Morality system is stupid

[Ven]

Kill bounty hunter dogs that are chasing you?
Loot the wrong body in a wasteland of corpses?
Rob someone on a TRAIN ROBBER MISSION?

Evil. Scum of the earth. Lose reputation

Edit:
Walk around town, and say hello to everyone in sight? Truly a saint amongst sinners

Originally posted by soldier6661111:

Let a deer die bleeding out? Lose as much or more as if you killed a man.

[John Webfishing]

cry about it

[KiLL ScreeN]

Put your bandana on

[Shaken_Widow]

killing domestic animals, robbing the dead, train robbing.

all low honor things you can do.

what exactly are you upset about?

that's exactly how it should be.

Originally posted by KiLL ScreeN:

Put your bandana on

this has absolutely nothing to do with hiding your face, with or without bandanas you will always either gain or lose honor for doing certain actions.

bandanas only protect you from being caught, and only if they don't recognize your clothing.

[Ven]

Originally posted by Shaken_Widow:

killing domestic animals, robbing the dead, train robbing.

all low honor things you can do.

what exactly are you upset about?

that's exactly how it should be.

The problem is that its all ♥♥♥♥ the game is setting you up to deal with. Puts dogs against you that you lose points for killing.
Puts dead bodies that you lose rep for looting in with ones that you can loot just fine (and have incentive to for healing items and donations)
Gives you a mission with the express intent of robbing a train full of rick folk, then docks you when for every person you actually rob

The best part? Walk around in town saying "Hey buddy!" and "Hi mister!" and youre a f*kn saint.

[Carbohydrated Caretaker]

I found a group of o'driscolls sitting somewhere so I decided to kill them with my new shotgun just to test how it felt. so anyways I started blasting and let me tell you I was aiming for limbs only and they were screaming in pain.

after I looted their dismembered bodies and looted their camp I saw a net there with a fish on it so I thought hey I might as well grab that too. that fish took a massive chunk of my honour away when I grabbed it.

that day I learned to not grab the fish at an o'driscoll camp if I want to keep my honour.

[Icedfate]

Originally posted by Carbohydrated Caretaker:

I found a group of o'driscolls sitting somewhere so I decided to kill them with my new shotgun just to test how it felt. so anyways I started blasting and let me tell you I was aiming for limbs only and they were screaming in pain.

after I looted their dismembered bodies and looted their camp I saw a net there with a fish on it so I thought hey I might as well grab that too. that fish took a massive chunk of my honour away when I grabbed it.

that day I learned to not grab the fish at an o'driscoll camp if I want to keep my honour.

in my mind, i read this whole post with a western accent. . .

[DargonBlak]

Originally posted by Ventricon:

"Morality system is stupid"

Well... yes, at times it seems foolish, broken, and wrong.

Have you tried robbing someone yet in game ? The game actually makes it better to simply kill peolpe and loot them, as well as kill any and all witnesses.

The Morality meter, however, works fairly well in the grand scheme, imo; it will tend to lean "+" or "-" based on your overall behavior outside of the scripted questing.

[VeeDubbin]

its not stupid. there are only two outcomes. Good guy are bad guy

Tutorial:

To be a bad guy: Rob and shoot anything that moves.... or doesn't
To be a good guy: Say hey to everybody

[Ven]

Originally posted by Carbohydrated Caretaker:

I found a group of o'driscolls sitting somewhere so I decided to kill them with my new shotgun just to test how it felt. so anyways I started blasting and let me tell you I was aiming for limbs only and they were screaming in pain.

after I looted their dismembered bodies and looted their camp I saw a net there with a fish on it so I thought hey I might as well grab that too. that fish took a massive chunk of my honour away when I grabbed it.

that day I learned to not grab the fish at an o'driscoll camp if I want to keep my honour.

Perfectly highlights my point lmao

[maul]

The bounty system is even worse, it's like all the attention was spent on visuals and story, and everything else was a distant second. Robbing trains with telepathic cops is one of the dumbest things I've seen in gaming.

[Ven]

Originally posted by maul:

The bounty system is even worse, it's like all the attention was spent on visuals and story, and everything else was a distant second. Robbing trains with telepathic cops is one of the dumbest things I've seen in gaming.

"It was a bearded white guy on a horse"
"Sir, that doesnt narrow it down in the slightest. I know exactly who it was"

[OPPINAME]

Originally posted by KiLL ScreeN:

Put your bandana on

It’s not helping

[DargonBlak]

Originally posted by OPPINAME:

Originally posted by KiLL ScreeN:

Put your bandana on

It’s not helping

yeh - bandana doesn't work against lawmen (or guards, or soldiers) - they insta-recognize u.

bandana will prevent a regular citizen from identifying u, which will mean no bounty for u, provided Arthur leaves the crime scene before the lawmen arrive.

[soldier6661111]

Let a deer die bleeding out? Lose as much or more as if you killed a man.

[Gunter Severloh]

Use this mod and turn all that sh*t off.
No honor system mod:
https://www.nexusmods.com/reddeadredemption2/mods/2215

or No honor lost when masked:
https://www.nexusmods.com/reddeadredemption2/mods/2122