Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

View Stats:
Shikari Leto Jul 22, 2022 @ 6:55am
conflict cycle with Trader and Naturalist
So how can i hunt for Trader and deal with Harriet's Aggro timer? I'm annoyed that if i defend myself form a scripted wolf attack Harriet will be piss and i can't talk to her for 15 mins only after i talk to her. Can i hunt then wait a a bit before talking to her?
Originally posted by Bad 💀 Motha:
I hunt a bit and then take a break and grab samples per the daily challenges. Then go to Harriet and sell samples if its a daily challenge OR if I have extras. I always keep at least 1 of each that I never sell. While the NPCs do not have some sort of visible Honor or Prestige bar for you to see. Deal with Harriet long enough and you can find ways to navigate around her BS. Do not show up to her place with bunch of pelts on your Horse, or show up wearing Animal stuff; such as anything made by Gus. As I for one do like to wear various items of his for my Cold Weather Outfit Preset, which I keep on my horse at all times. Before I reach Harriet I always switch over to "regular" clothes; like my Dress or CowGirl outfit. Another way to make her happy is doing any of her missions with success. Doing any Legendary Sample Mission she provides can be helpful to you if you've never gotten a sample from that animal. Or do not know the location is hangs out in / spawns in.

When I get to Harriet I also select an Emote and give out a happy greeting. It helps perk her up a bit.

As long as your Camp has at least 25% or so of Donated Goods and you go on Supply Runs; then he can continue to output as a means of getting a full wagon stocked and ready. Do not let a fully stocked wagon sit too many days. It might empty on you one day. I've had a happen a few times. Same goes for Moonshine ready to ship. If you ignore that for a few days it will reset it all.

If you really want to kill less but impact that bar for donated goods to your camp's table; hunt and donate anything Legendary. Once you've unlocked everything from Gus by doing what he needs, there is no reason to keep off-loading all the Legendary stuff to him, give towards your camp instead.

If a Legendary Animal can be picked up; then it's always possible to Sample + Revive + Kill + Skin it. All in the same go. The exploit for this is once you put the carcass on your Horse. Right click the Horse and select Flee. Wait til the horse de-spawns completely. Then call it back. Now remove the carcass and put on ground and then skin it. Or if you have Wilderness Camp, spawn one of those and then just Fast Travel to a town that has a butcher. Once you get there you can remove carcass from horse and skin it.

Take the skinned carcass to Butcher. Take the Pelt or whatever the item is you get off the animal, either to Gus (if have not already) or to your Camps Table as a Donation.
< >
Showing 1-12 of 12 comments
JuiceWSA Jul 22, 2022 @ 7:02am 
Naturalist is a real hoot, ain't it?

(Sure am glad I kept that Gold - my first instinct about that Woman was correct - she's a Looney)
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Jul 22, 2022 @ 7:18am
pike Jul 22, 2022 @ 7:55am 
being a vegan supporter of the honorable and virtuous Miss Harriet i do not understand your conflict heathen carnivore killing beast machine
but
i can offer this sage worthy advise, alternate naturalist and trader days , simply put,, dont hunt on the days you do naturalist stuff, you have to murder a lot of our furry friends before Miss Harriet goes full PETA, also if attacked by wolves you dont have to kill them to drive them off, shooting towards them does work
naturalist is the toughest role to do because of all the in game behavior restrictions and it pays so poorly,
to do it you really have to want to
in Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:10am 
It's only ~5 minutes, not 15. Instead of hunting trash animals do Harriet's missions and donate skinned legendary pelts to Creeps. Naturalist is a great supportive role for it. Get a hunting wagon and you can store up to 50 flat legendary pelts into it + few big ones/carcasses. This way you can forget about hunting for a long time and do it whenever you feel like it.
Last edited by in; Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:10am
JuiceWSA Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:20am 
Originally posted by in:
It's only ~5 minutes, not 15. Instead of hunting trash animals do Harriet's missions and donate skinned legendary pelts to Creeps. Naturalist is a great supportive role for it. Get a hunting wagon and you can store up to 50 flat legendary pelts into it + few big ones/carcasses. This way you can forget about hunting for a long time and do it whenever you feel like it.

...and what's the payoff for those Legendary Pelts?
Animal Head Hats?

...and once more for clarity:
Once you join The Team - you're joined at the hip for life?
Like there's no getting away from that crazy Koot - Ever?

(Yea, I'm a lot happier not being one of Harriet's Boys)
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:24am
Rusalka Jul 22, 2022 @ 1:49pm 
Yeah, I just load up the trader with a ton of dead critters and then just forget about it for a while and Alligator Grind for Harriet. It's not too tough, aside from when rabbits dash out under my horse's hooves or when I accidentally shoot a horse while doing a bounty.

I'm still not sure why RDO decided to not make a single likable NPC. It's so strange to go from storymode, which has lots of interesting NPCs that are fun to talk with, to RDO, which is all lunatic anachronistic cartoon characters.
in Jul 22, 2022 @ 1:51pm 
Maggie is kinda alright.
Rusalka Jul 22, 2022 @ 1:52pm 
Originally posted by in:
Maggie is kinda alright.
You know what? You're right, Maggie is alright.
Annihilator Jul 22, 2022 @ 1:56pm 
Is only 5 minutes waiting not 15 :)
Shikari Leto Jul 22, 2022 @ 3:42pm 
Originally posted by in:
It's only ~5 minutes, not 15. Instead of hunting trash animals do Harriet's missions and donate skinned legendary pelts to Creeps. Naturalist is a great supportive role for it. Get a hunting wagon and you can store up to 50 flat legendary pelts into it + few big ones/carcasses. This way you can forget about hunting for a long time and do it whenever you feel like it.

what do you mean? her legendary missions? im almost lvl 5. So what, do the legendary mission but kill the animal in the end instead of sedating it? I'm confused
The author of this thread has indicated that this post answers the original topic.
Bad 💀 Motha Jul 22, 2022 @ 8:29pm 
I hunt a bit and then take a break and grab samples per the daily challenges. Then go to Harriet and sell samples if its a daily challenge OR if I have extras. I always keep at least 1 of each that I never sell. While the NPCs do not have some sort of visible Honor or Prestige bar for you to see. Deal with Harriet long enough and you can find ways to navigate around her BS. Do not show up to her place with bunch of pelts on your Horse, or show up wearing Animal stuff; such as anything made by Gus. As I for one do like to wear various items of his for my Cold Weather Outfit Preset, which I keep on my horse at all times. Before I reach Harriet I always switch over to "regular" clothes; like my Dress or CowGirl outfit. Another way to make her happy is doing any of her missions with success. Doing any Legendary Sample Mission she provides can be helpful to you if you've never gotten a sample from that animal. Or do not know the location is hangs out in / spawns in.

When I get to Harriet I also select an Emote and give out a happy greeting. It helps perk her up a bit.

As long as your Camp has at least 25% or so of Donated Goods and you go on Supply Runs; then he can continue to output as a means of getting a full wagon stocked and ready. Do not let a fully stocked wagon sit too many days. It might empty on you one day. I've had a happen a few times. Same goes for Moonshine ready to ship. If you ignore that for a few days it will reset it all.

If you really want to kill less but impact that bar for donated goods to your camp's table; hunt and donate anything Legendary. Once you've unlocked everything from Gus by doing what he needs, there is no reason to keep off-loading all the Legendary stuff to him, give towards your camp instead.

If a Legendary Animal can be picked up; then it's always possible to Sample + Revive + Kill + Skin it. All in the same go. The exploit for this is once you put the carcass on your Horse. Right click the Horse and select Flee. Wait til the horse de-spawns completely. Then call it back. Now remove the carcass and put on ground and then skin it. Or if you have Wilderness Camp, spawn one of those and then just Fast Travel to a town that has a butcher. Once you get there you can remove carcass from horse and skin it.

Take the skinned carcass to Butcher. Take the Pelt or whatever the item is you get off the animal, either to Gus (if have not already) or to your Camps Table as a Donation.
Last edited by Bad 💀 Motha; Jul 22, 2022 @ 8:36pm
Dr. Peeper Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:35pm 
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:
Originally posted by in:
It's only ~5 minutes, not 15. Instead of hunting trash animals do Harriet's missions and donate skinned legendary pelts to Creeps. Naturalist is a great supportive role for it. Get a hunting wagon and you can store up to 50 flat legendary pelts into it + few big ones/carcasses. This way you can forget about hunting for a long time and do it whenever you feel like it.

...and what's the payoff for those Legendary Pelts?
Animal Head Hats?

...and once more for clarity:
Once you join The Team - you're joined at the hip for life?
Like there's no getting away from that crazy Koot - Ever?

(Yea, I'm a lot happier not being one of Harriet's Boys)

No, donate to cripps. I think a legendary cougar skin is 40 mats? Someone throw the #'s if they have them.
Last edited by Dr. Peeper; Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:36pm
JuiceWSA Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:42pm 
Originally posted by Dr. Peeper:
Originally posted by JuiceWSA:

...and what's the payoff for those Legendary Pelts?
Animal Head Hats?

...and once more for clarity:
Once you join The Team - you're joined at the hip for life?
Like there's no getting away from that crazy Koot - Ever?

(Yea, I'm a lot happier not being one of Harriet's Boys)

No, donate to cripps. I think a legendary cougar skin is 40 mats? Someone throw the #'s if they have them.

Trust me - I won't be joining Team Freak-Fest.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TvHIdFziWfQ
Last edited by JuiceWSA; Jul 22, 2022 @ 9:45pm
< >
Showing 1-12 of 12 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jul 22, 2022 @ 6:55am
Posts: 12