Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

View Stats:
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 8:48am
Can I trade or give items to posse members?
I just started playing this game (not even level 20 yet) and I was wondering if there is a way to give items to posse members through trade, or drops etc.
< >
Showing 1-12 of 12 comments
JuiceWSA Jul 25, 2022 @ 9:14am 
I don't think so. All you can give them is some Super Duper Stew and animals off your horse - providing you have that set for Posse Member Access. If you do, you'll have to take them off the horse yourself - they can't access your horse.

Note:
I denied access to the horse for everyone. I ride alone... so far. Incidentally, you should set that to YOU only if you're going to be causing hate and discontent in other's Camps. A guy rode in and tried to shoot my Dog and while he was doing that I took every animal off his horse and gave it to Cripps. He left feeling unfulfilled and lonely...lol
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Jul 25, 2022 @ 9:16am
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 9:40am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
I don't think so. All you can give them is some Super Duper Stew and animals off your horse - providing you have that set for Posse Member Access. If you do, you'll have to take them off the horse yourself - they can't access your horse.

Note:
I denied access to the horse for everyone. I ride alone... so far. Incidentally, you should set that to YOU only if you're going to be causing hate and discontent in other's Camps. A guy rode in and tried to shoot my Dog and while he was doing that I took every animal off his horse and gave it to Cripps. He left feeling unfulfilled and lonely...lol
TY. I generally follow the live and let live ideology in the game. Unfortunately, I am not getting the same from other players. I have stumbled across a few friendlies, but mostly i am being attacked and ambushed constantly by other players. I had to reset game yesterday cause someone tied me up and put me on their horse. I am still learning the mechanics with my controller. I have a bad habit of hitting the wrong buttons at the worst times lol For example, I shot at a posse member when I went to open my satchel lol
in Jul 25, 2022 @ 9:46am 
If you do trader sale then slaves get half of a payout. Full long sale nets 300+$ for each helper which is not that bad.
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:00am 
Originally posted by in:
If you do trader sale then slaves get half of a payout. Full long sale nets 300+$ for each helper which is not that bad.
ty. Im all up for any tips and tricks I can get right now. I often look like a spaz in game because of my mechanics errors lol
JuiceWSA Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:23am 
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
I don't think so. All you can give them is some Super Duper Stew and animals off your horse - providing you have that set for Posse Member Access. If you do, you'll have to take them off the horse yourself - they can't access your horse.

Note:
I denied access to the horse for everyone. I ride alone... so far. Incidentally, you should set that to YOU only if you're going to be causing hate and discontent in other's Camps. A guy rode in and tried to shoot my Dog and while he was doing that I took every animal off his horse and gave it to Cripps. He left feeling unfulfilled and lonely...lol
TY. I generally follow the live and let live ideology in the game. Unfortunately, I am not getting the same from other players. I have stumbled across a few friendlies, but mostly i am being attacked and ambushed constantly by other players. I had to reset game yesterday cause someone tied me up and put me on their horse. I am still learning the mechanics with my controller. I have a bad habit of hitting the wrong buttons at the worst times lol For example, I shot at a posse member when I went to open my satchel lol


It's rather dependent on your location geographically and the puberty progress of the player base where you live, but in my area Defensive Mode pretty much tags me as 'not interested' and everyone mostly leaves me alone.

An occasional disturbance, but I just Parlay and turn the other cheek. I'm working. I don't have time for nonsense right now. I'm also alone, so I'm quite busy doing Trader and Collector and of course, Daily Challenges.

I Just headshot a few Revenue Agents from across the map that were shooting at another player. Not sure why there were two Agents over there still living, but - they're not any more. Not sure what happened to the Player either. I rode off quietly.... and it didn't take me out of Defensive Mode when I shot 2 Agents.

I often get visitors - unhostile - some even chat and drink a beer from our Wagon.

Just made $625 and about a half a bar for a couple of Dailies.

Good Times.
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:26am
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:26am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
TY. I generally follow the live and let live ideology in the game. Unfortunately, I am not getting the same from other players. I have stumbled across a few friendlies, but mostly i am being attacked and ambushed constantly by other players. I had to reset game yesterday cause someone tied me up and put me on their horse. I am still learning the mechanics with my controller. I have a bad habit of hitting the wrong buttons at the worst times lol For example, I shot at a posse member when I went to open my satchel lol


It's rather dependent on your location geographically and the puberty progress of the player base where you live, but in my area Defensive Mode pretty much tags me as 'not interested' and everyone mostly leaves me alone.

An occasional disturbance, but I just Parlay and turn the other cheek. I'm working. I don't have time for nonsense right now. I'm also alone, so I'm quite busy doing Trader and Collector and of course, Daily Challenges.
I have never used the parley option. I will try it. Im so sick of the toxic players in my game
JuiceWSA Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:29am 
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:


It's rather dependent on your location geographically and the puberty progress of the player base where you live, but in my area Defensive Mode pretty much tags me as 'not interested' and everyone mostly leaves me alone.

An occasional disturbance, but I just Parlay and turn the other cheek. I'm working. I don't have time for nonsense right now. I'm also alone, so I'm quite busy doing Trader and Collector and of course, Daily Challenges.
I have never used the parley option. I will try it. Im so sick of the toxic players in my game

That gives you 10 minutes of God Mode with that Player.

hit L - Online Options - Go Defensive.
Don't shoot any one.
They can't lock on, or lasso you and when targeted you have a 'Shield Icon'. That won't stop them from killing you, but it may make them reconsider. it works for me - most of the time.
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:30am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
I have never used the parley option. I will try it. Im so sick of the toxic players in my game

That gives you 10 minutes of God Mode with that Player.

hit L - Online Options - Go Defensive.
Don't shoot any one.
They can't lock on, or lasso you and when targeted you have a 'Shield Icon'. That won't stop them from killing you, but it may make them reconsider. it works for me - most of the time.
This is awesome tips. ty so much. Sometimes I dont care about all the attacks but others, I just want to go about my business. This will help a lot
JuiceWSA Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:33am 
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:

That gives you 10 minutes of God Mode with that Player.

hit L - Online Options - Go Defensive.
Don't shoot any one.
They can't lock on, or lasso you and when targeted you have a 'Shield Icon'. That won't stop them from killing you, but it may make them reconsider. it works for me - most of the time.
This is awesome tips. ty so much. Sometimes I dont care about all the attacks but others, I just want to go about my business. This will help a lot

Be non hostile.
Be polite, but quiet.
Just go about your bidness.
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:35am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
This is awesome tips. ty so much. Sometimes I dont care about all the attacks but others, I just want to go about my business. This will help a lot

Be non hostile.
Be polite, but quiet.
Just go about your bidness.
That will be easy because I already do all of that :) Beiing polite has made me a bigger target so far, but I didn't know about parley or defensive mode. :)
JuiceWSA Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:39am 
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:

Be non hostile.
Be polite, but quiet.
Just go about your bidness.
That will be easy because I already do all of that :) Beiing polite has made me a bigger target so far, but I didn't know about parley or defensive mode. :)

Oh, one last thing:
Stay out of Valentine - a hive of scum and villainy.
Noobs love Valentine - it's the only place they know.

I do well in Great Plains.
2 Cougar Spawns, Quail (I have 20 in the satch) and stacks of meat.
Run Long Distance Deliveries from Gaptooth. Not a super long ride and the bad guys make easy targets.

Set the wagon on course at full speed - aim behind you with the Bolt Action - the horse knows the way.

Enjoy.
BecketsGD Jul 25, 2022 @ 10:41am 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
Originally posted by anarchisticlees:
That will be easy because I already do all of that :) Beiing polite has made me a bigger target so far, but I didn't know about parley or defensive mode. :)

Oh, one last thing:
Stay out of Valentine - a hive of scum and villainy.
Noobs love Valentine - it's the only place they know.

I do well in Great Plains.
2 Cougar Spawns, Quail (I have 20 in the satch) and stacks of meat.
Run Long Distance Deliveries from Gaptooth. Not a super long ride and the bad guys make easy targets.

Set the wagon on course at full speed - aim behind you with the Bolt Action - the horse knows the way.

Enjoy.
This is awesome. Thank you. I have been attacked in valentine more than once. Also in tumbleweed. It was so bad I had to restart the game. On the plus side though, I have encountered many friendlies as well, so It doesn't deter me. Thanks for all your tips. I will definitely be following them
< >
Showing 1-12 of 12 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jul 25, 2022 @ 8:48am
Posts: 12