Cigarette Cards

[mach1bob]

UPDATE; DON'T BOTHER COLLECTING ALL OF THE SETS, this achievement is broken! I tried all of the things that I mentioned in my original posting below and now I just finished uninstalling and reinstalling RDR2 but still cannot mail the last two completed sets so the checklist cannot be completed.

I have collected all 144 Cigarette Cards that began with "Smoking and other hobbies" and I cannot mail the "Fauna of North America" or the "Amazing Inventions" decks. I have been able to mail all of the other decks but not those two. I have completed the whole story including "Who is not without sin" and both epilogues. After finding out that I could not mail those two sets I sold all cards in my inventory to Fences and bought premium cigarettes from merchants (I originally traveled all over the whole map collecting cards, bones, carvings, etc.). All of the cards in those two decks visibly appear in my compendium so I don't even have a blank spot to see if anything is missing. It is extremely disappointing to have spent so much time only to find out that RDR2 cannot be 100% completed. Does anyone have any clues for a solution???

[Zombits]

you can mail any ONE of the sets, only 1 has to be complete for 100 % completion . thats how i did it

On this 2nd playthrough i bought all the cards from shops and mailed those 12 or 13 sets , it said i didnt mailed them all on checklist, but that's another weird thing

[mach1bob]

I was able to sell 10 sets, I still have two left.

[mach1bob]

Originally posted by Zombits:

you can mail any ONE of the sets, only 1 has to be complete for 100 % completion . thats how i did it

On this 2nd playthrough i bought all the cards from shops and mailed those 12 or 13 sets , it said i didnt mailed them all on checklist, but that's another weird thing

The checklist doesn't show that you mailed all of the cards, that is exactly what I am talking about.

[Good Time]

yeah this bug is still in the game, just ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ sell them forget about the achivements some of them are still impossible (like this one but as far as i can tell it's RNG if it works or not)

[onanonehand8]

Continues to work for me.

[Citizen]

sold all sets with no issues.