The Real Rat

[atrex]

Micah was not the real rat. it was John it all makes sense play the bank job back and then chapter 5 ?!?!? They say in chapter 5 that “john wasn’t killed and Abigail managed to slip out” I think something fishy. And there a video I think pvp cat did that Micah was not the real rat. But idk let me know

[GhostyOsty]

Yeah, then proceeding into the original game with John Marston being called by the government forcefully having to fight to kill his gang members wouldn't make any sense.

[GoobleMoWizard]

I still think Micah was the Rat. Micah was bad business from the very beginning at the Ferry Heist. The thing is, Dutch got sloppy as Arthur mentions when they go to meet with Cornwall. Every plan Dutch had put the Gang in harms way, but more so after Dutch's knock on the head, and by creating more noise, as Dutch puts it, Arthur knew more noise was a bad idea. Arthur: Maybe we don't need a Rat. We got sloppier than the town Drunk, and now they know who we are, where we are, and what we're doing.

And Micah's reaction to all of that was, "Snooooore!" Micah is nothing but a puppet master mind that got into Dutch's brain, cause without Hosea, who else is he gonna listen to, other than the one person that has only been riding with them for a couple months? Definitely not Arthur, cause oh no, listening to Arthur isn't in the, "Plan" And as Dutch puts it when they're in Guarma, "For someone, this is all going exactly to plan."

I may be wrong, but I stick by what Arthur says, "We Don't Need a Rat", it's Micah and Dutch's planning that lead them to ruin.

[DargonBlak]

Blind Man Cassidy said to Arthur at one point:
"Your father is seduced by the one with the forked tongue... it's no use hoping"

Meaning Dutch was beginning to believe Micah, and Micah was a Snake.

Pretty clear there was nothing hidden.

[Pieshaman]

Micah was a ratsnakedogpigchickencockroachman
Like manbearpig but worse.

[Lufka]

letting dutch go was the worst and the most disapointing moment for me in the history of video games

[Hex]

The law was tipped off before Micah ever came back to camp or knew of certain plans. The only person with the opportunity and motive was Abigail. Why? To protect Jack, and get him out. The number of people who knew about the train job was extremely small.

[DargonBlak]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย Pieshaman:

Micah was a ratsnakedogpigchickencockroachman
Like manbearpig but worse.

Perfect

[The Commendatore]

Nah, Micah's the rat.

[30NAAN30]

I think the reason Abigail escaped in that hiest is hosea i think hosea helped her escape by sacrificing him self to get caught john is not rat bro lol

[Hex]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย 30NAAN30:

I think the reason Abigail escaped in that hiest is hosea i think hosea helped her escape by sacrificing him self to get caught john is not rat bro lol

The one that's planned by John. Near Rhodes. Micah is in jail when that happens and has no way of knowing about it yet the law is tipped off.

Micah is a snake filling Dutch's head with stupid ideas, but he's not the rat.

[in]

If Abigail wanted to "protect" her kid then she could've just left the gang and that's it. Why people need to keep coming up with some dumb ideas when R* themselves confirmed that rat is a rat.

[Hex]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย in:

If Abigail wanted to "protect" her kid then she could've just left the gang and that's it. Why people need to keep coming up with some dumb ideas when R* themselves confirmed that rat is a rat.

Then how did Micah tip the law off when he didn't even know about the train robbery. Explain.

[Porkhammer]

I don't remember where I read this, but somebody had a pretty good theory on how Pearson was one of the rats as well.

Personally I don't think John was a rat. Micah was the main culprit.

[in]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย Hex:

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย in:

If Abigail wanted to "protect" her kid then she could've just left the gang and that's it. Why people need to keep coming up with some dumb ideas when R* themselves confirmed that rat is a rat.

Then how did Micah tip the law off when he didn't even know about the train robbery. Explain.

And wo said the law was tipped off to begin with?
If Abigail was ratting for Milton then how come she killed him? If she had any deals with them that's not the brightest choice don't you think.

[Zombits]

are you guys arguing about a video game story ? I just play this game skipping 3/4 cutscenes since there are already animations for skinning animals, grabbing herbs that never ends, fast travel loading. Wish had enough time to folllow that