Micah rn...
town treated him like crap and put him in jail cause he murdered somebody lol. He didn't snap he's just crazy.

Yeah yeah, crazy maniac... Or so the Germans would have us believe...

[Jamesinator]

Originally posted by 卂几卂乂卂Ꮆㄖ尺卂丂:

Originally posted by Jamesinator:

Bruh no way you defending Micah rn...
town treated him like crap and put him in jail cause he murdered somebody lol. He didn't snap he's just crazy.

Yeah yeah, crazy maniac... Or so the Germans would have us believe...

Germans? Wha? Bro they make it clear he has a screw loose? Idk how the town is at fault at all lol

[Bill]

Originally posted by Jamesinator:

Originally posted by 卂几卂乂卂Ꮆㄖ尺卂丂:

This town was treating him like crap, no wonder he snapped

Bruh no way you defending Micah rn...
town treated him like crap and put him in jail cause he murdered somebody lol. He didn't snap he's just crazy.

Micah did nothing wrong

[Kasper]

You, the player, are literally just as bad as Micah. You have no room to feign moral superiority. You're a career criminal who murders, lies, cheats, and steals, filling your pockets and stomach by inflicting misery upon others.

Micah is the most straight up honest character in the entire group. He is the epitome of unrepentant wild west outlaw, a viking with guns. Anyone who has a problem with him is a hypocrite, because you're him but with a layer of self-deception making you think you're better.

During the Strawberry gunfight the only people he kills who weren't shooting at him were his O'Driscoll cellmate (an enemy) and the two people who had his guns and left him to die.

Aside from the player, he literally contributes more financially than any other member of the gang, he constantly urges Dutch to abandon the dead weight civilians and cut the gang down to the core gunslingers to help evade capture.

People whine about Micah ultimately choosing himself over a bunch of dependent fools who didn't even like him, like the entire first Red Dead Redemption game isn't about John Marston hunting and killing his former friends for the government to get out of being punished for his own crimes.

Micah is a Machiavellian warrior, the Joker of his time, and the best character in RDR2. The people who hate him need to open their eyes and look in the mirror. You and everyone else in the camp are wandering murder hobos who victimize innocent people.

Micah was the only one who wasn't pretending not to be.

I'm a survivor, Morgan! Living and dying, that's all there is! -Micah Bell

[Wehzy]

Uhm.. But the whole gang is as bad as micah. IF you think this was bad, then you shouldn't play this game. Its a game about the bad guys, not the good guys.

Also its Rated R.

[Jamesinator]

Originally posted by Cato Sicarius:

Originally posted by Jamesinator:

Bruh no way you defending Micah rn...
town treated him like crap and put him in jail cause he murdered somebody lol. He didn't snap he's just crazy.

Micah did nothing wrong

I'm flabbsergasted by this
apparently murder isn't wrong anymore lol

[Goneja]

Originally posted by Jamesinator:

Originally posted by Cato Sicarius:

Micah did nothing wrong

I'm flabbsergasted by this
apparently murder isn't wrong anymore lol

In 1899 murder was cool back then

[MaC]

Originally posted by Kasera:

You, the player, are literally just as bad as Micah. You have no room to feign moral superiority. You're a career criminal who murders, lies, cheats, and steals, filling your pockets and stomach by inflicting misery upon others.

Micah is the most straight up honest character in the entire group. He is the epitome of unrepentant wild west outlaw, a viking with guns. Anyone who has a problem with him is a hypocrite, because you're him but with a layer of self-deception making you think you're better.

During the Strawberry gunfight the only people he kills who weren't shooting at him were his O'Driscoll cellmate (an enemy) and the two people who had his guns and left him to die.

Aside from the player, he literally contributes more financially than any other member of the gang, he constantly urges Dutch to abandon the dead weight civilians and cut the gang down to the core gunslingers to help evade capture.

People whine about Micah ultimately choosing himself over a bunch of dependent fools who didn't even like him, like the entire first Red Dead Redemption game isn't about John Marston hunting and killing his former friends for the government to get out of being punished for his own crimes.

Micah is a Machiavellian warrior, the Joker of his time, and the best character in RDR2. The people who hate him need to open their eyes and look in the mirror. You and everyone else in the camp are wandering murder hobos who victimize innocent people.

Micah was the only one who wasn't pretending not to be.

I'm a survivor, Morgan! Living and dying, that's all there is! -Micah Bell

Beautifully said